Shiny's Mario Mafia - Game Over! Town + FireEmbleminer Victory!

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

So you're claiming to be Shrek in a Mario-themed game? :V

No, but it would be ****ing hilarious if that was the case

And odds were good I would end up being a character I like since it's Mario-themed, so not that big of a deal.

True, but it's the one you're the biggest fan of, afaik.

But hey, it's only a character claim, so big whoop.

 

[Deleted member]

No, but it would be ****ing hilarious if that was the case


True, but it's the one you're the biggest fan of, afaik.

But hey, it's only a character claim, so big whoop.

As long as there aren't any other Wario claims, I think we're good.

 

[Ura]

Can someone catch me up to speed on this thread?

 

[Fire Emblemier]

One major thing happened. AmericaDJ did something scummy ie voting the same things as Natz was, me, natz, and soup reacted and he roleclaimed as the town toad tracker

 

[Fire Emblemier]

The rest is either ****posting or Dgamers and NZoners compare and contrasting.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Vote: AmericanDJ

You better talk, DJ

 

[Natz~]

Vote: AmericanDJ

You better talk, DJ

....um...why did you do that?

 

[Natz~]

....um...why did you do that?

also uni if i can say something else...you were the only other person who followed me for the no lynch just kinda out of the blue...

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

....um...why did you do that?

The way he's acting is just weird, so I'm doing a pressure vote.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

also uni if i can say something else...you were the only other person who followed me for the no lynch just kinda out of the blue...

I always No Lynch on day 1 until something happens.

 

[Natz~]

The way he's acting is just weird, so I'm doing a pressure vote.

I always No Lynch on day 1 until something happens.

alright alright

i agree hes acting weird and should answer

 

[Fire Emblemier]

So for the NZoners here, do you guys typically have a fake claim for scum in your games?

 

[Fire Emblemier]

I'm wondering cause I'm trying to see how reasonable it is that DJ is using a fakeclaim role or not.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

So for the NZoners here, do you guys typically have a fake claim for scum in your games?

We don't. It's usually the scums themselves who have to come up with stuff.

 

[Natz~]

So for the NZoners here, do you guys typically have a fake claim for scum in your games?

depends on the host tbh

some throw it up in the air and let you deal with it, which can be a hassle, i remember my mafia buddies have an agonizing time coming up with fake claims (i just did bowser as i was actually mario and i realized there was no two same representive tehre so it was safe)

others make it so you don't need a fake claim, like this game where the scum could be any character of the mushroom kingdom, same thing for capcom mafia as well where the mafia was morgan, frank west, zero, spencer, and ****ing chris redfield

it just depends on the host

 

[Natz~]

I'm wondering cause I'm trying to see how reasonable it is that DJ is using a fakeclaim role or not.

oh i can tell you this, shiny and polly confirmed before the game begun theres no fake claims here

so theres little need to fake claim your favor, though there could be a situation needed

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Ok that makes me think DJ is more likely town. I feel as if unikorn's vote is unnecessary, due to this. Why put pressure on a likely townslot like that? All it does waste a vote

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Ok that makes me think DJ is more likely town. I feel as if unikorn's vote is unnecessary, due to this. Why put pressure on a likely townslot like that? All it does waste a vote

Not like we have anywhere else to waste it on.

Besides, I said it's a pressure vote. Once he explains himself, I'll take it off.

 

[Maven89]

Why is everyone ignoring Bardull?

 

[BarDulL]

And Nabe's butt doesn't go against any global rules?

For clarity's sake, Nabe's avatar can be considered suggestive but can not be appropriately classified as pornography; this has been the prevailing sentiment towards his avatars for years.

In other words, Nabe is either a master of walking a fine line, we're all naughty minded, or it really is just a turtle. LOL
---------------------

Anywho, I'm back from taking a break. It appears Kary's case momentum died out a bit. I definitely wasn't sure if I was going to live through that one (granted I wouldn't have technically died because the day ends at a specific deadline).

Tidbits:

I'm really excited for Fire Emblemier 's recent gameplay as well as Natz~ .

DJ's claim absolutely reads to me as genuine, so it sucks that we have an outed Tracker; his method feels very unassisted and totally unplanned, and since it seems there are a lack of safe claims, it is very likely he is telling the truth. However that is just one extra person we know we can safely avoid when trying to figure out who the scum are.

