• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Mini Game | Werewolves win

Orboknown

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 3, 2011
Messages
5,097
Location
SatShelter
I think Spak sees the light. Like I said earlier, I should really see more from him before I can get a proper read in, but I haven't seen anything particularly bad from him. I like that he doesn't like J :p Might switch Spak with Orbo, but I feel like Orbo is kinda denying how shifty ThatSmasher's actions are, so that worries me a little.

@ TheKingofKoopas TheKingofKoopas has been mostly inactive, but his really early posts in his rumble with RadicalRat and Generic left a nasty taste in my mouth. I want to see more from him before actually lynching him though. I'd feel confident in lynching either Slick or J though.
Nobodys really said anything about tsyk except that they flipped over his toh so sure comment which i already covered. Errybadeh all he so scummy tho with no why
 

Orboknown

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 3, 2011
Messages
5,097
Location
SatShelter
The only thing ive seen mentioned for why he is scummy is that one comment and something about not knowing how to defend himself
 

SlickWylde

Smash Champion
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
2,846
3DS FC
1349-5237-9158
Well, I think knowing how to defend yourself is a huge part of Mafia. If I'm suspicious of someone and they don't seem to defend themselves well, I'm going to think even more that they're scum. What else am I suppose to base it off? We ask a bunch of people questions, and find which ones look guilty, right? It's not like there's actual evidence, unless someone has a bad slip, which I haven't seen in over 43 pages of content. Do you have an alternative for finding out if someone is scum?
 

Zalak

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
1,632
Location
Washington
NNID
Zalak123
Well, I think knowing how to defend yourself is a huge part of Mafia. If I'm suspicious of someone and they don't seem to defend themselves well, I'm going to think even more that they're scum. What else am I suppose to base it off? We ask a bunch of people questions, and find which ones look guilty, right? It's not like there's actual evidence, unless someone has a bad slip, which I haven't seen in over 43 pages of content. Do you have an alternative for finding out if someone is scum?
But this guy was a brand new mafia player right? And either way, if he doesn't know how to defend himself, he doesn't know how to defend himself. it doesn't matter if he's scum or town.
 

Zalak

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
1,632
Location
Washington
NNID
Zalak123
I just thought it was worth noting because ThatSmasher's shenanigans are the reason I put you below Red and Spak.
 

SlickWylde

Smash Champion
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
2,846
3DS FC
1349-5237-9158
You aint the problem here lol
Okay. Well this is only my 2nd game, so help me out. How should I be trying to find out who's scum? How would I find out, especially with an even noobier player like TSYK, if they're scum or not? I just based it off, he made the worst post at that time, so I pursued it.

I'm not being sarcastic, I'm looking for advice.
 

Zalak

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
1,632
Location
Washington
NNID
Zalak123
@ SlickWylde SlickWylde

i think it's for the best that we investigate orbo as if thatsmasher was never here, cuz like he said, even if he turns out to be scum, he doesn't know why thatsmasher acted the way he did.
 

Orboknown

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 3, 2011
Messages
5,097
Location
SatShelter
Sorry i didn't mean to make that sound accusatory.
forst off, you gotta know how experianced a dude is. If me J or ryu made a post and couldn't explain how we got to that point, thats bad. Moreso than a guy like that smash whos just getting into the game, where he can say something and not realize why thats bad for something. A lot of scumhunting is looking for inconsistencies, like when i asked zalek about calling my townie but having my slot an overall scum lean, i was worried because it looked like he had said something and then changed it real quick. If theres a change on something just like that, its usually a scum player trying to get on someone for opprotunistic reasons. Its why vote trails are nice.
 

Orboknown

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 3, 2011
Messages
5,097
Location
SatShelter
Also, in most games theres a lot of NAs (night actions)floating around, and you can see if a persons claimed targets make sense with their reads and actions (ie if someone claims to be a tracker and they saw the guy go to the person who was killed, but didn't press the person on it in their reads around that time thats not a good sign). Even more than that, you can see if the role makes sense woth what else has been claimed (ie claiming a poison doc in a setup with no apparent poison deaths isnt a good sign, because theres no ise for the role so why have it)
 

TheKingofKoopas

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
230
Location
New York
NNID
Bowser5566
3DS FC
0001-3508-1615
I told ya I was gonna be here today. Last 20 minutes, but yeah.
Just posting to show I'm here, gonna get to stuff right now.
 

