Paper Mario Mafia: Day 4 finally ends! Luigi wins!

[frozenmarsh751]

final reads ronike? lets see if youve still got it

 

[Ronike]

Don't care. You don't do that, you read it, and respond to it. If you had done so, my lynch probably would have gone through sooner, as the rust would have dug my grave even better if I had been posting.

 

[Ronike]

BTW,

ronike

that was easy

Compliment? Or burn? I couldn't tell.

 

[BarDulL]

*shrug*

Talk to me out of game, I'm a different guy in here. I get nasty and do nasty things. That chumminess in the beginning was not fake though, just fyi.

 

[Ronike]

Don't care. You don't do that, you read it, and respond to it. If you had done so, my lynch probably would have gone through sooner, as the rust would have dug my grave even better if I had been posting.

Still responds to your last post, just as well as the one before.

 

[Pierce7d]

Come on, for a novice bro? =(

 

[frozenmarsh751]

compliment my friend. our lack of synergy this game disturbed me

 

[Rajam]

Did John present a reason for not being here @ last day? His inactivity reeks

 

[Pierce7d]

John was on last night at like 3am

 

[adumbrodeus]

He really isn't that bad of a guy ronike.


Just you know, not the best mafia player

 

[Ronike]

Well then thank you, I'm flattered you think that, even if I disagree.

 

[Pierce7d]

Holy balls, Ronike is actually scum. LOL

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Yo, sorry 'bout the way that went down, Ronike.

Bardull, there's no need to criticize Ronike's play right now, so yeah...

I'm a think that's it from me for time being.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

P.S. Although, if Ronike is scum, that's awesome.

 

[Inferno3044]

Night 1 Begins!

A long day has gone by within Peach's castle. But one member of the party stood out a lot more than the others. He was a very quiet person. Quite shy if you will. He was asked to state who he was, but still no response. The town had turned toward Ronike and brought him to the gallows to meet his maker (because apparently Princess Peach has one within her castle). There Ronike hung quietly with no parting words. All that remained was the mask upon his face. The group goes to sleep a little more soundly than they would have before because they see that:

Ronike - General Guy, Mafia Ninja has been lynched!

It is now Night 1. Please send in all of your night actions by June 13th at 11:59PM EST. I will be strict on the deadline. The faster they are sent, the faster we can move on with the game.

 

[Inferno3044]

Day 2 Begins!

The night started out very quietly. It seemed it was going to be a peaceful night. Just before it turned to dawn, everyone heard a very loud

BOOM!!!

Everyone woke up from their sleep and rushed as fast as they can to where they heard the explosion. Sorrow and sadness had rolled over everyone's face because they saw:

Overswarm, Bombette, Town Bomb has been killed!

Although everyone had wept about Overswarm's death, they had noticed that another member was not among them. They searched all the rooms as they found yet another dead body. However, this death made everyone smile and rejoice because they saw:

Adumbrodeus, Kammy Koopa, Mafia Roleblocker has been killed!

Seeing the yet another mafia taken down, the town continues to search for scum.


J (0)
SangfroidWarrior (0)
Rajam (0)
John2k4 (0)
Pierce7d (0)
Chibosempai (0)
BarDulL (0)
Sephiroths Masamune (0)
Kary (0)
Frozenmarsh751 (0)

Not voting: J, Sang, Rajam, John, Pierce, Chibo, Bardull, Seph, Kary, Fmarsh

Day 2 has officially begun! With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline set to 6/23 at 11:59PM EST.

 

[Pierce7d]

LOL. Adumb hit the bomb. Odd, I had him as a town read. His AtE and his confidence that I was town off such a flimsy read made me think he was scummy all of the first day, but then on my night read, I thought he was Town based off of his pressure on Ronike. My biggest worry was that I was going to decide he was town, and him turn out scum or that I was going to think Overswarm, and he turned out to be scum, but now they're both dead, so I don't have to worry about either, LOL.

