Ax00x0
Smash Apprentice
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2008
- Messages
- 98
I'll throw my 2 cents down:
For specifics, I agree with the DDD, Goyf presents a good argument for the IC but they could probably use a limitation if need be, and I dunno enough about Pika's to give an opinion.
I'd want Norfair and Pictochat legal, especially since Norfair helps for a lot of matches (Snake, ROB, etc.) I'm not too adament on Pictochat or Pirate ship, but I'd be more for chat and less for ship. But whatever.
Agreed, SBR can reall go suck a fat one. I'd really be all for severing from them completely after Genesis, in fact. And agreed on the doubles infinite grabs.As for the doubles chain grab (grab release > grab by other partner) that stupid **** is banned. Any and all things that are debateable can be debated upon by us, the NM smashers. I'm tired of relying on a bunch of morons (read: the back room) only to get rulesets that essentially CRAVE the stagnation, and ultimately, the failure of Brawl's metagame.
I may be the vocal minority here, but in my views, ALL CG's should have a cap of 3, with standing infities (DDD, all those who can abuse Wario/Ness) flat out banned. The reason is simple: even if you don't get 0-death from Falco or whoever, you're still getting a guarenteed 30%+ damage, situations permitted, all because your opponent can hit V+Z. This wouldn't make match ups like Wario vs DDD, DK vs Wario, Falco vs Everyone, etc. horribly one sided match ups. There just ins't a good reason a handful of the cast should get a lot of free damage for doing minimal work.Things to be debated upon:
DDD's standing infinite- currently banned, and for good reason
IC's infinites- takes a lot more skill to perform than DDD's, but they can use a limitation if need be
Pikachu's buffered CG's- I don't know how difficult these may be, but in all honesty I believe they should at the very least be limited to something like 50% or so. Pika against Falco/fox/Wolf are ALL unwinnable for the spacies anymore. Sad story.
For specifics, I agree with the DDD, Goyf presents a good argument for the IC but they could probably use a limitation if need be, and I dunno enough about Pika's to give an opinion.
Like Goyf said, what are the specifics about this? I'm interested because as Pit main, I end up using the ledge a lot, obviously.Planking- banned as of now, but if you guys absolutely want it for whatever reason, we can talk about it
No argument here.Trash-talk/rage during and after matches- sportsmanship's a must guys, if anything this is just a reminder but we need to keep our cool in and out of match, as well as not seem condescending/discouraging to new people that come to the scene
Agreed, especially since it hasn't been monitored in the last few tournies...not that there is anyone specific to blame, just saying. Also agree with the MK rule, but a better one would be "How 'bout we all not be gay and don't use him."Double blind picks- the first round sets the tone for the rest of the set in any match. Being that we all know each other's mains pretty well, we need to start doing double blind picking processes, starting with this Saturday.
MK- what I just stated above goes hand in hand with what I'm about to say; if you plan on choosing MK for the first round in the set, I believe your opponent should be allowed to choose their best character against you. The reasoning behind this is simple: MK has no bad match-ups, only even ones, those in his favor, and those that can be won without use of the c-stick or A button. The most this rule could do is to make it an even game.
I'd say no for PS1 being neutral-too much random ****, there's the glitch on the desert part where you can't rolldoge on the right edge, the EDGES in general are ******** and hard to grab/use...counter pick for sure, but neutral? No. I don't care about Lylat one way or another, but it can be neutral.Stage legality- What should be banned? What shouldn't? I'd like for us to discuss PS1 as a starter in place of Lylat, as well as pictochat being made legal again.
I'd want Norfair and Pictochat legal, especially since Norfair helps for a lot of matches (Snake, ROB, etc.) I'm not too adament on Pictochat or Pirate ship, but I'd be more for chat and less for ship. But whatever.