My Mafia Academia -- ENDGAME: Bites Za Dusto

[Pokechu]

yeah, I read the last two or three pages just in case I missed anything but I haven't

lemme jot down some notes to see what I'm feeling

 

[praline]

Alright praline just one question
If you did investigate him, why did you bother briefly voting for him?

EDIT: Annoying typo (both -> bother)

Cause I don’t know 100% that he’s a townie, but from what I’ve gotten I firmly believe that he should be town.

 

[Lore]

Pyra The "what did you learn" was in reference to the post I made saying that I had big news, awkwardly posted right as the Day began. I thought the night phase was over.

 

[Z25]

Cause I don’t know 100% that he’s a townie, but from what I’ve gotten I firmly believe that he should be town.

what made you think the result could be wrong?

You claimed a female character. However no female works as an investigatir afaik. There’s a cop who’s a recurring character but he’s male. None of the females introduced past season 1 are investigators of any kind.

If you don’t mind asking who is your character?

 

[praline]

what made you think the result could be wrong?

You claimed a female character. However no female works as an investigatir afaik. There’s a cop who’s a recurring character but he’s male. None of the females introduced past season 1 are investigators of any kind.

If you don’t mind asking who is your character?

I’m Ragdoll.

 

[praline]

what made you think the result could be wrong?

You claimed a female character. However no female works as an investigatir afaik. There’s a cop who’s a recurring character but he’s male. None of the females introduced past season 1 are investigators of any kind.

If you don’t mind asking who is your character?

I accidentally hit post reply. I’m not a regular cop. My quirk ability is a one time use where I can look at their role pm. Ability names and alignment are not included.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Yo guys! I haven't read anything for 8-9 hours or something like that, but I DO remember that we were putting a bunch of pressure on Z25. I'm going to start off with an unvote to relieve Z25 some stress and so that I can make sense of everything, because there are a bunch of text to read. We were kind of blindly going after Z25, and while there was a good initiative to it, I've been thinking that we were reading too much into Z's flavor speculation as a scum slip, when they were just trying to help out, even if they were persistent about it. Now hopefully you aren't still berating each other by now.

 

[Pyra]

Pyra The "what did you learn" was in reference to the post I made saying that I had big news, awkwardly posted right as the Day began. I thought the night phase was over.

Fair enough tbh
Like I said, I only skimmed.

 

[Pyra]

I accidentally hit post reply. I’m not a regular cop. My quirk ability is a one time use where I can look at their role pm. Ability names and alignment are not included.

And he's definitely Shinzo then?

 

[praline]

And he's definitely Shinzo then?

Yeah. The only reason I was hesitant on him 100% being town is cause he seemed creepy in the anime so I assumed he would become a villain at some point lol

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Top 3 Susp:

1. Z25. While I am willing to give leniency in this direction, there is still a lot of evidence in this direction that they still earn the top spot. Not much we can really do.

2. Golden. Once again, if Z25 flips town, Golden must be telling a blatant lie. I might have missed something, but I believe this is still true.

3. Werekill. Less impacted if Z25 flips town, but still is undeniably cast with a bad light if Z25 gets lynched.

Now these aren't the best reads in the world, I was trying to write this during the MHA advertisement break, but I believe these hold true for now. I don't really see anything scummy about praline at the moment, which is why my top scum reads are unaffected. I would keep my vote on Z, but Z has done a lot for his case since he was first accused of being scum. We'll see how this turns out.

 

[Maven89]

Sorry going to have to replace out

 

[Pyra]

Yeah. The only reason I was hesitant on him 100% being town is cause he seemed creepy in the anime so I assumed he would become a villain at some point lol

In the interest of progress I'm going to choose to believe this, meaning that Praline and Z are town.

I'm not trying to say I'm correct of course, but I'm going to pick this line of reasoning for now to see where it leads.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Sorry going to have to replace out

*Sees Maven notification* YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS...OOOoooooooh. Oh.

 

[Pyra]

2. Golden. Once again, if Z25 flips town, Golden must be telling a blatant lie. I might have missed something, but I believe this is still true.

Could you extrapolate on why you believe this?

 

[Deleted member]

Sorry going to have to replace out

Well, guess I'll look into that then. Brb.

 

[Z25]

I’m Ragdoll.

I accidentally hit post reply. I’m not a regular cop. My quirk ability is a one time use where I can look at their role pm. Ability names and alignment are not included.

I see this makes a lot of sense.

As for my charcter, hats kind of the point. Spoilers below but he’s one of the best written characters I’ve seen:

Spoiler

All his life he’s been desperately trying to be a hero. However because his quirk brainwashes people he was already judged and bullied as a kid for having a power that only a “villain” would use. Because of this and the fact that his quirk is very good but hard too pull off, he wound up in normal courses at ua and was rejected from the hero course.

