SmashBoards Roster Evolution (11-1, break)

[SmasherMaster]

Not sure who to vote for.

I going to vote for one of the people who don't have Peach, Zelda and Samus. While many people have choices that are weird early on, this is because they already had Samus, Zelda and/or Peach. So I understand why the weirder female choices were picked.

My vote came between Fortanono, ScatmansWorld25 and YoshiandToad. Mostly because they all lacked Peach.

I spun a random spinner and the loser was Fortanono.

Sorry if I cause you one of you to be voted out.

 

[Fortanono]

DAMN YOU RANDOM SPINNER...

 

[LoneKonWolf]

someone had too take the fall, sadly it ended up being you

 

[SmasherMaster]

DAMN YOU RANDOM SPINNER...

Don't blame the spinner. It's not the spinners fault that Peach was not in your roster.

 

[Fortanono]

Don't blame the spinner. It's not the spinners fault that Peach was not in your roster.

I already had Luigi, and so I decided to put in characters from franchises that have less reps.

 

[Autumn ♫]

Voted for Shortie due to Krystal and Kalos trainer.
Nothing personal, my friend.

 

[Shorts]

I regret nothing.

 

[josh bones]

I regret nothing.

You shouldn't but man to man/woman/giant space turkey, why kalos trainer?

 

[Shorts]

It's a cool idea, and I don't care about cutting a few characters.

 

[josh bones]

Would you have chosen her if this wasn't a round for female though?

 

[Jakor]

Voted for BluePikmin11 because of Prince Sable and Anna. I don't think adding those two this early is a good idea. Also, Prince Sable doesn't seem like a good character choice to me.

 

[Starbound]

I voted for YoshiAndToad. The lack of Peach in his roster is a bold move, but it's such a glaring omission that I can't ignore. Anna was another bold move that makes some sense, and I can accept it much easier than I can accept the lack of Peach. But I still don't think Anna, a recurring side character in Fire Emblem, should be in Smash Bros. before Marth.

I really don't like making this vote as in terms of aesthetics, your roster wins by a mile (or 12).

 

[YoshiandToad]

I voted for YoshiAndToad. The lack of Peach in his roster is a bold move, but it's such a glaring omission that I can't ignore. Anna was another bold move that makes some sense, and I can accept it much easier than I can accept the lack of Peach. But I still don't think Anna, a recurring side character in Fire Emblem, should be in Smash Bros. before Marth.

I really don't like making this vote as in terms of aesthetics, your roster wins by a mile (or 12).

Heh, no worries, that's the point of the game.
The moment someone pointed out I forgot Peach I knew I'd be in trouble. But I'll certainly take the compliment at the end. (If I survive this round I should probably add Peach...unless the round rules prevent it)

Took me a while to finally pick. I almost went for one of the Wii Fit Trainer including Rosters since at this time she seems far too obscure to be included(but hey; I thought that about Smash 4 too). I checked to see if anyone included Rosalina without Peach...no one did.

I decided on Golden Icarus in the end by using this rounds rules.
I don't consider Ice Climbers a female character as such, since Popo is technically the default that you play, with Nana being the playable one in alt colours.
A lot of others did this too, but then adding Yoshi as a female rep just killed it for me.

I love Yoshi to bits and wanna see him on all the rosters, but he is primarily considered male first and foremost.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

I love Yoshi to bits and wanna see him on all the rosters, but he is primarily considered male first and foremost.

actually i'm pretty sure Yoshi (and their entire race) are considered its (genderless)

 

[YoshiandToad]

actually i'm pretty sure Yoshi (and their entire race) are considered its (genderless)

Oh.

Well, still not female then.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Oh.

Well, still not female then.

they aren't,
i'm wondering how he didn't get called on it

 

[Gunla]

they aren't,
i'm wondering how he didn't get called on it

Unless I counted it.

 

[Golden Icarus]

A lot of others did this too, but then adding Yoshi as a female rep just killed it for me.

I love Yoshi to bits and wanna see him on all the rosters, but he is primarily considered male first and foremost.

I did add Dixie Kong originally for being a more obvious female, but since he said he accepted Yoshi I thought, why not. Same goes for the Ice Climbers; I would have added WFT instead, but he said Ice Climbers would count, so I included them instead.

 

[YoshiandToad]

Alright, well that's my reasoning still. Sorry Golden but I gotta vote for someone.

(Although on this note; do Dee's have genders? Is Kirby officially male? Would Ridley count as female because of that one guy saying 'she' when referring to the space dragon? Maybe we should have a round with gender neutral options at some point)

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Alright, well that's my reasoning still. Sorry Golden but I gotta vote for someone.

(Although on this note; do Dee's have genders? Is Kirby officially male? Would Ridley count as female because of that one guy saying 'she' when referring to the space dragon? Maybe we should have a round with gender neutral options at some point)

don't know if dee's have genders, but by canon Kirby and bandana dee are officially male, don't know about ridley, though it'll be odd if it was a she and i'm pretty sure its widely accepted that's its a he

 

[Starbound]

I see four votes, and only one explanation.