 

[Pierce7d]

I'll post my night analysis, but of course, I will require another reread to post my dawn flip analysis. Despite the dawn flip, I will show everyone my night analysis uneditted.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Paper Mario Mafia Notes

78 Rajam calls Ronike on a scum slip
127 Ronike says he doesn't like Seph or Rajam
164 Ronike votes Seph.

237 I team up with Seph and OS, but state that I think Ronike is the stronger play than Bardull
249 J further pressures Ronike. He has already buddied with Marshy at this point.
301 Rajam puts more pressure on Ronike
317 Bardull states he also does not like Ronike
381 Marshy states his scum read on Ronike
418 Seph defends Ronike
426 Kary states he likes Ronike the least out of a player pool he thinks to be scum
430 Ronike reads a null/leaning scum on me (Pierce)

448/449, Marshy KNOWS Ronike is scum, LOL
450 Adumbrodeus moves his vote onto Ronike and attempts to team up with Marshy to get him killed
452 Bardull votes Ronike as well
453 Marshy defends Bardull
454 J votes Ronike
457/458 Ronike puts pressure on Bardull
459 OS does not hop on the Ronike wagon and soft pressures Marshy
471-489 Ronike and Bardull go head to head
500 Kary states he dislikes Bardull. This is noteworthy because the timing is when Bardull is trying to push Ronike to L-1
510 Marshy pushes pressure away from Bardull back onto Ronike
511 Seph pushes pressure away from Ronike back onto Bardull
513 J puts pressure away from Bardull back onto Ronike.
517 Seph defends Ronike again.
521 This post is very interesting to me. Bardull is (now obviously) not scum, and is heavily pressuring Ronike. Seph is worried about it being difficult to kill him later, when he put a lot of pressure on Ronike.
522 J wants Kary lynched
523 Seph targets Kary
526/527 Marshy/J also target Kary
533 Kary cannot see Bardull as town.
546 Seph targets Kary and defends Ronike
560 Seph gives a list. Despite defending Ronike multiple times, he puts Ronike in his "still deciding" slot. This looks like distancing to me.
598 OS does not want to unvote Bardull. Sometime before this, I said I would be okay with compromising the Bardull lynch.
612 Adumbrodeus asks why Ronike is still alive
618-621 Bardull and I finally interact.
622 Marshy puts a list out
623 Kary tries to move pressure back onto Bardull
630 What the hell? Sangfroid basically says, Pierce, I don't like you. Here's why. And your reasons, screw them. But then completely drops all pressure on me. Scummy to me.

636 Rajam falls from grace. Agrees with defending Ronike and starts targetting Bardull while voting Adumb
640 Adumb continues pressuring Ronike.
651 OS pushes Bardull again
658 Marshy HEAVILY defends Bardull
!!!664 J pushes Kary. At this point, I'm getting an Indy read on Kary. What is FUD?
670 Seph defends Ronike again
691 Kary SCREAMING Indy to me. Not looking townish, but willing to throw Ronike under the bus.
698 Adumbro posts the godliest list
726 Bardull, despite being under immense pressure, keeps his stance on scum Ronike, and does not worry about own survival. Getting a strong VT read here.
756 I push pressure onto Bardull.
770 OS states that he does not trust Marshy. This actually scares me a bit, because in my eyes, Marshy is the towniest player.
780-789 Bardull and Kary go at it
790 Adumb defends Kary (this is actually a null for me)
795 Kary's read has both Bardull and Ronike as scummy. There is no way in hell I see a Bardull, Ronike scum team, and Ronkie actually flipped scum. Noob Indy read from this
812 John pressures Bardull
866 Chibo votes for Kary. I feel this is probably one of the most significant votes of the day because Kary's play appears scummy, and it also saved Bardull, who appears town. Scum could easily get away with hammering Bardull and joining in the Pierce/Seph/OS vote block.
874 Despite being cluttered with the AtE, this is the best post Kary made all game.
885 Seph has a quality post
893 Rajam has me read as null. This is odd, because he states that I'm playing to my meta, but I disagree. My meta is usually with a lot more inexperienced players, and I'm usually way, WAY less sheepish, and more of a leader/aggressive scum-hunter. Rajam should easily remember this because I lead town to almost victory by DESTROYING scum in my very first game, and then Rajam quick lynched me with the Indy before I came online in Lylo.
903 Kary has another good post.
909 Chibo defends Bardull
941 Kary begins the wheel of a Ronike lynch
After this, the game snowballs into quick lynch Ronike. In order of voting is J/Marshy/Seph/Adumb/Kary/Pierce/Bardull

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Game should be easy mode now. GGs and props to Marshy and J winning this for us Day1
1. J TOWN
2. SangfroidWarrior NULL LEANING SCUM
3. Rajam TOWN LEANING NULL
4. John2k4 NULL LEANING SCUM
5. Pierce7d TOWN
6. Chibosempai TOWN
7. BarDulL TOWN
8. Sephiroths Masamune TOWN LEANING INDY
10. adumbrodeus TOWN
11. Kary INDY LEANING TOWN
12. Overswarm NULL LEANING TOWN
13. marshy TOWN

Plan: Assemble all town bros in center, spray outwards. Squeeze the trigger and don't look back.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

[#HBC | J]

Wow now that is baller.

