Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

????????????? · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
I would be inclined to agree, but then again... what if it is ROB? Ignore my own personal bias, I just don't think he will spark any creative discussion.

Maybe not. But it'd be fun for showing off to people who are against ROB.

Morbi · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

Why is Jigglypuff off of the roster and by the Random icon? That seems disrespectful.

TumblrFamous · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
I would be inclined to agree, but then again... what if it is ROB? Ignore my own personal bias, I just don't think he will spark any creative discussion.

Are you kidding? I'd be thrilled if ROB was next.

Lonekon, I like the roster. I would be content if that was the final roster.

????????????? · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

Two minor things that bug me:

Pokemon having more characters than Mario.

Kid Icarus having more characters than Metroid.

Small things that don't make a huge difference. Looks great regardless.

Espio264 · Nov 3, 2013

I wonder how development time for G&W compares to any other character? He's gotta be done by now right? Even if they've updated him in some way. How easy would it be just to give him to us now? And wouldn't the hype be relatively well received considering he's always been one of the last reveals?

Morbi · Nov 3, 2013

pizzadudemanguy said:
Two minor things that bug me:

Pokemon having more characters than Mario.

Kid Icarus having more characters than Metroid.

Small things that don't make a huge difference. Looks great regardless.

You are looking at the roster "representative based" as opposed to "character based". It actually isn't too odd in my opinion. The only thing odd is how he treats Jigglypuff.

????????????? · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
You are looking at the roster "representative based" as opposed to "character based".

I am. I know I am.

I think it's a minor point, but still enough for me to care.

Espio264 · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

That's the finest roster I've seen since my mirror got grease on it!
It looks just like mine, except I have Ridley and Toad. It's pretty.

Morbi · Nov 3, 2013

Espio264 said:
That's the finest roster I've seen since my mirror got grease on it!
It looks just like mine, except I have Ridley and Toad. It's pretty.

Did you also cast Jigglypuff off of the roster by the Random slot? Did you do that too? Huh?!

LoneKonWolf · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
Why is Jigglypuff off of the roster and by the Random icon? That seems disrespectful.

~~because she is a goddess, and needs to be treated as such, that is her throne~~
I just merely ran out of room so I just put her right next to the random spot, sorry if it does bother ya, I can't really change it

pizzadudemanguy said:
Two minor things that bug me:

Pokemon having more characters than Mario.

Kid Icarus having more characters than Metroid.

Small things that don't make a huge difference. Looks great regardless.

I don't see any Mario rep as likely, so I didn't add any

its just that mewtwo just seems inevitable so that is why Pokémon has 5 slots
I can't really see ridley making it on a roster of the size of 45, so it pained me, but I couldn't put him on it.
thanks for the feedback, mates

Seraphim. · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

Good roster.

XStarWarriorX · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

~~previous comment: Not really, though its kinda annoying when your always kind to people yet get hated anyway.~~

Roster looks good, though maybe roy instead of chrom. other than that it looks to small for my taste, maybe 5 more. (I'm assuming its 45)

overall 8.5/10.

????????????? · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
I don't see any Mario rep as likely, so I didn't add any its just that mewtwo just seems inevitable so that is why Pokémon has 5 slots
I can't really see ridley making it on a roster of the size of 45, so it pained me, but I couldn't put him on it.
thanks for the feedback, mates

There isn't a single new Mario rep that absolutely stands out as an obvious newcomer, but all the same, it looks odd to me to have Pokemon have more characters than Mario. However, I like your Pokemon line-up and would not change it.

Another TOTAL opinion... I honestly think that Ridley is more likely than Palutena.

Espio264 · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
Did you also cast Jigglypuff off of the roster by the Random slot? Did you do that too? Huh?!

Actually, somehow Jiggs and Kirby ended up together in the exact center to create a bright pink roster belly button of sorts.

