• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Social NintenZone Social 5 - Thanks, Everyone

Personal Highlight of the Mini Direct?

  • Super Mario Odyssey Update

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Fe

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Celeste

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    66
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Deleted member

Guest
Just as another point, I really don't think they'd keep Ness and Captain Falcon if they did the kind of purge a reboot suggests. The number of people who care about them outside the capacity of Smash is fairly small and they're essentially being maintained off of legacy, so it's likely they'd be cut and replaced with Isabelle and the Squid Sisters instead.

You can't really think of a purge from the perspective of a wishlist, you have to think of what they would actually pursue on a business level and sales and currently maintained franchises are important. If they're willing to burn bridges by rebooting then they're going to burn them all.
Captain Falcon being so tied to smash is the exact reason it'd terrible to remove him.
 

Kurri ★

#PlayUNIST
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
11,026
Location
Palm Beach FL
Switch FC
7334-0298-1902
Just as another point, I really don't think they'd keep Ness and Captain Falcon if they did the kind of purge a reboot suggests. The number of people who care about them outside the capacity of Smash is fairly small and they're essentially being maintained off of legacy, so it's likely they'd be cut and replaced with Isabelle and the Squid Sisters instead.

You can't really think of a purge from the perspective of a wishlist, you have to think of what they would actually pursue on a business level and sales and currently maintained franchises are important. If they're willing to burn bridges by rebooting then they're going to burn them all.
You really think they wouldn't keep Ness and Falcon?

I don't think you carry two characters for 4 games straight, and cut them the next like that.
 

Autumn ♫

I'm terrible with these Custom Titles.
Joined
Apr 20, 2013
Messages
7,147
Location
Sakurai's Secret Headquarters
Personally, I'd rather see them keep everything from 4 and build onto it in Switch, than start off with a much smaller roster, and unclone the cloney characters. (Especially Lucina and Ganondorf).
 

Metal Shop X

CHAINSAW POWEEEEEEEER
Joined
May 4, 2015
Messages
26,850
Location
USA
NNID
Mao644
3DS FC
4339-3012-0905
Switch FC
SW-2905-0652-6700
YES!!:falconmelee: I did it! I unlock Wesker and, most important of all, I unlock the infinite ammo for the Handcannon!!
Now, this is going to be even more fun! >: )
 

Coricus

Woom-em-my?
Joined
Feb 19, 2015
Messages
14,055
Switch FC
SW 4794 7152 2904
You really think they wouldn't keep Ness and Falcon?

I don't think you carry two characters for 4 games straight, and cut them the next like that.
Nobody says anything in defense of Jigglypuff. Nobody says anything in defense of the 2-3 dozen other characters that would be removed, a large chunk of which are immensely more popular in the gaming community even without Smash than the newcomers that these fantasies inevitably end in would be.

To push the point further, a Smash reboot wouldn't be "even," either. It'd be frontloaded with Mario characters and half or more of the long string of single character represented franchises that show up in these lists would just be gone.

There'd obviously be hell to pay, but there would be with the reboot scenario as it is and no one ever stops to think of that. Why make a special exception for a series that's been dormant for two generations and another one that isn't getting touched again? Because they're more nostalgic?
 

Wolfie557

Witch-King of the North
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
6,181
Location
London, United Kingdom
3DS FC
3153-4071-1007
Switch FC
SW 3128 8188 4021
To be fair, I haven't started playing the game until a few days ago. :p It's one of those games I wish I got into sooner because it's really my kind of game.(Metroid like map with a dark gothic style? Hell yes!) I would be further into it if I wasn't still playing Aria of Sorrow, which is also great.


But is it a hentia artist that draws males? :p


You're going to make the Nino lovers here triggered dude. Big mistake, almost as bad as @Undyne not knowing who Hector is.
Lmao I only know less than 20 characters from fire emblem.
 

FalKoopa

Rainbow Waifu
BRoomer
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
32,231
Location
India/भारत
3DS FC
1650-3685-3998
Switch FC
SW-5545-7990-4793
Despite all the other games that did the system well?
Yes, flops speak louder than successes.

