Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[Chandeelure]

So...who wants to talk about Bandana Dee? XD

 

[Starcutter]

has anyone read through my post regarding kamek yet?

 

[Hotfeet444]

So... no more Krystal?

I still support Krystal soooooo...

Spoiler

Yush.

 

[Reznor]

well I missed the Krystal argument ............ anyways
I no longer hate Krystal (for reasons that don't make the most sense) but I still think we don't need a 4th Starfox rep
if Falco or Wolf get cut Krystal is an ok option
but I will always hate Geno

 

[BluePikmin11]

Ah, but It seems like you were the one who changed.

I mean no harm to anyone.

 

[Cpt.]

So...who wants to talk about Bandana Dee? XD

I'm down to hear some reason why he should make the roster.

 

[TopTierPichu]

I'm down to hear some reason why he should make the roster.

fourth character from return to dreamland, still pretty important in triple deluxe

 

[Bowserlick]

I really hope Sakurai thinks about releasing more characters after the game is complete.

 

[Starcutter]

I still support Krystal soooooo...

Spoiler

View attachment 7438

Spoiler

Yush.

that makes her look like a bobcat or something, well, minus the tail. bubsy's long lost cousin?



EDIT: you drew that yourself, didn't you? it looks really good, and I mean no offence to it, it was just a joke.

 

[Bowserlick]

Krystal should be a crystal and not a fox.

 

[HylianHeroBigBoss]

has anyone read through my post regarding kamek yet?

Yeah, but honestly kamek would feel like one of those inclusions for sole reason of "this series needs more reps, and that's the best they got". I don't see sakurai looking for newcomers in that way unless they really truly stand out, especially for a character that could be seen as a normal enemy in other games.

 

[?????????????]

So...who wants to talk about Bandana Dee? XD

B: Spear Barrage
B>: Multispear
B^: Spear Copter
Bv: Moon Drop

 

[Hotfeet444]

that makes her look like a bobcat or something, well, minus the tail. bubsy's long lost cousin?



EDIT: you drew that yourself, didn't you? it looks really good, and I mean no offence to it, it was just a joke.

Yes, I drew it meself, and it's okay, I don't mind some feedback like that since when it comes to detailing fur, I always go a little overboard. And what was it that made her look like a bobcat....it was the poofy face and fanged smile wasn't it?

 

[BluePikmin11]

I really hope Sakurai thinks about releasing more characters after the game is complete.

I hope we get them, but personally I think clones and past Melee (and Brawl if cut) veterans will be DLC.

 

[Bowserlick]

Bandana Dee, Krystal, Little Mac, Chrom... what good ways to ruin a roster.

 

[Louie G.]

Guys, sorry to go off-topic again, but I think that @SaturnGamer64 is really angry/upset about what happened about half an hour ago.
I know that his arguments may not be ideal, or he may come across as mean or offensive, but Saturn's my friend and I should have stood up for him back there.
There are more people like him here that don't get the hate he does. I don't understand why everyone ganged up on him like that, since it's basically just another argument on the RPD, and really it should have been treated as such.
Whether Krystal will make it or not shouldn't do this to us. We're all Smash fans, and Smash Bros is a game that should bring us together, not tear us apart and start wars.
Thanks for listening to my speech.

 

[Chandeelure]

I'm down to hear some reason why he should make the roster.

-Because he would be the first spear user in Smash Bros. (adds something new to the game)
-Moveset potential.
-He is now one of the main characters and a staple in the Kirby series.
-Pretty requested, specially in Japan.
-Kirby is one of the best and most popular Nintendo franchises.

 

[Gune]

I'm down to hear some reason why he should make the roster.

He has a spear nuff said.

 

[Luigi#1]

So...who wants to talk about Bandana Dee? XD

He would make a good character. Easy to come up with move set, is in a series that doesn't have enough reps for it's popularity. Fan favorite. I support him.

 

[?????????????]

Bandana Dee, Krystal, Little Mac, Chrom... what good ways to ruin a roster.

They have enough going for them. And plenty of significance.

 

[Sharkarat]

I'm not going to show respect to someone who refuses to show it to anyone else and cause hours upon hours of our time to be wasted because of his own ignorance. We don't hate him because of what he says, it's the inflection in which they're said. It's simple to disagree and try to keep positive, as the main answer is "Agree to disagree" and "Both are possible", not "I'm right, listen to what I have to say NOW."

Anyways, I still support Krystal regardless of this trainwreck of an afternoon.

I'm not defending him. I was mostly targeting the kind of comments that add little to the discussion and mostly seems like jabs at Saturn. I don't care what you think about him, but I just think those comments just makes it worse and are therefor very unnecessary.

 

[Xhampi]

has anyone read through my post regarding kamek yet?

Not a fan of Kamek, he is only one of three antagonist of the Yoshi series and one of them (Bowser) is already playable.

 

[Louie G.]

Bandana Dee, Krystal, Little Mac, Chrom... what good ways to ruin a roster.

Little Mac ruining a roster?
That doesn't compute.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Guys, sorry to go off-topic again, but I think that @SaturnGamer64 is really angry/upset about what happened about half an hour ago.
I know that his arguments may not be ideal, or he may come across as mean or offensive, but Saturn's my friend and I should have stood up for him back there.
There are more people like him here that don't get the hate he does. I don't understand why everyone ganged up on him like that, since it's basically just another argument on the RPD, and really it should have been treated as such.
Whether Krystal will make it or not shouldn't do this to us. We're all Smash fans, and Smash Bros is a game that should bring us together, not tear us apart and start wars.
Thanks for listening to my speech.

Dude, you're trying to reason with Smashboards. You haven't even tackled IGN or GameFaq's and you're trying to redeem this place. I appreciate the effort. But, no.