However with the sports festival he has a chance to be put into the hero course if he does well and the school changes their mind. So he works his hardest to overcome everything so far and show he’s a good guy who wants nothing more then to help others. He almost beats Deku too by getting under his skin and baiting Deku into answering questions.

However Deku’s willpower and the power from the previous one for all users help him get a little control back allowing him to win by pushing shinzo out of the ring for a knockout.

Shinzo gets a small spotlight but grows really well in the end. It’s a great development for his charcter.

 

[Pyra]

Going through old posts again to see if I can pull ANYTHING out lol

But anyway, the point is that, if Goldie's role is correct, both Z and I should've been notified. I wasn't.

I wonder.
If Z's quirk didn't work due to Were's being a passive at the time (I'm not sure if y'all finished deliberating that yet), then I could see it being the case that the target was canceled as well, meaning you were the only one who targeted him.

Right?

 

[Pyra]

So if I'm going to follow this hypothetical train of thought (Praline and Z are not lying), then Praline and Z are town.

A lot of implications earlier were based on assumptions and miscommunications, so I still can't really tell anyone for Scum.

As far as anyone knows, both of the AFK people/replacements could be scum.

 

[praline]

I see this makes a lot of sense.

As for my charcter, hats kind of the point. Spoilers below but he’s one of the best written characters I’ve seen:

Spoiler

All his life he’s been desperately trying to be a hero. However because his quirk brainwashes people he was already judged and bullied as a kid for having a power that only a “villain” would use. Because of this and the fact that his quirk is very good but hard too pull off, he wound up in normal courses at ua and was rejected from the hero course.

However with the sports festival he has a chance to be put into the hero course if he does well and the school changes their mind. So he works his hardest to overcome everything so far and show he’s a good guy who wants nothing more then to help others. He almost beats Deku too by getting under his skin and baiting Deku into answering questions.

However Deku’s willpower and the power from the previous one for all users help him get a little control back allowing him to win by pushing shinzo out of the ring for a knockout.

Shinzo gets a small spotlight but grows really well in the end. It’s a great development for his charcter.

I might have to go back and keep watching MHA after this game is done.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Could you extrapolate on why you believe this?

*Reactionary image from MHA that I can't seem to upload here for some reason...*

This was in reference back to when Golden claimed he received no "you were targeted to be killed" spiel from Shish last night. Sorry I didn't get back to you sooner, I was failing at posting an image here. I'll try to find more info on that after the episode.

 

[Pyra]

*Reactionary image from MHA that I can't seem to upload here for some reason...*

This was in reference back to when Golden claimed he received no "you were targeted to be killed" spiel from Shish last night. Sorry I didn't get back to you sooner, I was failing at posting an image here. I'll try to find more info on that after the episode.

No worries.

I still don't actually understand (maybe I'm having a brain fart here) but according to the lore so far, he wasn't targeted by a killer, right? Why would this make him a liar?

Did I miss something huge?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

There are two possibilities here.

1. Z's redirect does not affect passives, and he already said that he received word that his ability does not affect every ability.

2. Z is lying and has not done a redirect. This is doubly so if Golden is telling the truth.

I was thinking about the inverse of possibility two Pyra

 

[Ura]

So going back to the Shiny topic (since I got the chance to re-read D1)...

I don't think we gave it enough that as to the ones who voted for him. The users in question being The Stoopid Unikorn Lore Z25 @GoldenYuiitusin (would later remove his vote) and giraffelasergun

What I find odd about the situation is that somehow towards the later parts of the phase, Golden backs off from voting Shiny despite him being the clear lynch target and Giraffe all of a sudden gets in on the action and hops the bandwagon.

I don't know about you guys but that seems incredibly sus. Golden taking his vote off and then Giraffe going right in as to disassociate themselves. Maybe not so much a hard, definitive scum read but i'm still weary.

In any case, this is how my Top 3 Sus List looks like...

1. Z25
2. Giraffe
3. Golden

Uni and Praline i'm also kinda skept on along with Doop from D1 but these 3 are what i'm leaning on the most as being scum.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

I wonder.
If Z's quirk didn't work due to Were's being a passive at the time (I'm not sure if y'all finished deliberating that yet), then I could see it being the case that the target was canceled as well, meaning you were the only one who targeted him.

Right?

That's what I'm thinking.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

*Reactionary image from MHA that I can't seem to upload here for some reason...*

Try Ctrl+P, then pasting the link

 

[Pyra]

In any case, this is how my Top 3 Sus List looks like...

1. Z25
2. Giraffe
3. Golden

I'm thinking that if Z25 is scum, Praline also has to be.
P claimed investigative role and confirmed Z's character.

 

[Pyra]

I'd put money on one of the scum being one of the people here that haven't been a focus yet.

Someone besides Z, Were, Golden...
Not that all three of them are innocent either, but I'm sitting here thinking that someone's probably getting a free ride here due to being low-key compared to the argumentative essay troupe + Golden

Maybe I need to read back... again...