There are plenty of successful Kickstarters but it just took Mighty Number 9 for people to start questioning it.
 

praline

the white witch
Joined
Feb 16, 2014
Messages
50,853
Location
the underworld
Switch FC
6178 82674988
It's super hype when you get the play of the game on Overwatch. Especially when it's woth someone you don't use often like Reaper.
 

Metal Shop X

CHAINSAW POWEEEEEEEER
Joined
May 4, 2015
Messages
26,850
Location
USA
NNID
Mao644
3DS FC
4339-3012-0905
Switch FC
SW-2905-0652-6700
Nobody says anything in defense of Jigglypuff. Nobody says anything in defense of the 2-3 dozen other characters that would be removed, a large chunk of which are immensely more popular in the gaming community even without Smash than the newcomers that these fantasies inevitably end in would be.

To push the point further, a Smash reboot wouldn't be "even," either. It'd be frontloaded with Mario characters and half or more of the long string of single character represented franchises that show up in these lists would just be gone.

There'd obviously be hell to pay, but there would be with the reboot scenario as it is and no one ever stops to think of that. Why make a special exception for a series that's been dormant for two generations and another one that isn't getting touched again? Because they're more nostalgic?
Because of the amount of fan who will be upset.
Like, do you even imagine the number of peoples who will be piss of if Capt.Falcon get removed? After that:
-His franchise hasn't got a single game for years.
-Nintendo doesn't seem to want to bring back F-Zero because they want to find a "gimmick" for it.
-That he is a veteran of the series.
-He is one of the most beloved character of the franchise. (Even when people don't know F-Zero, they still know who is Capt.Falcon because he is so iconic)
-He is a fun and great character in most games.
And most important of all:
-How he is going to show his moves if he isn't in the game?
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member

Guest
I'm gonna go crazy.
I was promised a February 2nd release so if Nintendo plans on delaying the game for the americas, then say it already!
 

Swamp Sensei

Today is always the most enjoyable day!
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
39,229
Location
Um....Lost?
NNID
Swampasaur
3DS FC
4141-2776-0914
Switch FC
SW-6476-1588-8392
All these terrible ideas for a reboot is why I don't want one.
 

Opossum

Thread Title Changer
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
34,183
Location
This Thread
NNID
OpossumGuy
3DS FC
4742-4911-3431
Switch FC
SW 2859 6322 5208
If people want a smaller Nintendo roster, just hope Nintendo vs Capcom becomes a thing. :p
 

Coricus

Woom-em-my?
Joined
Feb 19, 2015
Messages
14,055
Switch FC
SW 4794 7152 2904
Because of the amount of fan who will be upset.
Like, do you even imagien the number of peoples who will be piss of if Capt.Falcon get removed? After that:
-His franchise hasn't got a single game for years.
-Nintendo doesn't seem to want to bring back F-Zero because they want to find a gimmick for it.
-That he is a veteran of the series.
-He is one of the most beloved character of the franchise. (Even people don't know F-Zero, they still know who is Capt.Falcon)
And most important of all:
-How he is going to show his moves if he isn't in the game?
And no one thinks of all the fans of other characters that would be upset?

Does no one think anyone would miss :4sonic::4megaman::4pacman::4ryu::4cloud::4bayonetta:?

Or how about :4lucario::4jigglypuff::4greninja:?

Would anyone miss :4falco:, I wonder?

People already miss :snake::wolf::popo: extremely badly. Now multiply that by a dozen.

Captain Falcon is not more special than any of the other characters that people care about just because he's a meme. From an objective standpoint he has some of the least to bring to a Nintendo crossover and is largely just riding off of recursive Smash popularity. Most other characters that people wouldn't even shed a tear over have more going for them than that, but they're not a concern because they don't "Show their moves."

Cap is just another fish in an ocean full of characters with people who love them. My point is that if Smash were cut down, it wouldn't be some fantasy that got rid of all the characters people don't like and none of the ones they do, it would be an objective culling that would only include the characters they know they can turn a profit marketing with. And Captain Falcon isn't one of them.
 

