Lovely Complex
KashiMashi: Girl meets girl
AIR
Fruit Basket
Are you guys even looking at the animes he listed? They're nothing like Darker than Black or Yakitate Japan! (unless he wants comedy animes that have no romance at all)
Welcome to the NHK might be in his tastes, though.
As for my own suggestions based on this list...
- Kanon 2006 ( not the original! The remake is 10x better )
- Clannad
- KimiKiss Pure Rouge
- Kimi ga Nozomu Eien
- Shuffle!
- REC ( very short, though )
- Onegai Teacher
- Onegai Twins
- Koi Kaze ( warning; delicious loli )
- To Heart 2 ( very laid back, though, but if you don't mind a smooth ride, it's awesome. Never saw the original series, though )
- Asatte No Houkou
- Tsukuyomi Moon Phase
- True Tears
- Ef - A Tale of Memories
If you don't mind the violence and extreme drama:
- School Days
- Myself, Yourself
These should satisfy your desire for romance/comedy/drama for some time : D
If you want to know where to start, I'd say Kanon 2006 and Kimi ga Nozomu Eien, Clannad too, if you don't mind that it's not over yet; second season's coming soon!
Edit: Didn't you add me to MSN already? If not, go for it, I think my addy's in my profile.