TheKingofKoopas

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
230
Location
New York
NNID
Bowser5566
3DS FC
0001-3508-1615
"
Deadline: Monday 14th; 10pm GMT"
It's in the title :p

what is this titans you speak of?
Oops. I check the thread by Gheb's avatar, not the name :I
It's a complicated board game, PM me if you're interested so we don't spam this thread.
___________________________________________________________________________________________
Alright, I'm gonna post my reads. I don't have the time to to reread this thread, so please tell me if I got information wrong because I do not need another moment like at the beginning of the game.

Spak - Spak's personality change was really noticeable. For most of the game, Spak had been pretty inactive but with the understandable excuse of AP classes. I find it weird that, along with seeming very defensive, he's suddenly making more posts. Could be a coincidence, but along with being null to me for most of this game, I'll list as a scum lean.

Slick - While everyone has been claiming he's very passive, I can understand his type of gameplay. Althooough, when he votes for someone, he's pretty much sure they're scum; ie TSYK and me. He's also been less passive the last two or so pages, I THINK after someone mentioned how he's been following along with the general consensus.

RR - While he's been busy most of the time, he doesn't have too much knowledge of the game considering he forgot certain slots when posting his reads. His posts are also short, and right now, lack substance. Asking people that have Mafia experience with him, does he normally make his posts more shorter and concise, or no? If not, do you think they're shorter simply because he hasn't been keeping up with the game?

Orboknown - I'm gonna completely erase TSYK's play out of this. I've been liking his posts from the past few pages, but I honestly hardly remember anything else outside of those. Can I hear what you guys have to say about Orbo WITHOUT TSYK?

J - I think he's town. I agree with a lot he has to say, and most of his posts, like the ones where he got excited over Spak, just seem honestly genuine. When there's something I disagree with him about, he always brings up good points, like his decision to rethink whether Zalak is scum or not. Speaking of Zalak...

Zalak - I still think his whole argument against J was opportunistic scum. He's self-meta'd multiple times already, it shows how self conscious he is about his play style. I believe that right there tells us that he could fake his performance as WW or Mafia easily.

Rosalina - I hate having to use vibes in my reads, but that's honestly all I got for him. A town vibe.

I'm going to go back and read things, and go into more detail on Orbo and Rosa when it's not three in the morning. Good thing Friday starts with late classes.
So far I would be okay with voting either Spak, Slick, RR, or Zalak, in no particular order.. If any of them have four votes and it seems like the way it is now, then I'm okay with hammering them. I know it's MyLo, but there are more scum than town, I feel we don't need to be that cautious.
 

Zalak

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
1,632
Location
Washington
NNID
Zalak123
Zalak - I still think his whole argument against J was opportunistic scum. He's self-meta'd multiple times already, it shows how self conscious he is about his play style. I believe that right there tells us that he could fake his performance as WW or Mafia easily.
WHAT OPPORTUNITY ??
??
?

Orboknown - I'm gonna completely erase TSYK's play out of this. I've been liking his posts from the past few pages, but I honestly hardly remember anything else outside of those. Can I hear what you guys have to say about Orbo WITHOUT TSYK?
I like him.

J - I think he's town. I agree with a lot he has to say, and most of his posts, like the ones where he got excited over Spak, just seem honestly genuine. When there's something I disagree with him about, he always brings up good points, like his decision to rethink whether Zalak is scum or not. Speaking of Zalak...
In a multi-faction setup, I don't think that's as valid a basis for a read. Because each faction is actually looking for the other faction, they can make genuine scum-hunting posts.

RR - While he's been busy most of the time, he doesn't have too much knowledge of the game considering he forgot certain slots when posting his reads. His posts are also short, and right now, lack substance. Asking people that have Mafia experience with him, does he normally make his posts more shorter and concise, or no? If not, do you think they're shorter simply because he hasn't been keeping up with the game?
his posts are usually pretty concise (from what i've seen), but I think it may partially have to do with the fact that he hasn't been keeping up too much.
 

