SmashBoards Roster Evolution (11-1, break)

[Mr_Anderson]

Voted for mr anderson for lack of newer IPs, which ultimately made me think it looked a little dull.

The newer franchise I went for is WarioWare, yo.

Voting artisticgamerxl as well. No DK and three 3rd party too early.

 

[SmasherMaster]

I voted for artisticgamerxl, but for a somewhat different reason. I looked at everybody and decided to vote for the person who had the least amount of series in the orginal smash bros. (Mario, Donkey Kong. Legend Of Zelda, Metroid, Kirby, Star Fox, Pokemon, Yoshi, Mother and F-Zero). artisticgamerxl was missing four of them.

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Voted for @artisticgamerxl for lacking DK and Yoshi and having third parties so early.

 

[Leafeon523]

The biggest risk led to the biggest downfall... sorry @artisticgamerxl

 

[a smart guy]

I voted for SmashRiver64, because of his crazy character mashups. Sakurai has never mashed up Mario and Luigi, and he has never put Pikachu with Pokemon trainer. No thank you.

 

[Tepig2000]

Voted artiticgamerxl. I don't mind the third-party characters, but where's DK?

 

[The_Sheik]

I can't vote because I'm using the same computer as @ Tepig2000 , but I would have voted @artisticgamerxl if I could vote.

 

[TheZombiePig]

Voted for ArtisticGamer. Third parties and whatnot, but not having DK especially. He's probably more recognizable than Megaman, and arguably really close to Sonic on that scale.

 

[Bedoop]

I voted for SmashRiver64, because of his crazy character mashups. Sakurai has never mashed up Mario and Luigi, and he has never put Pikachu with Pokemon trainer. No thank you.

That's the uniqueness of it.

 

[YoshiandToad]

That's the uniqueness of it.

Thanks for reminding me!

I'll start using uniqueness as the main judging factor when we hit round 3 and beyond.

 

[Bedoop]

Thanks for reminding me!

I'll start using uniqueness as the main judging factor when we hit round 3 and beyond.

You're welcome, friend :D

 

[The Light Music Club]

Crap. @ LoneKonWolf I was talking to my Grandpa when I voted. I accidentally selected myself. I meant to vote for artisicgamer because no smash game would have 1/4 third parties. Please don't count one vote that is on my name.

What a way to start the competition. Oh well.

 

[Bedoop]

Crap. @ LoneKonWolf I was talking to my Grandpa when I voted. I accidentally selected myself. I meant to vote for artisicgamer because no smash game would have 1/4 third parties. Please don't count one vote that is on my name.

I've just now noticed how much people have Viridi as their Icon. :|

 

[The Light Music Club]

I've just now noticed how much people have Viridi as their Icon. :|

Haha. Out of all of them, I'm the only one brave enough to put her in my roster (I did it last game and still made top 3)

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Crap. @ LoneKonWolf I was talking to my Grandpa when I voted. I accidentally selected myself. I meant to vote for artisicgamer because no smash game would have 1/4 third parties. Please don't count one vote that is on my name.

What a way to start the competition. Oh well.

Shouldn't really matter anyway, artistic's basically guaranteed to get the boot, given how many votes they got.

 

[Deleted member]

Okay, I'm gonna get this off my chest now, because this has been bugging me since the first few people commented. I understand people here are trying to win, and to save the surprises for later and what not, but I find the "Nintendo would never do this" or the "Why third parties over DK" argument a bit odd. Not to hate on your opinions, but I am fully aware Nintendo would have never actually done this.

When I was reading the rules, they stated you can do whatever you want with your roster, and that you didn't even need Nintendo characters, so when I was looking at the other rosters, I noticed no third parties. Now, I obviously love Smash and I wouldn't be here if I didn't, but when I was making my roster, I thought I would add some the 3rd parties to mix up the game a bit since every roster was so similar, and to say the least, I didn't expect to get so much back lash.