Kurri ★

#PlayUNIST
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
11,026
Location
Palm Beach FL
Switch FC
7334-0298-1902
Yes, flops speak louder than successes.

There are plenty of successful Kickstarters but it just took Mighty Number 9 for people to start questioning it.
I understand flops speak louder than success, but I don't think that's reason enough to not look into an idea. It's more just an example of how not to handle something.
The biggest issue with SFV isn't even that they employed such a model, but that the rest of the game was lacking content. Things that would have been standard in other games.
You look at something like Killer Instinct, MKX, even Smash 4, and those issues aren't anywhere near as pronounced because a lot of the things that would be expected are already there.

Halo 5 almost suffered a similar fate, but thankfully, 343i fixed most of their issues quick.
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
What would a reboot be, though? With the likely scenario for a reboot, a 20 character roster with newcomers, you're going to end up with a veteran selection the size of Smash 64. At that range, it's a lot more than the "characters no one outside of Smash cares about" getting cut, you're going to be bleeding third party characters that sent people that don't even normally care squeeing and large chunks of franchises like Mario, Pokemon, and Zelda. Over a dozen franchises would probably just outright vanish, and a lot of them have characters that are sacred cows to sectors of the fandom that don't normally overlap with the roster people as much. And don't think for a moment that DK and Metroid would actually fare well in this situation either, say goodbye to Diddy and Zero Suit Samus and don't expect anyone else in trade.

I think you're underestimating how much of a backfire would happen. Even the casual community would start bleeding members with a reboot sized roster, and Nintendo would be bombarded with questions of "Where are all the characters?"
Who said it would be 20 characters?

If Sakurai doesn't return (which he likely won't), it's the perfect reason for a reboot, and he's the one you're quoting saying "20 is ideal" I'm sure many would disagree.

What would a reboot be?

SFII > SFIII or SFIII > SFIV or SFIV > SFV, or what Guilty Gear Xrd is to the XX series. It's happened dozens of times with fighting games, and is essentially a staple of the genre. Excessively large rosters are in fact a problem for fighting games due to balance issues. In fact, when rosters are picked for new installments in a fighting game, they're typically done by selecting certain characters that might best highlight some of the new mechanics, all the while still adding staples and familiar faces.

And I think you're overestimating how much backlash it would get. Nintendo has done this many times before (WindWaker), and people have coped just fine. It wouldn't bleed anything. If a reboot gets a lot of praise for trying new things, and etc... all the people throwing a hissy fit would eat their words and cave in anyway. There's nowhere else to go with the Smash series from here. You run a very serious risk of getting a lot of backlash from burnout if you retread your steps for a 5th time. A 5th Smash is unlikely to get Cloud, Ryu and a bunch of others to return, but mere virtue of that, it'll already be seen as inferior to it. And Smash 4 already exists, people can easily replay that installment if they wanna play as those characters. For one, that's a very Nintendo mentality, as they've literally said what I just said, and two, it's not uncommon of the Smash fanbase to cling to older games, (Melee) nor has this affected sales of future games.

Finally, it's very unreasonable to demand more and more and more and more each time. It's already reached a point, where more is simply too costly, and demands way too much work. EVERY character would need new models, animations, etc... and they would all need to be re-balanced, and reprogrammed (new engine, thus, a simple import doesn't quite work), for... what? 70+ characters?

An expanded port of 4, guaranteed, then a bit of break, and then a reboot. Mark my words.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Opossum

Thread Title Changer
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
34,183
Location
This Thread
NNID
OpossumGuy
3DS FC
4742-4911-3431
Switch FC
SW 2859 6322 5208
And no one thinks of all the fans of other characters that would be upset?

Does no one think anyone would miss :4sonic::4megaman::4pacman::4ryu::4cloud::4bayonetta:?

Or how about :4lucario::4jigglypuff::4greninja:?

Would anyone miss :4falco:, I wonder?

People already miss :snake::wolf::popo: extremely badly. Now multiply that by a dozen.

Captain Falcon is not more special than any of the other characters that people care about just because he's a meme. From an objective standpoint he has some of the least to bring to a Nintendo crossover and is largely just riding off of recursive Smash popularity. Most other characters that people wouldn't even shed a tear over have more going for them than that, but they're not a concern because they don't "Show their moves."