SlickWylde

Smash Champion
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
2,846
3DS FC
1349-5237-9158
So far I would be okay with voting either Spak, Slick, RR, or Zalak, in no particular order.. If any of them have four votes and it seems like the way it is now, then I'm okay with hammering them. I know it's MyLo, but there are more scum than town, I feel we don't need to be that cautious.
I like this post, except for this last paragraph. If we lynch another town, it's pretty much over for us. This round ESPECIALLY, we need to be very cautious. What do you mean there are more town than scum? 2 Vanilla town, 1 Doctor, 3 Mafia, and 2 WW.
 

TheKingofKoopas

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
230
Location
New York
NNID
Bowser5566
3DS FC
0001-3508-1615
I still disagree with "we don't need to be that cautious."
It's more of the fact that if I were to pick out anyone still alive and say "ur scum", I have more of a chance of being right.

Also, I mentioned being willing to hammer certain people now so that it doesn't look like I'm jumping the bandwagon if I end up hammering.
 

SlickWylde

Smash Champion
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
2,846
3DS FC
1349-5237-9158
It's more of the fact that if I were to pick out anyone still alive and say "ur scum", I have more of a chance of being right.

Also, I mentioned being willing to hammer certain people now so that it doesn't look like I'm jumping the bandwagon if I end up hammering.
Sure... BUT if you pick the wrong person, we're screwed..

I'm not going to paint a picture without giving you recourse for defense, but this is what I think of you:

You'd pretty much vote for anyone, because you don't care, as long as you survive till tomorrow. That says 1 of two things:
1. You're town, but not a good town teammate, and will lose. or 2. You are scum, and you know that there is a high chance that either a townie or scum from opposite faction will die if we lynch someone. And if you lynch a scum teamamte, it will make you look good.

I'm curious if anybody is willing to defend Koopa, or give any indication that they think he's town. Has anybody seen "townie" posts from him?
 

TheKingofKoopas

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
230
Location
New York
NNID
Bowser5566
3DS FC
0001-3508-1615
Sure... BUT if you pick the wrong person, we're screwed..

I'm not going to paint a picture without giving you recourse for defense, but this is what I think of you:

You'd pretty much vote for anyone, because you don't care, as long as you survive till tomorrow. That says 1 of two things:
1. You're town, but not a good town teammate, and will lose. or 2. You are scum, and you know that there is a high chance that either a townie or scum from opposite faction will die if we lynch someone. And if you lynch a scum teamamte, it will make you look good.

I'm curious if anybody is willing to defend Koopa, or give any indication that they think he's town. Has anybody seen "townie" posts from him?
Excuse me?
I'm not voting for anyone, and definitely not because I don't care. I said I'm willing to vote for the players I have a scum read on. I'm simply confident in my reads while waiting to see more defense.
 

SlickWylde

Smash Champion
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
2,846
3DS FC
1349-5237-9158
Excuse me?
I'm not voting for anyone, and definitely not because I don't care. I said I'm willing to vote for the players I have a scum read on. I'm simply confident in my reads while waiting to see more defense.
Okay, then I misunderstood. I reread the original post I replied to, and I think I get it better now. Your wording definitely came off wrong to me.
 

Orboknown

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 3, 2011
Messages
5,097
Location
SatShelter
But...theres no accusation from you for them to defend. Also you should get @ Zalak Zalak about being oppotunistic before he rages about not getting answered
 

SlickWylde

Smash Champion
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
2,846
3DS FC
1349-5237-9158
But...theres no accusation from you for them to defend. Also you should get @ Zalak Zalak about being oppotunistic before he rages about not getting answered
You talking to me or Koopa? I don't remember Zalak asking me a question that I did't answer.
 

TheKingofKoopas

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
230
Location
New York
NNID
Bowser5566
3DS FC
0001-3508-1615
WHAT OPPORTUNITY ??
??
?
At first, the NK analysis, then trying to make J look suspicious.

But...theres no accusation from you for them to defend.
Not necessarily defenses, meant answers to my questions.

Okay, then I misunderstood. I reread the original post I replied to, and I think I get it better now. Your wording definitely came off wrong to me.
So far I would be okay with voting either Spak, Slick, RR, or Zalak, in no particular order.. If any of them have four votes and it seems like the way it is now, then I'm okay with hammering them.
I honestly don't see the wording being a problem.
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
*waves*

I'm having a drunk league night with friends. So I'll be around, but if you want silly answers just lemme know. We can chit-chat.
 
Top Bottom