AmericanDJ hey dude, it's totally cool and I get you. I've been there before where the pressure is on...believe me, the pressure that was just on me was intense. Scorching flames. Don't give up and keep on trying to figure out who the mafia are.

Kary's case reads to me as null. Their actions were pro-town, I think, albeit I will have to pry deeper to make a proper assessment. Ergo Spak , I will answer their case.

Maven seems...opportunistic. I am concerned for where this slot's head is at, but I am open to discourse at this juncture. Why do I feel that he is not his normal scum hunting self?

Not like we have anywhere else to waste it on.

Besides, I said it's a pressure vote. Once he explains himself, I'll take it off.

Hrmmmmmmmm.

 

[Deleted member]

Not Voting: Lampy

Vote: Maven
The fact he was so eager to start the game seems somewhat suspicious to me.

What were you saying?

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

In other words, Nabe is either a master of walking a fine line, we're all naughty minded, or it really is just a turtle. LOL

Why not all three at once?

DJ's claim absolutely reads to me as genuine, so it sucks that we have an outed Tracker; his method feels very unassisted and totally unplanned, and since it seems there are a lack of safe claims, it is very likely he is telling the truth. However that is just one extra person we know we can safely avoid when trying to figure out who the scum are.

Huh... I know I said I'd wait until he explains himself, but this makes a lot of sense.

I don't wanna break my word though, so my pressure vote stays until he shares some stuff... or before the day ends. Whichever happens first.

However, if he ends up mafia, I'll be pointing fingers at you.

 

[BarDulL]

Kary's case predominantly highlights a clash of ideologies.

Kary is more or less making a claim that no town player would suggest to lynch themselves because it's just plain stupid; "a townie should be trying to keep themselves alive while attempting to find scum". They are, in turn, suggesting that I am trying to make myself look good with no follow-up.

However, this is where Kary and I differentiate in terms of ideological play. While Kary believes that self-preservation is ideal and the most sensible in mafia, I believe that, sometimes, sacrifices must be made to progress the game, and I will do it at any cost when it is clear that the game is at a standstill. I will forego my sociopolitical standing if it means breaking open the story and narrowing down the avenues of approach. I will inevitably become a magnet, but that magnet will draw actions, stances, and opinions from other players, and will bring us closer to discovering who the Mafia are.

I understand that, sometimes, a price must be paid to achieve results in Mafia. If I must make sacrifices, then I will willingly do it if it means we are closer to securing the win.

That is how I play Mafia.

Much of the crowd was not getting their hands dirty and did not want to vote. This is not exclusive to a particular group, just a generality in our midst.

With no content being produced and no major actions being taken, I took it into my own hands and riled some people up. In turn, a lot of content was generated, and votes were placed. Scrutiny was applied. Things are now a lot less foggy.

I won't say that what Kary suggests is impossible, but believe what you will. It's up to you all to decide what the more likely scenario is and act accordingly.

Kary tries to reinforce the scumDulL perspective by stating that I am not aware of who all the players are based on my mistake that I thought Shish was in the game. From a third eye, I feel that this is a reasonable mistake to make with 19 players in the game and Shish posting at least once in it recently.

 

[BarDulL]

However, if he ends up mafia, I'll be pointing fingers at you.

Interesting. So you feel that DJ's vote on me was a potential bus?

 

[Natz~]

bardul uses so many big and complicated words everything he says goes over my head @~@

 

[Natz~]

For clarity's sake, Nabe's avatar can be considered suggestive but can not be appropriately classified as pornography; this has been the prevailing sentiment towards his avatars for years.

In other words, Nabe is either a master of walking a fine line, we're all naughty minded, or it really is just a turtle. LOL
---------------------

all i see is ass

so probably the second with a strong emphasis on the first

 

[BarDulL]

I attribute most of my vernacular to reading pseudo-intellectual **** posts.

 

[Natz~]

 

[BarDulL]

Current players I think are a tad suspicious at the moment:

Unikorn
Maven

Players I think should live for now:

Nabe
Soup
Kary
Natz
Fire Emblem
AmericanDJ
Vaanrose

Players I am interested in hearing more from:

Lampy
Dark Horse
Spak
Golden
Swampasaurus

Players that are currently traversing the void:

Ura
Yellowlord
Coricus

Pokechu:
Pokechu

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Swampasaurus

I don't talk to people who can't spell my name.