Cap is just another fish in an ocean full of characters with people who love them. My point is that if Smash were cut down, it wouldn't be some fantasy that got rid of all the characters people don't like and none of the ones they do, it would be an objective culling that would only include the characters they know they can turn a profit marketing with. And Captain Falcon isn't one of them.
Basically this for me. Hell, I'd miss folks like Greninja and Lucario a hell of a lot more than Captain Falcon...I'd even miss Palutena a lot more.
 

Professor Pumpkaboo

Lady Layton| Trap Queen♥
Joined
Sep 10, 2014
Messages
81,716
Location
IDOLM@STER Side M Hell, Virginia Beach
Switch FC
SW: 5586-2837-4585
And no one thinks of all the fans of other characters that would be upset?

Does no one think anyone would miss :4sonic::4megaman::4pacman::4ryu::4cloud::4bayonetta:?

Or how about :4lucario::4jigglypuff::4greninja:?

Would anyone miss :4falco:, I wonder?

People already miss :snake::wolf::popo: extremely badly. Now multiply that by a dozen.

Captain Falcon is not more special than any of the other characters that people care about just because he's a meme. From an objective standpoint he has some of the least to bring to a Nintendo crossover and is largely just riding off of recursive Smash popularity. Most other characters that people wouldn't even shed a tear over have more going for them than that, but they're not a concern because they don't "Show their moves."

Cap is just another fish in an ocean full of characters with people who love them. My point is that if Smash were cut down, it wouldn't be some fantasy that got rid of all the characters people don't like and none of the ones they do, it would be an objective culling that would only include the characters they know they can turn a profit marketing with. And Captain Falcon isn't one of them.
Id really miss Bayonetta. And if Villager is gone, Id be even more sad
 
Last edited:

Autumn ♫

I'm terrible with these Custom Titles.
Joined
Apr 20, 2013
Messages
7,147
Location
Sakurai's Secret Headquarters
So, I attempted to make a Brawl sized Smash 5 Roster



I honestly think this would be as good as it could get without losing anyone too important, and even then, I cut some good characters (like Palutena, Megaman, the Miis gimmick, WFT, Lucina, among a few others)
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member

Guest
The problem with rebooting Smash is that it's big because of the characters more so than ANYTHING, there's a reaaon why character speculation is by far the most prominent and important than anything else.

Downgrading the size with a similiar roster would easily be banned regardleas of how good the competive gameplay and balance is.

Competetive players who want a smaller roster for the sake of the competetive scene are more self rightious than people that want *insert charactet here*

I hope they don't pander to the competetive scene and put in much less content, that's what killed SFV...
I'm gonna go crazy.
I was promised a February 2nd release so if Nintendo plans on delaying the game for the americas, then say it already!
Saaaame, uuuuuuuggggh. I really want to play it.
 

Cutie Gwen

Lovely warrior
Joined
Jul 1, 2014
Messages
64,226
Location
Somewhere out there on this big blue marble
Who said it would be 20 characters?

If Sakurai doesn't return (which he likely won't), it's the perfect reason for a reboot, and he's the one you're quoting saying "20 is ideal" I'm sure many would disagree.

What would a reboot be?

SFII > SFIII or SFIII > SFIV or SFIV > SFV, or what Guilty Gear Xrd is to the XX series. It's happened dozens of times with fighting games, and is essentially a staple of the franchise. Excessively large rosters are in fact a problem for fighting games due to balance issues. In fact, when rosters are picked for new installments in a fighting game, they're typically done by selecting certain characters that might best highlight some of the new mechanics, all the while still adding staples and familiar faces.

And I think you're overestimating how much backlash it would get. Nintendo has done this many times before (WindWaker), and people have coped just fine. It wouldn't bleed anything. If a reboot gets a lot of praise for trying new things, and etc... all the people throwing a hissy fit would eat their words and cave in anyway. There's nowhere else to go with the Smash series from here. You run a very serious risk of getting a lot of backlash from burnout if you retread your steps for a 5th time. A 5th Smash is unlikely to get Cloud, Ryu and a bunch of others to return, but mere virtue of that, it'll already be seen as inferior to it. And Smash 4 already exists, people can easily replay that installment if they wanna play as those characters. For one, that's a very Nintendo mentality, as they've literally said what I just said, and two, it's not uncommon of the Smash fanbase to cling to older games, (Melee) nor has this affected sales of future games.