With that being said, know that for the rest of this game, I will be studying the choices the rest of you make. Character for character, change for change, elimination per elimination. And know for the next game, I will be back for a fiery vengeance and crush all of you with the best rosters you've ever seen in your natural born lives, and you will all suffer. *Insert Evil Laugh Here*

Disclaimer: That last paragraph is only meant to be a joke. I don't despise any of you so don't worry. However, I mean it when I say I will be back, and I will win.

 

[Bedoop]

However, I mean it when I say I will be back, and I will win.

(9ewe)9 Ding, Ding.

 

[SmasherMaster]

Okay, I'm gonna get this off my chest now, because this has been bugging me since the first few people commented. I understand people here are trying to win, and to save the surprises for later and what not, but I find the "Nintendo would never do this" or the "Why third parties over DK" argument a bit odd. Not to hate on your opinions, but I am fully aware Nintendo would have never actually done this.

When I was reading the rules, they stated you can do whatever you want with your roster, and that you didn't even need Nintendo characters, so when I was looking at the other rosters, I noticed no third parties. Now, I obviously love Smash and I wouldn't be here if I didn't, but when I was making my roster, I thought I would add some the 3rd parties to mix up the game a bit since every roster was so similar, and to say the least, I didn't expect to get so much back lash.

With that being said, know that for the rest of this game, I will be studying the choices the rest of you make. Character for character, change for change, elimination per elimination. And know for the next game, I will be back for a fiery vengeance and crush all of you with the best rosters you've ever seen in your natural born lives, and you will all suffer. *Insert Evil Laugh Here*

Disclaimer: That last paragraph is only meant to be a joke. I don't despise any of you so don't worry. However, I mean it when I say I will be back, and I will win.

Isn't the biggest difference in votes. Pretty sure that somebody once got all the votes because they did not include Mario.

 

[pupNapoleon]

I almost put super Mario on my list instead

but no one cares how the characters function, its a visual thing

 

[LoneKonWolf]

@artisticgamerxl was voted off by almost 3/4's of the votes,
tricky thing about this game is that while people value uniqueness, make an unrealistic move early and your out, sorry mate, at least I award you the SWFRE consolation prize for at least entering (which is more than you might think since only 3rd and higher gets anything)
anywho we start off with the first of the "special rules" since the first round was designed to not base the original roster of 64, i'm going to push that a bit more,
you can not add any smash 64 veterans for this round and future ones till the rule ends
1 one down, 20 to go, 16 slots, good luck mates

oh and ya, not going to be posting any music for awhile, i'm on vacation with the family, play your own or whatever to make due
[collapse=vote count]

• Sunnydust 0 (0%)

• The Light Music Club 1 (4.17%)

• SmasherMaster 0 (0%)

• The Zombie PIg 1 (4.17%)

• Angelglory 0 (0%)

• DukeNapoleon 2 (8.33%)

• Tepig2000 0 (0%)

• The_Sheik 0 (0%)

• kylexv 0 (0%)

• TORNADO BUS DRIVER 0 (0%)

• a smart guy 0 (0%)

• Golden Icarus 0 (0%)

• YoshiandToad 0 (0%)

• LumaOkami 0 (0%)

• Mr_Anderson 1 (4.17%)

• domokl 0 (0%)

• BlueDrago 0 (0%)

• artisticgamerxl 17 (70.80%)

• SmashRiver64 2 (8.33%)

• Yams 0 (0%)

• KingShadow 0 (0%)

[/collapse]
[collapse=players]
@ SunnyDust
@ The Light Music Club
@ SmasherMaster
@ TheZombiePig
@ Angelglory
@ pupNapoleon
@ Tepig2000
@ The_Sheik
@kylexv
@ TORNADO BUS DRIVER
@ a smart guy
@ Golden Icarus
@ YoshiandToad
@LumaOkami
@ Mr_Anderson
@ domokl
@ B BlueDrago
@ Bedoop
@ Yams
@ Depressed Gengar
[/collapse]
[collapse=rosters]
The Light Music Club -

SunnyDust -

Mr_Anderson -

SmashRiver64 -

Yams -

TheZombiePig -

domokl -

Angelglory -

BlueDrago -

TORNADO BUS DRIVER -

SmasherMaster -

Tepig2000 -

The_Sheik -

kylexv -

YoshiandToad -

Golden Icarus -

DukeNapoleon -

KingShadow -

a smart guy -

[/collapse]

we'll start up on Sunday 10 pm. eastern time zone (guaranteed!)​

 

[Bedoop]

Wait, so, what do we do? Make a Roster of 12 with no Smash 64 Veterans?

