Paper Mario Mafia: Day 4 finally ends! Luigi wins!

[BarDulL]

Is that really a question at this point?

Are you?

 

[Pierce7d]

Marshy, I'm Kolorado, town Tracker. I wish I was a watcher, because we would've won this game already if we had a good watcher.

 

[frozenmarsh751]

If you're actually bulletproof, that means you [j] watch me, then you watch Kary. If they hit Kary first, it's basically game over by process of elimination.

why dont we just do this?

 

[John2k4]

Props on the amazing image quality, Inferno.

Reading now, page 101/103

 

[#HBC | J]

John, bro, tell me what I wanna hear. You're town right?

 

[frozenmarsh751]

smfh @ some of the power roles in this game

pierce as tracker shouldve gone rajam/john last night. the last scumbag HAS to perform the kill at this point and couldve cleared one of em

kary shouldve just jailed me all game and him and i wouldve both lived to endgame

not that it matters now. but its disappointing

 

[BarDulL]

Then if I guess right, I am able to get an investigative or protecting ability. I choose investigative and I got a DayCop ability which I used on Bardull to clear him from any shenanigans that could happen later in the game if someone tried to bring up D1 w.r.t. him and left a crumb of Bardull being my strongest town read to Marshy within that Tier-list post that relates to the players and also moreso in my first post of the day with Marshy/Bardull being obv-town.

Explain this part in detail. Why not use it on a slot like Sang/John/Rajam or even Kary? Why choose my slot when Ronike was going strong for my slot and essentially cleared myself in our end-of-d1 interactions?

 

[BarDulL]

John, I expect a claim out of you and an explanation for what this "gem" is.

 

[#HBC | J]

Bardull, patience please.

marshy, you may be happier in a couple minutes.

 

[John2k4]

John, bro, tell me what I wanna hear. You're town right?

You bet I am.


@Barbell - If J thinks he has it, then the gem is his to reveal. I feel it would be better for him to expand on, since you were apparently seeing things/not remembering correctly.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

ALGDjaofg-0ew[ouwiedjkjahfhwqkjlehhj

Oh well go town.

 

[#HBC | J]

I'm sad Bardull can't find his gem. I found a diamond.

Pierce, you done re-reading my posts yet?

 

[John2k4]

Go forth and reveal, J. I'll be around.

 

[Pierce7d]

No really, we should do that though. If J is scum then he is correct about Bardull being town. If J is town, he is correct that Bardull is town. That means Bardull is town.
If Kary is Jailer, and protected Marshy (which is very likely to be true) then that means Marshy is town, because he could not NK anyone. Unless Marshy is the best Indy ever, he is town. IF I AM WRONG ABOUT THIS, SOMEONE NOT NAMED MARSHY POINT IT OUT.
I am obviously town. I just claimed tracker. The odds of a tracker in the game with a ninja is astoundingly high. You can also see I've been crumbing Kolorado PRETTY DAMN HARD, especially day 1 and day 2. Night 1 I tracked Overswarm because I figured that tracking Seph would solve nothing since I thought he'd shoot someone and we'd all know it was him since no one counter claimed Vig. I wanted to see if my voteblock was stable, so I tracked my other ally. Obviously OS visited no one, and also died, so that was a waste. Good thing I wasn't caught in the explosion.
Then last night I tracked J. I didn't like how Seph was bringing pressure onto him when I had a strong townie vibe from him, and I didn't want to track someone we were gonna lynch anyways, because well, we're gonna lynch them anyways. I'd rather check the thought-to-be-townies and see if I could find something suspicious.
Of course, I tracked J, and he was found actually visiting the player who was killed. You'll have to forgive me J, but Mafia 101 tell me that I have to be auto-suspicious of you now. If anything, Seph will be one shot vig and shoot me in every game ever if you turned out to be scum and I didn't avenge him. Gotta watch you for the homie Seph.