 

[praline]

I'd put money on one of the scum being one of the people here that haven't been a focus yet.

Someone besides Z, Were, Golden...
Not that all three of them are innocent either, but I'm sitting here thinking that someone's probably getting a free ride here due to being low-key compared to the argumentative essay troupe + Golden

Maybe I need to read back... again...

There is also the possibility that Maven and Joja actually could be both villains.

 

[Ura]

I don't think we gave it enough that

*I don't think we gave it enough thought*

Just wanted to clarify my typo.

 

[Ura]

I'm thinking that if Z25 is scum, Praline also has to be.
P claimed investigative role and confirmed Z's character.

Oh yeah def. With certain flips, we can deduce the links some users will have.

I just find Giraffe's sudden inclination to vote right at the end of D1 to be odd given Shiny had no chance there. And Golden seemed to conveniently back off sometime before him. We need to take this in to account because this could be a ploy to differentiate themselves.

 

[Pyra]

There is also the possibility that Maven and Joja actually could be both villains.

Yes, but we can't do anything about that right now, unfortunately.

So, trying to prove the innocence of people who ARE active would help. The downside is that it's likely roles get revealed that way.
Like I said, I'm currently taking the stance that you and Z are town, but I don't know how to follow through from there.
People say this would implicate Golden, but I'm not sure he's done anything that would do that.

There's also Pokechu, Ura, Unikorn, Myself, and Utopian. (And Were and Golden). And some others I might be forgetting... lol.
But mainly the first five.

I think the whole conundrum triangle between Z, Golden, and Were could be explained, so I no longer feel safe trying to accuse any of them at the moment.
There are too many people right now that are ??? status for me, lol.

 

[Pyra]

Oh yeah, also Giraffe to that list

 

[Maven89]

Never mind I decided to stick around but won’t be able to post or dive in until tomorrow

If there’s major objection to my absense I can still replace out

 

[Z25]

I'd put money on one of the scum being one of the people here that haven't been a focus yet.

Someone besides Z, Were, Golden...
Not that all three of them are innocent either, but I'm sitting here thinking that someone's probably getting a free ride here due to being low-key compared to the argumentative essay troupe + Golden

Maybe I need to read back... again...

I honestly agree.

Decent candidates imo would be pokechu, utopia, ura and praline. I’m more inclined to believe praline is town though with today’s events.

Pokechu is the best bet imo as he sort of shows up posts one thing and then disappears. He’s active but it’s also kind of a minimum amount of posting imo.

Utopia isn’t to familiar with flavor which would explain some of his actions buts he’s still reletavily active so I’m 50/50 on him coasting.

Lastly ura has activity that falls between pokechu and utopia imo. He posts a lot of reads but he also mentions catching up a lot.

So he could also be trying to just cost by costabtly playing catch-up.

The problem is it’s hard to narrow down any of those though

 

[Deleted member]

My vote for Shiny was because he was seemingly avoiding this thread, which was suspicious.
I took my vote off once he started being active.

Context clues, Ura.

 

[Z25]

Never mind I decided to stick around but won’t be able to post or dive in until tomorrow

If there’s major objection to my absense I can still replace out

If your able to stay then I say stay. It’s a lot of reading to do though, but we could probably catch you up a bit.

However,

@Shishœ what will be done about joja?

 

[Deleted member]

If your able to stay then I say stay. It’s a lot of reading to do though, but we could probably catch you up a bit.

However,

@Shishœ what will be done about joja?

If he doesn't show up by the end of this phase, we'll replace him out. We're already looking for someone to replace him, though.

 

[Pokechu]

I honestly agree.

Decent candidates imo would be pokechu, utopia, ura and praline. I’m more inclined to believe praline is town though with today’s events.

Pokechu is the best bet imo as he sort of shows up posts one thing and then disappears. He’s active but it’s also kind of a minimum amount of posting imo.

Utopia isn’t to familiar with flavor which would explain some of his actions buts he’s still reletavily active so I’m 50/50 on him coasting.

Lastly ura has activity that falls between pokechu and utopia imo. He posts a lot of reads but he also mentions catching up a lot.

So he could also be trying to just cost by costabtly playing catch-up.

The problem is it’s hard to narrow down any of those though

why does activity have anything to do with being scum? the gamestate just sucks, it's no wonder joja hasn't showed up with how toxic this thread has been

ooooooo roast

but yeah the toxicity really burnt me out already, I'll keep working on rereading some posts though to see if I get anything. I was already OK with you and praline from the start so nothing's changed there.

 

[Ura]

My vote for Shiny was because he was seemingly avoiding this thread, which was suspicious.
I took my vote off once he started being active.

Context clues, Ura.

Noted. But it still doesn't come across well given the nature of how the phase ended.

Shiny was in a predicament where just about nothing could save him from being lynched. So regardless of the circumstance, Giraffe's vote for Shiny is off-putting. Coming at the end of the phase where Shiny had virtually no chance of surviving.