 

[The Light Music Club]

Wait, so, what do we do? Make a Roster of 12 with no Smash 64 Veterans?

No I think it's a roster of 16. You can't add any Smash 64 characters that you didn't have last round. So since I didn't have Ness last round, I can't add him until the rule is lifted.

 

[Bedoop]

No I think it's a roster of 16. You can't add any Smash 64 characters that you didn't have last round. So since I didn't have Ness last round, I can't add him until the rule is lifted.

Okie dokie.

 

[The Light Music Club]

Oh @ LoneKonWolf can I add ZSS to Samus this round? Or no? I forget how that works.

Added: Mr. Game and Watch, Zelda + Shiek, Little Mac, Wario, and ZSS to Samus
Series: Mario, Donkey Kong, Yoshi, Warioware, Metriod, Fire Emblem, Game and Watch, Kid Icarus, Zelda, Kirby, Starfox, Pokemon, Punch Out! (Total 13 series)

Was thinking of adding Villager.

Will add Luigi, C. Falcon, and Ness soon. Originality will start to show next round. (Donbe and Hikari??)

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Oh @ LoneKonWolf can I add ZSS to Samus this round? Or no? I forget how that works.

you can add to existing slots,
just the main slot can't be added if its not allowed to, (i.e. you couldn't add samus this round if she wasn't on it before, but you can modify the existing slot to include ZSS)

 

[SunnyDust]

Added Bowser, Mewtwo, Mr. Game & Watch and Villager.
Total series : 14

 

[Mr_Anderson]

Alright, here it is.

Added Characters:
Bowser (Mario)
Pig Ganon (Legend of Zelda)
ROB (ROB)
Olimar (Pikmin)

 

[Bedoop]

http://i.imgur.com/qpULWN8.png

I call this is the Retro Pack, which focuses on the NES-SNES-N64 Era of Games.

For the NES Era, we have Mega Man, since he was the King of the NES. Mega Man 2 is 2 Good. Plus during that time Mega Man was Nintendo exclusive.

SNES Era gets Bowser and King K. Rool, the reason Bowser is in the SNES Era is because of Super Mario World, and how awesome he was during then. Also I added King K. Rool because he has so much potential, even in the SNES Days. (SupportKingK.RoolforSmash4Today)

I was debating wiether to add Zelda/Shiek or Ganondorf for the N64 Era, but ultimately I decided for Zelda/Shiek, not only to balance the Hero/Villian ratio for this part, but because Zelda is a more Unique Fighter.

ALSO, the only reason I didn't want to add more New Series' other than Mega Man is not because I wanted to be safe, but I wanted the more Popular series to have more Reps this time around, since Pokemon technically got 3 in the first batch.
I hope you understand where I'm coming from.

HONORABLE MENTIONS:

• Captain Falcon (it pains me that the no 64 Vets past what I added rule was applied, but I have to go with it)
• Little Mac (Didn't seem in top priority in my mind at the time, sorry to all you Mac Fans, me being one of you.)
  
• Pac-Man (I didn't want to risk it, that's basically my excuse.)

 

[Yams]

Continuing with my theme of Nintendo All-Stars, each character represents their own series.

NOTES:
-I think it's somewhat important to mention how Mario Bros. work, and it's not like Ice Climbers or Zelda/Sheik. One Bro will act as the "Popo" and will lead the way, while the other Bro will follow behind but not fight. When you taunt, the leading Bro. switches out, so when you're playing as Mario and taunt, you will switch to Luigi. Each has a full moveset.
-Ness would have been added instead of Game and Watch, had it not been for the "no N64 character" rule. He'll be added as soon as the rule is lifted.

 

[TheZombiePig]

Olimar: Get a post-2000 franchise in here.
Bowser, Ganon, and Mewtwo: yay villains!