But yes. Scum must shoot me dead, or I will watch one of the people we don't lynch, and they are going to be supremely screwed with so many cleared townies. J is bulletproof, and he's getting cop powers, so he's doing even more power scum hunting. Marshy is cleared townie if J is jailer (and if Marshy is a power role, then he can even confirm Kary as Jailer if he failed his NA last night because he was jailed, and THAT will let me rest easy).

Bardull just goes with the flow because he's townie. Oh, but he can be shot. Well, WIFOM it up between Marshy and Bardull then, Kary.

 

[Pierce7d]

Between J and John, someone better tell me what I want to hear, because at this point I will lynch you both.

Also, I don't play this game Marshy. And if J is scum then I think that my plan of tracking him to clear him or see if he's super awesome scum was a big success.

 

[#HBC | J]

If Pierce isn't going to answer me I'll just reveal it in a couple of seconds. Give me time to post it.

 

[frozenmarsh751]

oh iight now that i see your thought process that isnt bad at all pierce

^ what j has done by asking me to be patient

 

[BarDulL]

I'm surprised I haven't seen a white flag yet.

 

[#HBC | J]

Marshy, you want a spoiler?

Spoiler

I lied about something I did.

I thought you'd figure it out by now.

 

[frozenmarsh751]

i know you know i know you know i you know i know your role + plan j

 

[John2k4]

Uh, what?

 

[BarDulL]

J, quit wasting time.

 

[Pierce7d]

So, you dayCopped John and not Bardull?

 

[Pierce7d]

But I don't see the motive of lying about that?

 

[#HBC | J]

Okay let me explain things more clearly now. I will make this part really clear so I don't confuse people anymore. I am terribly sorry for having to do this but I want this game to end now and I needed one final nail in the coffin before this thing is over.

I did not investigate Bardull. I investigated John and got innocent.

Here are some posts that I would like to highlight explicitly around the time that I decided to use my abilit:

After? Lol how does that work?

Rajam>Kary>Sang/John

Keeps changing the more I think about it. My gut is weird on Sang/John where I don't wanna lynch them but there is ample evidence to lynch them.

Also I ain't going anywhere, mafia won't kill me. 8)

Here is the post I made before sending in my Day-action where I expressing my gut on Sang/John and didn't know what to do. Because my gut was weird on those two, I flipped between John/Sang and got John.

This is like the saddest post I've ever read this game...=[

Pierce/Bardull, talk to me, Kary or John for you toMorrow?

Sang....do something...anything.....please? I don't want to lynch you but logic suggests otherwise.

Here is the post after my investigation where I question Pierce/Bardull after me getting my innocent on John and quoted his sad post because I realzied he was actually town being this way. It was also the point where I was leaning towards Sang may actually be a more likely mafia consideration especially since I got an inno on John.

Can you specifically point out how your John read dropped dramatically? Can you also point out how your Rajam read is so strong when compared to others especially when other players feel he is scummier?

I begin to go more offensive on when people start talking about their John read "dropping dramatically" and her being so okay with Rajam which did not make sense. I wanted to see her train of thought behind John.

Well he did explain that he was at a convention/tournment for the weekend, so ya gotta be fair on that part. ;P

Marshy translate this post if I am not here later in the game:

This post I switched around a few of the people. Chibo = Rob and is my middle ground. Switch John = Bubble to the top above Wario and then you have my lynch list from yesterDay's PoV because Pierce was giving me really off/weird vibes with his over-zealous John push that I can now set aside to him just being certain he felt John was scum after this tracker fiasco.

Am I really the only one who found that gem w.r.t. John?

This is where I crumbed that I "found a gem" with John which is a crumb for my FT since FT uses crystal ball (though if memory serves he uses the stars to predict the future which could still be considered a gem haha) and saying that the gem I literally found through my own means was that he is in fact town.

I've actually mentioned it before Bardull and John confirmed it too. ;P

I kind of blatantly asked John about it and he did confirm it and I tried to play it off like I had found a possible PR crumb that I didn't want to out and I was bluffing on that point, which made me find it weird that Bardull was saying that he found a similar "gem" and now that he was the first to find it, it disappeared. Don't know how I feel about it.

