People who are ATs who you think SHOULD have been characters.

[2007]

Lyn. that is all.
=2007=

 

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

Should've been playable

Stay as assist trophies

 

[Devotion]

Saki and Lyn for me.

 

[.:«Jeff»:.]

The only problem I see with Little Mac is that he wouldn't be an original character to Smash. I have a feeling that he'd have been like C.F. Same thing with Grey Fox, he would've been like another clone of Marth, Roy, and Ike. However the Hammer Bros. they'd either be like the Ice Climbers or they'd be like a combination of Mario and Ice Climbers.

 

[Aqua Rock X]

There isn't really an AT that I think should have been playable. The only Assist Trophy "deconfirmation" that hurt me in the slightest was Lyn, but I knew her chances were grim with the introduction of ATs. And prior to ATs I though Goroh was the only character I was CERTAIN to make the cut, and what do you know, first to go. My hopefuls (Megaman, Bomberman, and Issac/Felix) are still in the running, so for the time being I'm fine with the ATs as they are.

 

[A Link to the Snitch]

Little Mac, Saki, Lyndis, Samurai Goroh, Excitebiker.

 

[Camera_Guy]

Gray Fox & Lyn

 

[raphtmarqui]

Lyn would have been a great playable character.
All others should stay ATs.

 

[lilparadise]

Meoth, Andros, little Devil, Knuckle Joe.

 

[nobletoast]

Lyn and Goroh might have been ok additions. But i'm hardly bothered at all with their de-confirmation.

 

[nobletoast]

double-post...oops.

 

[A Link to the Snitch]

Just because they have swords doesn't mean they would be the same.

 

[nobletoast]

Their both samurai.

They both have no other abilities to their samurai style of sword fighting (maybe Sumo but thats a very limited method in a game like Smash).

Who gives a **** anyway their both out and not worth arguing over.

 

[Zevox]

Only one I was bothered by was Lyn. Shes a personal favorite FE character for me, so even though I never truly expected her to be playable, I was holding out hope that her international popularity might just make that a possibility. 'Twas a sad day to see her ATed, even if it was fairly predictable.

Otherwise, the only one I feel was worthy as a PC was Samurai Goroh, and personally I'm not an F-Zero fan, so I don't care about him ultimately. The only thing about it that annoys me is that with him out of the way some folks are suggesting more foolish F-Zero characters be in more serious, like Black Shadow, and thats an inevitable part of speculation.

Their both samurai.

Lyn is no Samurai. There has never been a Samurai in Fire Emblem - its worlds are based on medieval Europe, not Japan. Lyn was a nomad of a plains region who learned swordfighting mostly on her own.

Zevox

 

[Supa_Sonic]

Saki definetly should have been a character he'd be sooooo cool

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

Lyn would have been a great playable character.
All others should stay ATs.

NO! They should not. Knuckle Joe should've been a character, as well as Hammer Bro, Lyn, Grey Fox and the space sword kid

 

[Thrillhouse-vh.]

Samurai Goroh
Little Mac
Meowth
Saki

 

[antimatter]

grey fox would have been sweet.

 

[hello_kitty]

Lyndis, Jill Dozer, and that's probably it.

 

[hello_kitty]

oh and Meowth and Gardevoir too, the rest could have stayed as AT's they wouldn't make a big difference to me.

 

[antimatter]

careful on double posting. youko is closing my thread for doing that.

 

[tirkaro]

saki amamiya.

WHY OH SAKURAI DIDN'T YOU MAKE SAKI PLAYABLE!!!!???? I SHALL NEVER FORGIVE YOU!!!!!

 

[Ridley22]

Samurai Goroh

 

[Princess Diana]

Gardevoir
Deoxys
Munchlax
Piplup
oh and umm... Samurai goroh i guess

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

Gardevoir
Deoxys
Munchlax
Piplup
oh and umm... Samurai goroh i guess

Um...Deoxys and Gardevoir I agree with, but Piplup and Munchlax can stay in a Pokeball.

 

[Strongside]

I find it hilarious that if someone suggested Saki before his announcement, they would have been shot down harder than a Romulen ship in Federation space.

Anyways...

My heart broke when I saw this update. He really is a great character, and should have been playable.

Great character, incredible potential.

I like Meowth. Bite me.

 

[KiddyDong]

Lyn to be the second FE character. Then we might actually have 2 decent lords instead of 1 good one and 1 and fail one (*looks at roy*)

 

[Princess Diana]

Um...Deoxys and Gardevoir I agree with, but Piplup and Munchlax can stay in a Pokeball.

I'm glad that you told me your opinion on who i think should have been characters...

Also i forgot to add meowth

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

Which Meowth are we talking about. Just a normal one or the one that talks?

 

[Geno4Brawl]

Quoted from Smash Dojo.

"Awww! It makes you want to use him as a playable character."
and
"Gray Fox, who engaged in a grand battle to the death with Metal Gear REX... To think that he would reappear on Wii, and alongside Mario and Sonic at that!

You never know what might happen in this world."

Hmm. I don't know why this makes me feel as if he might be more than just a AT.

 

[Zevox]

Quoted from Smash Dojo.

"Awww! It makes you want to use him as a playable character."
and
"Gray Fox, who engaged in a grand battle to the death with Metal Gear REX... To think that he would reappear on Wii, and alongside Mario and Sonic at that!

You never know what might happen in this world."

Hmm. I don't know why this makes me feel as if he might be more than just a AT.

Also quoted from the Smash Dojo (emphasis mine):

"Well, these are characters who appear to aid the fighter that called them forth. Basically, they’re guest characters separate from Smash’s playable roster!

Super Smash Bros. Brawl is sort of like a festival that all sorts of characters show up for. Bear in mind, though, that you can’t control any of the characters appearing on these pages. Let there be no mistake about that."

Zevox

 

[EPX2]

Meowth would've been pretty cool to play as.

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

Saki ftw. Why Sakurai?

 

[Fearthesmash]

Lyn Lyn Lyn Lyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn LynLyn Lyn Lyn

 

[bballstar23]

Goroh and Little Mac. Saki would be cool too, but I don't think I would have used him very much.

Off-topic edit: I'm still a little confused about the way Little Mac appears in the game. I never played the SNES version, but apparently Little Mac is the blonde guy in this picture, so why did they use the guy with black hair who's knocked out on the floor?

 

[Collective of Bears]

Lakitu, Goroh, Hammer Bro, Dr. Wright (lol)

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

Lakitu? lol

 

[XACE-K]

• Hammer Bro
• Samurai Goroh
• Lyn
• Little Mac
• Saki
• Gray Fox

 

[ChaosStar]

Personaly, I honestly think (Dont hate me for this...) that Resetti would have been a fun character, just give him little legs. Honestly, how could you NOT like the idea as playing as a mole with a pickaxe? His FS could be his AT function.

I REALLY would have liked an Advance Wars CO to be a character, and there FS could work like Pit's, but slightly different. (Plus, can't you just SEE a guy getting hit on the head with a wrench in this game?)

Goroh would've been nice, or Black Shadow, just to add another F-Zero guy in there.

Lyn is another one I'd have liked in there, but not as much as certian others, like Hector, Ephiram, The Silver-Haired Maiden (Cant remeber name), or a few others.

All the others I have no particular feelings for. Never played Punch Out or Sin and Punishment (I plan to once i get the money), so I can't give an unbiased opinion on them.

 

[ChaosStar]

Oops, this is my brother's account. It's me, Smashassassin. Sorry about that people...