 

[Bedoop]

Continuing with my theme of Nintendo All-Stars, each character represents their own series.

NOTES:
-I think it's somewhat important to mention how Mario Bros. work, and it's not like Ice Climbers or Zelda/Sheik. One Bro will act as the "Popo" and will lead the way, while the other Bro will follow behind but not fight. When you taunt, the leading Bro. switches out, so when you're playing as Mario and taunt, you will switch to Luigi. Each has a full moveset.
-Ness would have been added instead of Game and Watch, had it not been for the "no N64 character" rule. He'll be added as soon as the rule is lifted.

That's actually how I originally wanted my version of Mario Bros. to work, but I thought it would be too crazy for the first round.
'Til Ice Climbers do we Part.

 

[domokl]

I have added Bowser Charizard Little Mac and Zelda this round.

 

[Angelglory]

Newcomers: Bowser, Little Mac, Pit, Charizard
New Series: Punch Out!, Kid Icarus
Total Series: 14

 

[BlueDrago]

New characters: Peach, Zelda, Ice Climbers, Olimar.

 

[Golden Icarus]

I don't have access to my computer right now so could someone please be kind enough to make the roster for me?
Here's the characters I want in this layout:

Mario, Bowser, DK, Wario, Mr. GW, Pit
Link, Samus, Marth, Kirby, Fox, C. Falcon
Pikachu, Villager, Olimar, Shulk​

Hopefully this will be the only time I have to do this, but I just can't get it ready before the deadline. Sorry, and thanks in advance!

 

[YoshiandToad]

you can not add any smash 64 veterans for this round and future ones till the rule ends

FOX IT ALL.

Going to have to change my initial plan. Also Ness isn't eligible for me, but I can live with this. And Jigglypuff, but I'm actively pleased about that.

 

[TORNADO BUS DRIVER]

there we go
Added:
Wario
Zelda/Sheik
Mewtwo
Little Mac

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Dang, was going to add Falcon this round. Going to get him in the instant this rule is lifted. Anywho...

Spoiler

Peach Blossoms!
Zelda Teleports in!
Marth Slashes through the Fray!
Mr. Game and Watch Rings the Bell!
Layout below:
Top Row: Mario, Pikachu, Link, DK
2nd to Top: Bowser, Lucario, Zelda, Kirby
3rd to Top: Peach, Samus, Yoshi, Fox
Bottom Row: Marth, Villager, Olimar, Mr. GaW
Honorable mentions:
Ganondorf (Was going to have him over Zelda, but I decided to play it safer this time around)
Diddy (Opted not to give any series outside the Big 3
more characters yet)
Dedede (See Diddy)
Wario (Coin flip between him and Marth)
Falcon (Rules)
R.O.B. (Coin flip between it and Mr. GaW)

 

[pupNapoleon]

I, too, have sent my computer in for repairs. THREE in a row, eh? if this takes me out of the competition as I've only got my phone for the next week or so, Blessed be to all.

But if not, my roster would be
Mario, Pokemon Trainer, Kirby, Dk, Yoshi, fox, Samus, Marth, Olimar, game and watch, villager, link

Pikachu, then Kanto started off to the side, and zss,
newcomers pit, little mac, Lucas, balloon fighter alicee(bf regular. If she isn't on it)

I'll make a few for others when mines back if I get that far

 

[SmasherMaster]

Newcomers: Bowser, Little Mac, Olimar and Mr. Game + Watch

Bowser: I wanted at least one villain. Plus, if any series was to have another character at this point, it would be Mario.
Little Mac: Long running popular series.
Olimar: Newer but still popular series with multiple installments.
Mr Game and Watch: I wanted a historical retro.

Honorable Mentions:
Luigi, Zelda, Mewtwo, Villager, Wario

Total Series: 15 (Mario, Donkey Kong, Legend Of Zelda, Metroid, Yoshi, Kirby, Star Fox, Pokemon, F-Zero, Mother, Fire Emblem, Kid Icarus, Punch Out, Pikmin, Game and Watch)