Finally, it's very unreasonable to demand more and more and more and more each time. It's already reached a point, where more is simply too costly, and demands way too much work. EVERY character would need new models, animations, etc... and they would all need to be re-balanced, and reprogrammed (new engine, thus, a simple import doesn't quite work), for... what? 70+ characters?

An expanded port of 4, guaranteed, then a bit of break, and then a reboot. Mark my words.
Wind Waker isn't a reboot, it was always seen as a sequel, a new Zelda game with new adventures. Not to mention a reboot isn't a single game, but a new series of games. The Zelda timeline has been split up to multiple points, so if anything, it's a sidepath. And a fighting game suddenly having a lot less characters WILL provide backlash, if Mewtwo, a character people didn't even play as that much in Melee, had THAT much fan demand, imagine the outrage for over 30 characters being cut. Not to mention it's easier to port the models and animations, etc. Who says a new engine is necessary? "It's unreasonable to demand more" but it's unreasonable to give less. The whole point of Smash is "Fight with your favourite Nintendo characters!", other fighting games aren't mascot fighters, the appeal to other fighting games are, well, the fighting, not so much the characters. Make a 20 character roster and try to do so in a way in which people wouldn't feel upset due to the loss of their favourite characters, like Street Fighter 3 learned the hard way

Also Shishi your waifu is ****, Nino can't read
 

Metal Shop X

CHAINSAW POWEEEEEEEER
Joined
May 4, 2015
Messages
26,850
Location
USA
NNID
Mao644
3DS FC
4339-3012-0905
Switch FC
SW-2905-0652-6700
And no one thinks of all the fans of other characters that would be upset?

Does no one think anyone would miss :4sonic::4megaman::4pacman::4ryu::4cloud::4bayonetta:?

Or how about :4lucario::4jigglypuff::4greninja:?

Would anyone miss :4falco:, I wonder?

People already miss :snake::wolf::popo: extremely badly. Now multiply that by a dozen.

Captain Falcon is not more special than any of the other characters that people care about just because he's a meme. From an objective standpoint he has some of the least to bring to a Nintendo crossover and is largely just riding off of recursive Smash popularity. Most other characters that people wouldn't even shed a tear over have more going for them than that, but they're not a concern because they don't "Show their moves."

Cap is just another fish in an ocean full of characters with people who love them. My point is that if Smash were cut down, it wouldn't be some fantasy that got rid of all the characters people don't like and none of the ones they do, it would be an objective culling that would only include the characters they know they can turn a profit marketing with. And Captain Falcon isn't one of them.
Yeah, but :4falcon: would cause alot more peoples angry because of the state of his franchise and how he is a emblematic to the Smash series.
It will be like removing Ryu from a Street Fighter game. Did you know that, Third Strike wasn't supposed to bring back any old character at all? Well guess what, the fan didn't like it. And judging from what I heard, there must be ALOOOT of cry if Capcom decided to bring back Ryu and Ken.

Really tough, this idea of a reboot is terrible. Making a roster smaller where the iconic twelve veteran not here wouldn't be great at all. Because if we go with that, do we have to remove :4samus: because her franchise isn't popular anymore? Do we have to remove:4luigi: because Mario is more iconic? Do we have to remove :4fox: because Star Fox Zero didn't sell enough?

Man, **** this ****, I hate when peoples want to remove old character because their favourite character didn't get in, **** that, I'm out of this debate.:4charizard:
 
Last edited:

Autumn ♫

I'm terrible with these Custom Titles.
Joined
Apr 20, 2013
Messages
7,147
Location
Sakurai's Secret Headquarters
I don't think we'll ever get a reboot. Sakurai already did state he hated seeing characters be cut because each character has their own fanbase. Rebooting the roster would not only do that, but do it to a much higher extreme than any game previously.