 

[BarDulL]

I don't talk to people who can't spell my name.

You don't have to talk to me if you don't want to, just know that disrespect was not intended...weren't you recently named Swampasaur or something like that? I forgot and it's late

Still, we don't really have much from you, so I'm sure most of us are curious to know what your thoughts are on the rest of the roster. That's all.

 

[Natz~]

i'm kinda good for now

as katt head is kinda still spinning in circles and not understanding anything in the past 2 hours

 

[Natz~]

katt doesn't really want more that she can't understand on her plate

 

[vaanrose]

Hmmm, yes. Shallow and pedantic.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

What you have to understand is that everyone is frustrated by Day 1 going in circles.
No-one else is going 'haha guys maybe you should vote for me'
'haha guys maybe you should vote for this other guy I haven't explained my vote on'

There are much better ways of finding suspicious players than doing this horseradish

 

[Coricus]

Current players I think are a tad suspicious at the moment:

Unikorn
Maven

Players I think should live for now:

Nabe
Soup
Kary
Natz
Fire Emblem
AmericanDJ
Vaanrose

Players I am interested in hearing more from:

Lampy
Dark Horse
Spak
Golden
Swampasaurus

Players that are currently traversing the void:

Ura
Yellowlord
Coricus

Pokechu:
Pokechu

I think I'm still not entirely used to visiting an actual thread for these games. I'll go read through and see what's going down. I can only hope I can actually sort out what on earth is going on for once, LOL.

Also LUL Pokechu getting his own category.

 

[Coricus]

Also Ura Yellowlord you two might waanna get in here too. I'm not sure how much I sorted from my browsing before I gave up, but clearly the DG crowd is keeping better track than I am and we need everyone to show for due process to kick in. Granted I'm saying this but I'm still not entirely sure what to do with myself other than just waatch. . .

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Interesting. So you feel that DJ's vote on me was a potential bus?

I’m... honestly not sure what to think...

Then again, DJ wouldn’t vote for a fellow scum on Day 1, of all times...

Alright, still gonna wait for explanations, but all this stuff pleases me enough to take off the pressure vote.

Unvote

But I’m still suspicious.

FoS: AmericanDJ

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

EBWOP:

Then again, DJ wouldn’t vote for a fellow scum on Day 1, of all times...

Unless this is just a mindgame. Sounds utterly insane for a Day 1 shenanigan, but I’d rather assume every single possibility, y’know?

 

[Maven89]

I think Americans DJ is honest about his claim, and I find it suspicious anyone would vote for him

Kary's case predominantly highlights a clash of ideologies.

Kary is more or less making a claim that no town player would suggest to lynch themselves because it's just plain stupid; "a townie should be trying to keep themselves alive while attempting to find scum". They are, in turn, suggesting that I am trying to make myself look good with no follow-up.

However, this is where Kary and I differentiate in terms of ideological play. While Kary believes that self-preservation is ideal and the most sensible in mafia, I believe that, sometimes, sacrifices must be made to progress the game, and I will do it at any cost when it is clear that the game is at a standstill. I will forego my sociopolitical standing if it means breaking open the story and narrowing down the avenues of approach. I will inevitably become a magnet, but that magnet will draw actions, stances, and opinions from other players, and will bring us closer to discovering who the Mafia are.

I understand that, sometimes, a price must be paid to achieve results in Mafia. If I must make sacrifices, then I will willingly do it if it means we are closer to securing the win.

That is how I play Mafia.

Much of the crowd was not getting their hands dirty and did not want to vote. This is not exclusive to a particular group, just a generality in our midst.

With no content being produced and no major actions being taken, I took it into my own hands and riled some people up. In turn, a lot of content was generated, and votes were placed. Scrutiny was applied. Things are now a lot less foggy.

I won't say that what Kary suggests is impossible, but believe what you will. It's up to you all to decide what the more likely scenario is and act accordingly.

Kary tries to reinforce the scumDulL perspective by stating that I am not aware of who all the players are based on my mistake that I thought Shish was in the game. From a third eye, I feel that this is a reasonable mistake to make with 19 players in the game and Shish posting at least once in it recently.