G0LD3N L0TUS · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

Aside from the awkward layout and questionable lack of a 2nd Metroid rep, nothing stands out at all. This is a pretty standard and solid roster! Good job!

Morbi · Nov 3, 2013

pizzadudemanguy said:
There isn't a single new Mario rep that absolutely stands out as an obvious newcomer, but all the same, it looks odd to me to have Pokemon have more characters than Mario. However, I like your Pokemon line-up and would not change it.

Another TOTAL opinion... I honestly think that Ridley is more likely than Palutena.

Toad seems pretty obvious to me, lets be honest, if Peach didn't have Toad as her neutral special everybody would expect him (IMO). Ridley has some tech related problems along with Sakurai disregarding him as a potential playable character in the past. Palutena doesn't have much going against her (aside from Sakurai's modesty).

????????????? · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
Toad seems pretty obvious to me, lets be honest, if Peach didn't have Toad as her neutral special everybody would expect him (IMO). Ridley has some tech related problems along with Sakurai disregarding him as a potential playable character in the past. Palutena doesn't have much going against her (aside from Sakurai's modesty).

I think Bowser Jr. has the best shot at the moment. I think he's become enough of a regular to the series.

Palutena...what I have against the character is that...I think she's better suited to other roles. I think of her more as a part of Pit, like Doc Louis to Little Mac, than a separate entity. I mean, she literally IS a separate entity, but I think she can be represented just as well with just Pit...again, like Doc and Mac.

More of my own views.

Espio264 · Nov 3, 2013

Well goodnight everybody! I'll catch you again when we're all one more update wealthier. Hopefully it'll be a good one. Don't badmouth Falco while I'm gone or I might just return and clock you in the balls/lady balls. Have a good one!

LoneKonWolf · Nov 3, 2013

G0LD3N L0TUS said:
Aside from the awkward layout and questionable lack of a 2nd Metroid rep, nothing stands out at all. This is a pretty standard and solid roster! Good job!

ya, lets just say i'm not the best when it comes to organizing.

Morbi · Nov 3, 2013

pizzadudemanguy said:
I think Bowser Jr. has the best shot at the moment. I think he's become enough of a regular to the series.

Palutena...what I have against the character is that...I think she's better suited to other roles. I think of her more as a part of Pit, like Doc Louis to Little Mac, than a separate entity. I mean, she literally IS a separate entity, but I think she can be represented just as well with just Pit...again, like Doc and Mac.

More of my own views.

That seems rational, it is what Sakurai did in Brawl. I think Uprising is what makes a lot of people speculate about her (despite them disregarding "muh recency").

Edit: We should probably cut Falco. He doesn't do much, he just sucks in general.

G0LD3N L0TUS · Nov 3, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
ya, lets just say i'm not the best when it comes to organizing.

May I suggest having the series go left to right rather than up to down?

Also, props for the Gumshoe.

LoneKonWolf · Nov 3, 2013

G0LD3N L0TUS said:
May I suggest having the series go left to right rather than up to down?

Also, props for the Gumshoe.

ya i'll do that next time,
also thanks mate

MorbidAltruism said:
Edit: We should probably cut Falco. He doesn't do much, he just sucks in general.

????????????? · Nov 3, 2013

Espio264 · Nov 3, 2013

MorbidAltruism said:
Edit: We should probably cut Falco. He doesn't do much, he just sucks in general.

Lady balls.

Scoliosis Jones · Nov 4, 2013

Well, i'm off to bed. But here is the first of my Super Smash Boards rosters! I'm going installment by installment, meaning i'm starting with 12, and will bump it up to 26 next time.

Here we are!

Here were my picks for Super Smash Boards 64:

Entei = GoldenYuiitusin
Booker DeWitt = Scoliosis Jones (shameless self inclusion

)
Toon Link = FalKoopa
Shulk = Xenoblaze
Roy = Chronobound
Mega Man = Super Smash Bros. Fan
K.Rool = BKupa
Ivysaur = Swampasaur
Mario and Sonic = Mario and Sonic Guy
Ridley = Oasis
Guile = JohnKnight
Diskun = SaturnGamer64

HarryTheChin · Nov 4, 2013

Pac-Man because I can.