 

[Autumn ♫]

Goooood Afternoon everyone, hope you are all doing well today. If I may ask, what's going on, because as usual we have multiple topics going on apparently and I can't tell which is which.

 

[Hotfeet444]

Guys, sorry to go off-topic again, but I think that @SaturnGamer64 is really angry/upset about what happened about half an hour ago.
I know that his arguments may not be ideal, or he may come across as mean or offensive, but Saturn's my friend and I should have stood up for him back there.
There are more people like him here that don't get the hate he does. I don't understand why everyone ganged up on him like that, since it's basically just another argument on the RPD, and really it should have been treated as such.
Whether Krystal will make it or not shouldn't do this to us. We're all Smash fans, and Smash Bros is a game that should bring us together, not tear us apart and start wars.
Thanks for listening to my speech.

Again, he was the one that caused the problem by forcing his opinion in our faces and not accepting other possibilities. Also, we didn't start a war, and we weren't fighting with arrows, spears and swords (Hellsing song reference FTW), all we did was state our own side and he refused to accept the fact that we thought differently, which led to HOURS lost. I am partially to blame as it was my roster that brought up the problem, but I'm not sorry for what I've said or what I've done, as I've done nothing but show my support for a character. You say we should be brought together, yet you're defending the one who's literally known for driving a wedge between our connections through speculation.

Goooood Afternoon everyone, hope you are all doing well today. If I may ask, what's going on, because as usual we have multiple topics going on apparently and I can't tell which is which.

Supporting Krystal is a cruel mistress.

 

[Reznor]

Dude, you're trying to reason with Smashboards. You haven't even tackled IGN or GameFaq's and you're trying to redeem this place. I appreciate the effort. But, no.

wait do you mean IGN and GameFaqs are good or bad i'm a bit lost

Goooood Afternoon everyone, hope you are all doing well today. If I may ask, what's going on, because as usual we have multiple topics going on apparently and I can't tell which is which.

I think there was an argument about Krystal and something else

 

[Chandeelure]

-Because he would be the first spear user in Smash Bros. (adds something new to the game)
-Moveset potential.
-He is now one of the main characters and a staple in the Kirby series.
-Pretty requested, specially in Japan.
-Kirby is one of the best and most popular Nintendo franchises.

I forgot to say
- His model is similar to Kirby's model, so he would not be that hard to develop.

Bandana Dee, Krystal, Little Mac, Chrom... what good ways to ruin a roster.

Good way to make an enemy

 

[Bowserlick]

Little Mac might be one of the most boring characters.

A popular argument for his inclusion is that he would be a contrast to the exciting fighters. Wow.

 

[Sharkarat]

Dude, you're trying to reason with Smashboards. You haven't even tackled IGN or GameFaq's and you're trying to redeem this place. I appreciate the effort. But, no.

But Seriously, if you don't want people to dislike you, stop with these comments where you insults smashboards as a community.

 

[andimidna]

View attachment 7435
So I made a few adjustments to my roster. Nothing too big, but whatever. Keep in mind that this is a DREAM roster, and I don't expect a lot of these characters.
Anyway:

Replaced Tetra with Tingle.
Made Chrom a Chrom and Lucina duo.
Replaced Glover with Cubivore.
Prettier icons

Feel free to critique it though.

Why did you replace Tetra with Tingle?!

 

[_fiercedeity]

Bandana Dee definitely has my support.

 

[kingmario92]

Dude, you're trying to reason with Smashboards. You haven't even tackled IGN or GameFaq's and you're trying to redeem this place. I appreciate the effort. But, no.

Noah, here's a question. Why do you hang out here if you think so poorly of this site

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Goooood Afternoon everyone, hope you are all doing well today. If I may ask, what's going on, because as usual we have multiple topics going on apparently and I can't tell which is which.

I proved that every character that's ever shared major similarities with another and was physically capable of performing their moves is how they become clones. Users got upset. Then this happened:

 

[Reznor]

Little Mac might be one of the most boring characters.

A popular argument for his inclusion is that he would be a contrast to the exciting fighters. Wow.

I usually keep my mouth shut about Little Mac but ya I kinda agree with you
all he does is punch right?

 

[Louie G.]

Little Mac might be one of the most boring characters.

A popular argument for his inclusion is that he would be a contrast to the exciting fighters. Wow.

He doesn't RUIN a roster though. He's a good choice because he is an iconic Nintendo character from an unrepresented franchise that recently got a reboot.
Little Mac deserves a spot this time around more than almost anyone else.

 

[Luigi#1]

Toad, Mii, Pac Man,... what good ways to ruin a roster.

Fixed.

 

[shrooby]

has anyone read through my post regarding kamek yet?

Kamek's a pretty cool dude.
I think it's arguable whether Kamek as a character has earned his inclusion, but I think his potential to be a unique character makes up for that. For me at least.

And what HylianHero said. It seems like Kamek is more garnering support from the fact that he's part of the Yoshi series than because he's Kamek, if you know what I mean.
Even with characters like Ridley, K. Rool/Dixie, or Goroh, for me, I don't support them because the franchises they hale from don't have that many characters. That's not enough for me. I think that the characters themselves, not just the series, have earned the spot.
Heck, that's almost the sole reason I support Ridley so much, and it's the reason I don't wish for Hades over Palutena.

 

[Will]

I forgot to say
- His model is similar to Kirby's model, so he would not be that hard to develop.

OR,if King Dedede still uses Waddle Dees,they can just slap a bandana and a spear and BAM. Instant Newcomer. It's like you're adding a halloween costume to it.

 

[Scoliosis Jones]

Dude, you're trying to reason with Smashboards. You haven't even tackled IGN or GameFaq's and you're trying to redeem this place. I appreciate the effort. But, no.

Just stop Noah. Please.