Ok, I'm only going to make serious posts henceforth.
this is looking past your comment about how melee has no combo's or edgeguards, because clearly it does and to disagree with that would only serve 1 purpose which would be to troll, and the only reason I can fathom that you would make such a statement (any of you) would be to imply that your game is 'better' than another
When did I say anything about smash64 being better than melee? I'm not the one implying that one game is better than another; that's what I feel like everyone else is doing.
It was an obvious exaggeration to say that Melee has NO combos or edgeguards. Particularly for edgeguards. Relative to smash64 though, there are fewer (especially combos) as far as I can tell.
Of course, I thought that it would come through that I was exaggerating. Perhaps that was silly of me. But anyway, I get responses like "just watch any high level match and you'll see tons of z2d combos". I think I've watched a fair amount of high level matches, and I don't see many at all. So I asked for some examples.
I don't think z2d happens often even in 64, so it surprised me.
if you're basing the worth of a game strictly on combo's, then 64 wins
if you're basing it strictly on edgeguards, then again 64 wins
I was talking about videos only. Edgeguards and combos are two things that I would consider exciting.
but if you're choosing not to look at the traits that melee has over 64 then you're promoting ignorance to yourself and to others
It's all subjective, but I was outlining two traits of smash64 videos that I find entertaining.
if you like and enjoy your game moreso than the others, then by all means play it
but if you need to demerit the worth of another game so that you can feel better about your own game then you might want to re-evaluate why you're playing your game at all
peace
Once again, I never said anything about smash64 being better than Melee. Although Melee players should definitely take this advice with respect to brawl
I am not trolling. You REALLY suck at detecting trolls. I was referring to the several threads that have gone down in the past (one of 'em was like "why do we like smash 64" or something like that) wherein 64 people have basically gone "we have online, but melee's better otherwise." That pisses me off. You+Peek+randomd00ds were reminding me of that, even though you (in this case) didn't say anything about melee being better as a game. Long story short: "I like melee vids better" is OK, "64 vids succckckk there aren't any good ones" is something you can go tell the melee video section.
Pretty much this. There are about 5 posts in this thread about how Melee videos are better. It's fine to have that opinion, but when you post about that in the smash64 video forum when a guy asks for good smash64 videos, you're asking for it.
I remember a while back some troll came into the main forum and posted something along the lines of "WHY DO U NOOBZ PLAY SMASH64 JUST PLAY MELEE INSTAD LOLZ". It's ok for him to have his opinion, but it's not really welcome in the smash64 forum, and he got flamed until mods closed the thread.
Let me clarify that I DEFINITELY don't think that any of the posts were on that level. But c'mon you can take a little heat.