I would suggest only counting the votes that were mentioned in the thread, as I am noticing around 20 votes on the poll and way fewer than 20 explanations.

 

[Gunla]

I would suggest only counting the votes that were mentioned in the thread, as I am noticing around 20 votes on the poll and way fewer than 20 explanations.

I'm not sure I'm going to have to do this right now, but I'm really considering removing the polls entirely if people aren't going to give a reason.
Though I might need to have a lightning round if we get a tie this Elimination.

Maybe we should have a round with gender neutral options at some point)

Well then, someone's guessed it.

 

[SmasherMaster]

Instead of a Lightning Round, have both of them stay in till the next round. Not only does the person with the most votes overall get eliminated, but so does the person with the most votes in the tie. (If somebody in the tie has the most votes, then the person with the second most amount of votes get eliminated.)

 

[Gunla]

I likely should have rephrased my thoughts:
What I mean by lightning round is where we SPECIFICALLY vote with those two in 24 hours. I set up a poll with two answers.
Doing what you suggested may work, but get madly complicated. I'll take both into my consideration.

 

[Autumn ♫]

Seems like it's going to be a pretty close match,good luck to both of you Shortie and CrapZapper

 

[Gunla]

Seems like it's going to be a pretty close match,good luck to both of you Shortie and CrapZapper

Fair warning, if we don't get one loser, we're doing a lightning vote.

 

[Autumn ♫]

Fair warning, if we don't get one loser, we're doing a lightning vote.

What if their is a tie during the lightning round?

 

[SmasherMaster]

Then a random person that is not on the site will pick the losing roster

 

[Gunla]

Then a random person that is not on the site will pick the losing roster

That IS what I am planning. Or I could vote.

 

[YoshiandToad]

Head to head lightning round seems inevitable right now.

 

[josh bones]

Head to head lightning round seems inevitable right now.

I get it, because their mice!

 

[SmasherMaster]

I get it, because their mice!

The fact you missed the joke is quite shocking!

 

[Gunla]

Simple Update Tonight. I'll flesh this out later.

@Crap-Zapper was eliminated with 20% of the vote. With 25 votes, that's 5.
Perhaps it was Goose. I liked it, but others didn't. I admire your inputs and efforts.
Shortie was second closest with 4 votes.

Results:
Answer Choices–
Responses–
-Fortanono
4%
1
-Louie G.
0%
0
-GreenReaperGod
0%
0
-Angelglory
0%
0
-BluePikmin11
4%
1
-Tepig2000
0%
0
-ScatmansWorld25
4%
1
-Smasher 101
0%
0
-ThatWasPeachy
4%
1
-Shortiecanbrawl
16%
4
-Crap-Zapper
20%
5
-Kon
16%
4
-GoldenIcarus
12%
3
-jakor
0%
0
-josh bones
0%
0
-SmasherMaster
0%
0
-YoshiandToad
8%
2
-LumaOkami
4%
1
-Keybladeguy
8%
2
Total25

Roster Cap this time is 20. No Special Rules.
Will add rosters later.
Notifications:
@ Fortanono
@Louie G.
@GreenReaperGod
@ Angelglory
@BluePikmin11
@Tepig2000
@ Autumn ♫
@ Starbound
@ Shorts
@Kon
@ Golden Icarus
@ Jakor
@ josh bones
@ SmasherMaster
@ YoshiandToad
@Keybladeguy
@ Smasher 101
@LumaOkami

New Rosters:

Spoiler

Fortanono-

Louie G.-

GreenReaperGod-

Angelglory-

BluePikmin11-

Tepig2000-

ScatmansWorld25-

ThatWasPeachy-

Shortiecanbrawl-

Kon-

Golden Icarus-

Jakor-

josh bones-

SmasherMaster-

YoshiandToad-

Keybladeguy-

Smasher 101-

LumaOkami-

BREAK III BEGINS NOW
YOU HAVE UNTIL SUNDAY EVENING TO SEND IN YOUR 20-SLOT ROSTER.​

 

[josh bones]

The fact you missed the joke is quite shocking!

Their tall mice!

 

[Starbound]

To the guy who voted for me, I'd like to know why.

No restrictions this time, right?

 

[Gunla]

No restrictions this time, right?

Absolutely no restrictions!

 

[Starbound]

My roster.

Added Luigi, Yoshi, Marth and Pit.

 

[Angelglory]

Newcomers: Yoshi, Diddy Kong, Captain Falcon, Little Mac (and a random button for even's sake)

 

[Smasher 101]

Additions: Diddy Kong, Captain Falcon, Olimar, and Little Mac. Also, I added Zero Suit Samus and Sheik to Samus and Zelda.

 

[Gunla]

Added all new rosters!