That, and characters sell the game, losing a bunch of characters, and only putting in a few newcomers would definitely turn off a lot of Smash fans.
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
Wind Waker isn't a reboot, it was always seen as a sequel, a new Zelda game with new adventures. Not to mention a reboot isn't a single game, but a new series of games. The Zelda timeline has been split up to multiple points, so if anything, it's a sidepath. And a fighting game suddenly having a lot less characters WILL provide backlash, if Mewtwo, a character people didn't even play as that much in Melee, had THAT much fan demand, imagine the outrage for over 30 characters being cut. Not to mention it's easier to port the models and animations, etc. Who says a new engine is necessary? "It's unreasonable to demand more" but it's unreasonable to give less. The whole point of Smash is "Fight with your favourite Nintendo characters!", other fighting games aren't mascot fighters, the appeal to other fighting games are, well, the fighting, not so much the characters. Make a 20 character roster and try to do so in a way in which people wouldn't feel upset due to the loss of their favourite characters, like Street Fighter 3 learned the hard way

Also Shishi your waifu is ****, Nino can't read
Here's a simple challenge for everyone ITT:

Make an appealing 35 character Smash 5 roster, under the assumption that every returning character is getting a revamped moveset. Either upgraded, or totally redone. Be sure to include new faces. No 3rd parties allowed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Opossum

Thread Title Changer
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
34,183
Location
This Thread
NNID
OpossumGuy
3DS FC
4742-4911-3431
Switch FC
SW 2859 6322 5208
To lighten the mood, here's a Smash hypothetical.

You were brought aboard by Sakurai to choose new characters for a Smash 4 Switch port. When asked how many, Sakurai smirks and says five. Five! Wow! Before now you thought that impossible...but there's a catch.

You must pick:

- One returning veteran
- One newcomer from an already-present Nintendo series
- One newcomer from a new Nintendo series
- One new third party character (must be an unrepresented franchise and must have appeared on a Nintendo system)
- ...And a Fire Emblem character.

Under these circumstances, which five characters would you pick?


Edit: Also Manly's challenge since I've been Ninja'd. :p
 
Last edited:

NonSpecificGuy

Hell’s Worst Nightmare
Super Moderator
Premium
Writing Team
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
14,056
Location
Mother Base
NNID
Goldeneye2674
3DS FC
0989-1770-6584
Can I please GET MY ****ING FIRE EMBLEM HEROES YET?!?!?!?!
 

FalKoopa

Rainbow Waifu
BRoomer
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
32,231
Location
India/भारत
3DS FC
1650-3685-3998
Switch FC
SW-5545-7990-4793
I understand flops speak louder than success, but I don't think that's reason enough to not look into an idea. It's more just an example of how not to handle something.
The biggest issue with SFV isn't even that they employed such a model, but that the rest of the game was lacking content. Things that would have been standard in other games.
You look at something like Killer Instinct, MKX, even Smash 4, and those issues aren't anywhere near as pronounced because a lot of the things that would be expected are already there.

Halo 5 almost suffered a similar fate, but thankfully, 343i fixed most of their issues quick.
That's why I said, "for now".

Nintendo has been much better about their DLC and other practices, so I have faith that they can do it well, but until SFV goes out of the public eye, I think they should not attempt it due the bad PR that would result.
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member

Guest
And no one thinks of all the fans of other characters that would be upset?

Does no one think anyone would miss :4sonic::4megaman::4pacman::4ryu::4cloud::4bayonetta:?

Or how about :4lucario::4jigglypuff::4greninja:?

Would anyone miss :4falco:, I wonder?

People already miss :snake::wolf::popo: extremely badly. Now multiply that by a dozen.

Captain Falcon is not more special than any of the other characters that people care about just because he's a meme. From an objective standpoint he has some of the least to bring to a Nintendo crossover and is largely just riding off of recursive Smash popularity. Most other characters that people wouldn't even shed a tear over have more going for them than that, but they're not a concern because they don't "Show their moves."