Vote: SangfroidWarrior

Now can we roll with this like I have a guilty on her?

Also Kary is on my hit-list but need to think some more about that. I just want Sang more atm.

 

[Pierce7d]

Vote: SangfroidWarrior

I love how me and J start off with the same idea.

 

[Pierce7d]

And yes, this is the part where Pierce starts playing the game. It's also the part where I stop ignoring pressure on me, so feel free to ask me questions that I'll actually answer.

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

J, how in the world do you have a guilty on me? (Note: not being stupid at the implications)

 

[#HBC | J]

Do I have a guilty on you? I never said that haha. ;P

 

[Pierce7d]

Oh, I did want to point this out since OS got killed. The parts where you see linebreaks in my read were the parts where I excluded because I thought Overswarm was crumbing Cop. However, since OS is dead, I no longer need to hide the fact that I had a slight suspcious Overswarm was cop. He's obviously not, LOL

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Ah. I read the "like I have a guilty on her" as a separation of phrases.

 

[#HBC | J]

Oh, I did want to point this out since OS got killed. The parts where you see linebreaks in my read were the parts where I excluded because I thought Overswarm was crumbing Cop. However, since OS is dead, I no longer need to hide the fact that I had a slight suspcious Overswarm was cop. He's obviously not, LOL

If I didn't love your notes and your slot so much this game already, I'd probably say this was a good reason to have OS killed last night. xD

 

[Pierce7d]

I think there are two seperate mafia factions though, which is going to disrupt my read a little bit. Adumb flipping scum, but being the 4th on his wagon means he either abandoned hope for Ronike being saved, and thought he could hide himself there, or there's two mafia factions. Considering the behavior of players like Kary, I'm willing to believe the latter.

 

[Pierce7d]

Sang, after the current flips, which player in the game do you think is most likely to be scum?

 

[Pierce7d]

Also, Seph, Day 1 was fun, but I'm a bit done being a sheep. Like I promised, I'll be making reads of my own now. It's about time for me to come out of my shell and explore the world a bit, you know?

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Pierce, give me some time on that. I want to re-read with the knowledge of who is scum and who is town. It might not change much, but it certainly helps. Also, I don't necessarily agree with your two-mafia factions thing. What do you mean by the behavior of players like Kary?

 

[frozenmarsh751]

vote scumfroidwarrior

 

[frozenmarsh751]

seph good call mah dude

 

[Pierce7d]

I mean Kary's play is very self-preservative, but Kary also was willing to vote Ronike, who was scum. This is the behavior of scum, but normally scum doesn't vote other scum. That means he could be Indy, or there could be a second mafia faction.

Also, a little food for thought.
http://www.smashboards.com/misc.php?do=whoposted&t=323153

 

[frozenmarsh751]

so glad that ****ing moron overswarm is dead. thank you adumb for ridding us of his dumb ***

 

[Pierce7d]

I can't believe OS was the NK target though. I guess Adumb really was afraid of that Doc, LOL

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Eh. Pierce, being self-preserving isn't always a scummy tell. And, scum vote other scum if they want to make it look like they are town and/or have no connection to their scum partner.

 

[frozenmarsh751]

yo btw frozen hit me up over the night phase and said hell read. however frozen is a pretty busy guy and might take like half a week to read this game. sangfroids the play today tho

are you in agreement with this seph?

 

[Pierce7d]

Vote for and try to have lynched are very different. I still think Kary's play has been scummy as all hell, especially considering the Adumb flip.

 

[Pierce7d]

Also, I am okay with a quick lynch Sang, but only if you guys send in your night actions quickly. Waiting 55 hours to finally start playing was hella boring.

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

And, yes, yes, if you were pointing out that I have the fewest posts, believe me, I know. I was really busy yesterday and I also didn't really have the motivation to play this game. I'll be trying to fix that today. I'd really like for you guys not to lynch me, but I'd rather it be that than have a player that is a liability, which is what I am at the moment.

Also, again, I've seen it where scum have hard-bodied their partners in order to save themselves for later in the game.