Pacack · Nov 4, 2013

Scoliosis Jones said:
Well, i'm off to bed. But here is the first of my Super Smash Boards rosters! I'm going installment by installment, meaning i'm starting with 12, and will bump it up to 26 next time.

Here we are!

Here were my picks for Super Smash Boards 64:

Entei = GoldenYuiitusin
Booker DeWitt = Scoliosis Jones (shameless self inclusion )
Toon Link = FalKoopa
Shulk = Xenoblaze
Roy = Chronobound
Mega Man = Super Smash Bros. Fan
K.Rool = BKupa
Ivysaur = Swampasaur
Mario and Sonic = Mario and Sonic Guy
Ridley = Oasis
Guile = JohnKnight
Diskun = SaturnGamer64

Why isn't Morbid already in?

SuperBrawler · Nov 4, 2013

Scoliosis Jones said:
Well, i'm off to bed. But here is the first of my Super Smash Boards rosters! I'm going installment by installment, meaning i'm starting with 12, and will bump it up to 26 next time.

Here we are!

Here were my picks for Super Smash Boards 64:

Entei = GoldenYuiitusin
Booker DeWitt = Scoliosis Jones (shameless self inclusion )
Toon Link = FalKoopa
Shulk = Xenoblaze
Roy = Chronobound
Mega Man = Super Smash Bros. Fan
K.Rool = BKupa
Ivysaur = Swampasaur
Mario and Sonic = Mario and Sonic Guy
Ridley = Oasis
Guile = JohnKnight
Diskun = SaturnGamer64

You better I add me lololol.

Capybara Gaming · Nov 4, 2013

Scoliosis Jones said:
Well, i'm off to bed. But here is the first of my Super Smash Boards rosters! I'm going installment by installment, meaning i'm starting with 12, and will bump it up to 26 next time.

Here we are!

Here were my picks for Super Smash Boards 64:

Entei = GoldenYuiitusin
Booker DeWitt = Scoliosis Jones (shameless self inclusion )
Toon Link = FalKoopa
Shulk = Xenoblaze
Roy = Chronobound
Mega Man = Super Smash Bros. Fan
K.Rool = BKupa
Ivysaur = Swampasaur
Mario and Sonic = Mario and Sonic Guy
Ridley = Oasis
Guile = JohnKnight
Diskun = SaturnGamer64

And where am I?

KingofPhantoms · Nov 4, 2013

I hope I'm in Super SmashBoards Melee.

LoneKonWolf · Nov 4, 2013

Scoliosis Jones said:
Well, i'm off to bed. But here is the first of my Super Smash Boards rosters! I'm going installment by installment, meaning i'm starting with 12, and will bump it up to 26 next time.

Here we are!

Here were my picks for Super Smash Boards 64:

Entei = GoldenYuiitusin
Booker DeWitt = Scoliosis Jones (shameless self inclusion )
Toon Link = FalKoopa
Shulk = Xenoblaze
Roy = Chronobound
Mega Man = Super Smash Bros. Fan
K.Rool = BKupa
Ivysaur = Swampasaur
Mario and Sonic = Mario and Sonic Guy
Ridley = Oasis
Guile = JohnKnight
Diskun = SaturnGamer64

looks good so far mate, can't wait to see the end product

and alas its time for me to take my leave, i wish you guys the best of times
also wake me up when a wolfo'donnel reference is made

yoonb · Nov 4, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
well then I do believe that this thread has been sidetracked long enough.
to get it back on track I'll post my roster here:

any question's? comments? statements?

No Pac-Man? No Mii? Shulk and Chrom? One of my favorite rosters by far. I'm a little iffy on Snake's inclusion, though.