Cap is just another fish in an ocean full of characters with people who love them. My point is that if Smash were cut down, it wouldn't be some fantasy that got rid of all the characters people don't like and none of the ones they do, it would be an objective culling that would only include the characters they know they can turn a profit marketing with. And Captain Falcon isn't one of them.
You don't understand, even outside of memes Captain Falcon is simply a smash icon, it's as simple as that. What are you going to say next, remove Master Hand because he's not making a profit.

Man, that's one of the problems with gaming nowadays is that people forget that games can and should take creative and expressive libreties, not everything has to be marketable.(For instance, why the hell would we even have retro characters then? They're from games that haven't been relevant in market for years and years...)

Man, I miss politics...
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Coricus

Woom-em-my?
Joined
Feb 19, 2015
Messages
14,055
Switch FC
SW 4794 7152 2904
To lighten the mood, here's a Smash hypothetical.

You were brought aboard by Sakurai to choose new characters for a Smash 4 Switch port. When asked how many, Sakurai smirks and says five. Five! Wow! Before now you thought that impossible...but there's a catch.

You must pick:

- One returning veteran
- One newcomer from an already-present Nintendo series
- One newcomer from a new Nintendo series
- One new third party character (must be an unrepresented franchise and must have appeared on a Nintendo system)
- ...And a Fire Emblem character.

Under these circumstances, which five characters would you pick?


Edit: Also Manly's challenge since I've been Ninja'd. :p
Wolf
K. Rool
Inkling
Jibanyan
Caeda

And there you have a roster. The last two are gonna make the world burn, but there you go.
 

Autumn ♫

I'm terrible with these Custom Titles.
Joined
Apr 20, 2013
Messages
7,147
Location
Sakurai's Secret Headquarters
Here's a simple challenge for everyone ITT:

Make an appealing 35 character Smash 5 roster, under the assumption that every returning character is getting a revamped moveset. Either upgraded, or totally redone. Be sure to include new faces. No 3rd parties allowed.
This minus Pac-Man and Sonic (Because rules), Mii, and Zero Suit Samus.

To lighten the mood, here's a Smash hypothetical.

You were brought aboard by Sakurai to choose new characters for a Smash 4 Switch port. When asked how many, Sakurai smirks and says five. Five! Wow! Before now you thought that impossible...but there's a catch.

You must pick:

- One returning veteran
- One newcomer from an already-present Nintendo series
- One newcomer from a new Nintendo series
- One new third party character (must be an unrepresented franchise and must have appeared on a Nintendo system)
- ...And a Fire Emblem character.

Under these circumstances, which five characters would you pick?


Edit: Also Manly's challenge since I've been Ninja'd. :p
Only one new Fire Emblem character? I would have wanted more :laugh:

- Ice Climbers, because fan demand
- Vaati :p
- Callie & Marie
- Jack Frost
- I think I'd go with Anna on this one.
 

praline

the white witch
Joined
Feb 16, 2014
Messages
50,853
Location
the underworld
Switch FC
6178 82674988
So for my FE Advance Wars you gotta choose both the gun and the ammo(unless they use grenades as they're weapon type then just ammo).

Guns have infinite uses and are where the strength, accuracy, etc are calculated but without ammo is like sending a unit in FE without a weapon. Ammo are finite uses and effect your attacks by either giving it a secondary effect(like silver bullets doing extra damage to monsters) or just raising a stat(slugs dealing less damage but better accuracy).

:p
 

Kirby Dragons

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 30, 2014
Messages
5,295
Location
Another Dimension
Here's a simple challenge for everyone ITT:

Make an appealing 35 character Smash 5 roster, under the assumption that every returning character is getting a revamped moveset. Either upgraded, or totally redone. Be sure to include new faces. No 3rd parties allowed.
  1. Mario
  2. Luweegee
  3. Peach
  4. Bowser
  5. Rosalina & Luma
  6. Wario
  7. Yoshi
  8. Donkey Kong
  9. Diddy Kong
  10. Link
  11. Zelda
  12. Ganondorf
  13. Midna
  14. Pikachu
  15. Charizard
  16. Greninja
  17. Decidueye
  18. Kirby
  19. King Dedede
  20. Meta Knight
  21. Bandana Waddle Dee
  22. Spring Man
  23. Inkling
  24. Marth
  25. Ike
  26. Robin
  27. Fox
  28. Falco
  29. Samus
  30. Federation Force Soldier
  31. Captain Falcon
  32. Villager
  33. Olimar
  34. Shulk
  35. Pit
 

Swamp Sensei

Today is always the most enjoyable day!
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
39,229
Location
Um....Lost?
NNID
Swampasaur
3DS FC
4141-2776-0914
Switch FC
SW-6476-1588-8392
- One returning veteran
:wolf:/:popo:

Probably :popo:.