Personally, I feel it explains John's actions more and I can see the town-intent for what he is doing>scum-intent after looking at his posts more closely during the John/Sang debate earlier toDay.

And here is where I pretty much just say, "Look, John's town, look for town-intent>scum-intent." I even crumbed the time where I investigated him which was during the John/Sang debate.

Okay, I also crumbed it in toDay's Dayphase by putting John in the "can-die" pile and also decided to use the chance to try and also clear Bardull but most of what he posted was null and also disheartening when he didn't find a "gem" in John. I am a little happy he didn't fake one "gem" but at the same time I don't like the fact I get the feeling he lied when talking about he "also found a gem in John". Bardull is in my "town-bros" list and I wouldn't lynch him over Rajam at all.

I honestly feel Rajam is the final scum, if he is not, I have no clue at the current time because who else could it be? Chibo? Don't think so. Bardull? Eh, possibly but I am just not wanting to think he is scum. Kary? Oooooh, I wish it was him.

So yeah, can we please just lynch Rajam and end this game hopefully?

 

[Pierce7d]

oh iight now that i see your thought process that isnt bad at all pierce

^ what j has done by asking me to be patient

This picture is not working

But yeah like, if the plan is to stand arm to arm and spray outward, then it's pretty infallible, and figured I'd use my powers to make sure I wasn't holding hands with scum. With two scum out the game, I only need one other confirmed townie in Lylo to win.

 

[#HBC | J]

So, you dayCopped John and not Bardull?

Bingo.

But I don't see the motive of lying about that?

I wanted to net an absolute 100% BardullTown read with my result but that part of the plan fell short.

 

[frozenmarsh751]

BUT WHAT IF JOHN IS GODFATHER????

meh. we should make some kind of night action plan

 

[Pierce7d]

I still think my plan is good. Just sayin.

 

[John2k4]

@J

What's Rajam at?

 

[#HBC | J]

For the love of christ marshy. xD

Kary jails Marshy
Pierce Tracks one of Bardull/Chibo
I predict One of Kary/Pierce

Sound good?

 

[#HBC | J]

Oh yeah, I also investigated John because I would love to be in the end of the game with him in the end.

That's just a personal gain.

*brofist*

Rajam is at L-3.

 

[Pierce7d]

Hmm, I think Rajam is town, but obviously I'm going to cooperate with town. Chibo, post your thoughts.

 

[frozenmarsh751]

For the love of christ marshy. xD

Kary jails Marshy
Pierce Tracks one of Bardull/Chibo
I predict One of Kary/Pierce

Sound good?

@ bolded

isnt it better to publicly state the choice like pierce suggested? that way we either force scum to keep one of our townbros or give you another power. if you are scum then we get info to figure that out in the future (tho i dont think youre scum)

 

[#HBC | J]

If Kary jails Pierce/Myself after claiming, I will lynch him so bad. I am just waiting for an excuse to, tbh.

Pierce, than who should go, in your opinion>Rajam?

 

[John2k4]

Vote: Rajam

L-2

Marshy we bros now. K?

 

[#HBC | J]

Okay, I'm cool with that. Which one should I FT toNight then?

 

[#HBC | J]

Oh, just an FYI, I don't know what I get for my 3rd+ FT. It's randomized after I was able to choose the first two.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

offhand im not sure j. any plan that maximizes mine and pierces lifespan is ideal. frozen would probably have a better idea on this **** than i do and i havent gotten a chance to think it out fully. i probably wont to be honest

 

[Pierce7d]

I don't think J is scum, but textbook does not suggest I give J this much power. However, J AND Kary can't be lying, unless Kary IS Indy, haha.

Also, John could just be lynched, and we lose a cleared townie, although we get a new one if scum doesn't kill me.

Also, J you're absolutely killing me with this claim bro. Gets a dayCop power, clears FRIKKEN JOHN, then gets BP which can never be confirmed. If he says he gets a bullet tomorrow, someone lynch him. BETTER BE A DAY BULLET FOR YOUR SAKE J.