Just a quick question for y'all. Why does everybody continue to have all Brawl veteran returning when most of don't expect (I think it's most of us) all of them returning in the first place? It's more of a curious question.

Morbi · Nov 4, 2013

lonekonwolf said:
looks good so far mate, can't wait to see the end product

and alas its time for me to take my leave, i wish you guys the best of times
also wake me up when a wolfo'donnel reference is made

Can't let you do that Star Fox!

Pacack said:
Why isn't Morbid already in?

Right? He is getting no more likes! Just kidding, he is saving the best for Melee.

Capybara Gaming · Nov 4, 2013

As long as I'm in Super SmashBoards Brawl I'll be happy.

Pacack · Nov 4, 2013

yoonb said:
No Pac-Man? No Mii? Shulk and Chrom? One of my favorite rosters by far. I'm a little iffy on Snake's inclusion, though.

Just a quick question for y'all. Why does everybody continue to have all Brawl veteran returning when most of don't expect (I think it's most of us) all of them returning in the first place? It's more of a curious question.

I do not, personally. My best guess is that people are just hoping for the best.

Morbi · Nov 4, 2013

yoonb said:
No Pac-Man? No Mii? Shulk and Chrom? One of my favorite rosters by far. I'm a little iffy on Snake's inclusion, though.

Just a quick question for y'all. Why does everybody continue to have all Brawl veteran returning when most of don't expect (I think it's most of us) all of them returning in the first place? It's more of a curious question.

After Toon Link was revealed, a lot of the "cut" fear left, probably erroneously. Most people still speculate that we will get a reasonable amount of cuts, perhaps one or two. Common candidates are Snake (based on licensing issues and any possible malice because MGS isn't going to be on the Wii U) and Lucas (Mother is dead and Ness is all we really need). Some people out of the norm speculate that certain characters might be dismissed, some Wolf/Lucario/Ike haters are out there. Obviously there isn't a basis for those cuts. I personally think that Pokemon Trainer will be a logical cut.

In the end, after Toon Link, people think that only 1 or 2 characters will be cut. Most people just assume that we will not get as many newcomers.

G0LD3N L0TUS · Nov 4, 2013

Nevermind this. I changed my mind. I'll take a surprise.

Morbi · Nov 4, 2013

G0LD3N L0TUS said:
If I may, could I ask to fav my representative be Floette, my favourite Flower Pokemon? Of coarse, that's provided I'm adding, which I don't expect would be till Brawl or Wii U/3DS.

He will probably troll you and make your icon a Sunflora, just saying.

BKupa666 · Nov 4, 2013

Mario and Sonic as a duo destroys their individuality!

Otherwise, stellar roster you've got there. I'd buy it.

Capybara Gaming · Nov 4, 2013

Imo, Fox and Falco are all Star Fox needs this time around, unless Krystal is added, then we need Wolf too.
Lucario won't leave; he's big still.
Ike probably won't either - He's got that "Everybody loves [strike] Raymong [/strike] Ike fanbase behind him.
Lucas won't go. You see, Sakurai LOVES Mother.

Snake I see leaving, and MAYBE R.O.B., anyone else is fair game.

Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

Smash Master

Scavenger

Smash Hero

Smash Master

Smash Ace

Scavenger

Smash Master

Smash Ace

Scavenger

Lazy Lonely Lurker☕

Smash Ace

[Get Ready]

Smash Master

Smash Ace

Smash Lord

Scavenger

Smash Master

Smash Ace

Lazy Lonely Lurker☕

Scavenger

Smash Lord

Lazy Lonely Lurker☕

Smash Master

Smash Ace

Kept you waiting, huh?

Smash Ace

Super Pac-Fan

Smash Master

Just Vibing

The Spook Factor

Lazy Lonely Lurker☕

Smash Journeyman

Scavenger

Just Vibing

Super Pac-Fan

Scavenger

Smash Lord

Scavenger

Barnacled Boss

Just Vibing

Information

Network