Sorry :wolf:.

Sorry :snake:.

- One newcomer from an already-present Nintendo series
K.Rool
- One newcomer from a new Nintendo series
Inkling.

- One new third party character (must be an unrepresented franchise and must have appeared on a Nintendo system)
Hmm.....

My heart says Phoenix Wright.

My brain say Rayman.

Get those western characters in there.

...And a Fire Emblem character.
************....

Uh....

Ephriam.
 

PsychoIncarnate

The Eternal Will of the Swarm
Joined
Jul 4, 2007
Messages
50,641
Location
Char
NNID
PsychoIncarnate
3DS FC
4554-0155-5885
What they should do for the next smash is make it free but only have Mario as a playable character and release the rest at a cost to download
 

Cutie Gwen

Lovely warrior
Joined
Jul 1, 2014
Messages
64,226
Location
Somewhere out there on this big blue marble
Here's a list of characters I'd personally be pissed about leaving
:4bayonetta:She got in BECAUSE of fan demand, cutting her means pissing off all those fans
:4bowser:One of the most popular Mario characters and a personal favourite
:4falcon:THE Smash Bros character
:4charizard:Sure, I suck as him, but he's fun and one of the most popular mons in the franchise
:4cloud:The character almost everybody on the planet ended up jizzing themselves about
:4corrinf:No other Nintendo character, perhaps even video game character for that matter, can imitate her unique yet fun style
:4dedede:Look at this jolly fat ****. Harming him in any way strikes everyone with grief
:4dk:It's on like Donkey Kong became a thing for a reason
:4ganondorf:One of the most fun characters to play as when you're with lots of friends
:4greninja:My favourite pokemon
:4myfriends:One of my favourite characters in the franchise
:4jigglypuff:Hilarious concept, and don't tell me you wouldn't miss landing Rest
:4kirby:Kirby's NEVER had a bad game, so if he gets cut, I'd cut the guy/gal who made that decision
:4littlemac:Is this a JoJo reference? Always satisfying to punch everything
:4mario:The Mickey Mouse of video games
:4marth:An incredibly fun character who reflects multiple aspects from his series which has become a major IP after 2 successful games
:4megaman:I was literally born on this guy's 10th birthday, his games have aged surprisingly well
:4metaknight:Absolute bad ass
:4mewtwo:Had SO many requests just to get back in
:4pikachu:You can't NOT have Pikachu
:4rob:Best joke character in the franchise
:4robinf:Very fun and unique character, the perfect character to reflect on Awakening's success
:4ryu:Without Ryu, it doesn't even feel like a real fighting game anymore
:4samus:/:4zss:Metroid fans have gotten enough ****
:4shulk:Sexy nekkid costume+British accent+Project Rainfall
:4sonic:Who DIDN'T want to see these two fight?

To lighten the mood, here's a Smash hypothetical.

You were brought aboard by Sakurai to choose new characters for a Smash 4 Switch port. When asked how many, Sakurai smirks and says five. Five! Wow! Before now you thought that impossible...but there's a catch.

You must pick:

- One returning veteran
- One newcomer from an already-present Nintendo series
- One newcomer from a new Nintendo series
- One new third party character (must be an unrepresented franchise and must have appeared on a Nintendo system)
- ...And a Fire Emblem character.

Under these circumstances, which five characters would you pick?


Edit: Also Manly's challenge since I've been Ninja'd. :p
Easy, Wolf, Ridley, Takamaru, Shovel Knight and Hector. Hardest part was Lyn or Hector
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom