Mini Game | Werewolves win

[Zalak]

@ R RadicalRat

Who is Generic's WW buddy?

 

[Zalak]

also why is he a WW and not mafia? @ R RadicalRat

 

[RadicalRat]

@ R RadicalRat Alright. Answer me this: if you really are town, who are the three members of the mafia? (in your opinion)

Kary, Smasher, and Koopa.

Kary is all but confirmed for me. 100% read there.
Smasher is... an interesting case. I can see him has Town, but he is second most likely to be mafia.
Koopa would be least likely, but still more likely than anyone else not already proclaimed scum.

 

[SlickWylde]

I leave my fate in the hands of the Town. I would like to keep playing the game, yes. But if my death would be more beneficial than letting me live as a suspect, I will cooperate, and even vote myself.

No. If you're town and you die, it's ONLY bad. There's one less towns person, 3 mafia, and 2 WW left. Honestly this first round is SO important. It would be a huge setback. If you're really town, you need to change our minds.

 

[RadicalRat]

@ R RadicalRat

Who is Generic's WW buddy?

Slick. Again. This is the third time in the past few minutes I've said this.

 

[Kaladin]

@ R RadicalRat

Who is Generic's WW buddy?

He said slick is.

@ R RadicalRat If you're scum, the best thing you can do for the mafia is not answer my question. If you do answer it, we get a mafia saying who he thinks the mafia is.

If you're a townie, then answer with nothing to fear.

I'm waiting

 

[RadicalRat]

also why is he a WW and not mafia? @ R RadicalRat

Because he was stalling Smasher's lynch until the end of a game day. Mafia wouldn't benefit from having a night phase. Werewolf would.

 

[Kaladin]

No. If you're town and you die, it's ONLY bad. There's one less towns person, 3 mafia, and 2 WW left. Honestly this first round is SO important. It would be a huge setback. If you're really town, you need to change our minds.

I mean, you're technically right, but I don't like you helping RR try to reverse rhis.

 

[RadicalRat]

He said slick is.

@ R RadicalRat If you're scum, the best thing you can do for the mafia is not answer my question. If you do answer it, we get a mafia saying who he thinks the mafia is.

If you're a townie, then answer with nothing to fear.

I'm waiting

I answered already.

 

[Kaladin]

Because he was stalling Smasher's lynch until the end of a game day. Mafia wouldn't benefit from having a night phase. Werewolf would.

But I dropped that at like page 6. Besides, wouldn't that make Smasher a WW, not slick?

 

[RadicalRat]

No. If you're town and you die, it's ONLY bad. There's one less towns person, 3 mafia, and 2 WW left. Honestly this first round is SO important. It would be a huge setback. If you're really town, you need to change our minds.

That's why I'm letting the Town decide. Am I worth the lynch on day one? I don't know the answer myself. I thought so going into this, but I questioned it as things went on. I left hints, and ultimate chickened out. Because I'd rather see a scum lynched than a Townie. I recognize that until my death I will still be suspicious though, so it's all up to the honest members of this Town.

 

[Kaladin]

I answered already.

About who the three mafia are? Where?

 

[Zalak]

Because he was stalling Smasher's lynch until the end of a game day. Mafia wouldn't benefit from having a night phase. Werewolf would.

aye but the WW faction still gets their kill if one of them dies

 

[Zalak]

About who the three mafia are? Where?

just above ye mate #803

 

[RadicalRat]

But I dropped that at like page 6. Besides, wouldn't that make Smasher a WW, not slick?

I've answered this before somewhere, but I changed my mind to think that you were planning on killing him, and using that you wanted to see him in Day Two as a defense.

Also, yes you dropped it. Which is why I don't think you were really buddies. But you had plans for him.

 

[Kaladin]

aye but the WW faction still gets their kill if one of them dies

That doesn't matter tho. RR claims Slick is the other WW, not Smasher. This feels like pulling something out of your ass and praying.

 

[RadicalRat]

aye but the WW faction still gets their kill if one of them dies

Which is another reason why I'm putting Slick as his buddy, and Smasher as a target.

 

[Zalak]

That doesn't matter tho. RR claims Slick is the other WW, not Smasher. This feels like pulling something out of your *** and praying.

oh yeah, that's weird.

that's really weird

 

[RadicalRat]

That doesn't matter tho. RR claims Slick is the other WW, not Smasher. This feels like pulling something out of your *** and praying.

Except that I've said this all before. Go look back.

 

[Zalak]

Which is another reason why I'm putting Slick as his buddy, and Smasher as a target.

oh WHAT?

why would he want to kill Smasher instead of getting a lynch? Smasher is so suspicious already. I'm not following.

 

[Kaladin]

Which is another reason why I'm putting Slick as his buddy, and Smasher as a target.

If I wanted to kill smasher and had the opportunity to do it with more efficency and use my (nonexistent) nightkill elsewhere, I'd do it. Especially because everyone thinks smasher is scum, so no one would point fingers at me.

 

[RadicalRat]

oh WHAT?

why would he want to kill Smasher instead of getting a lynch? Smasher is so suspicious already. I'm not following.

At the TIME this happened, Smasher looked much less suspicious than he does now. That way he gets town points for defending the innocent, AND for wanting to see Smasher on Day Two, therefore not possibly being the killer.

 

[RadicalRat]

If I wanted to kill smasher and had the opportunity to do it with more efficency and use my (nonexistent) nightkill elsewhere, I'd do it. Especially because everyone thinks smasher is scum, so no one would point fingers at me.

Which is why you dropped that as the evidence started piling up.

 

[Kaladin]

Kary, Smasher, and Koopa.

Kary is all but confirmed for me. 100% read there.
Smasher is... an interesting case. I can see him has Town, but he is second most likely to be mafia.
Koopa would be least likely, but still more likely than anyone else not already proclaimed scum.

Alright. We have this, and we see how he flips. I'm actually slight town lean on koops now. Smasher is a super safe answer. Kary is a special snowflake as I'll be talking about a bit later.

 

[Zalak]

 

[RadicalRat]

Alright. We have this, and we see how he flips. I'm actually slight town lean on koops now. Smasher is a super safe answer. Kary is a special snowflake as I'll be talking about a bit later.

I told you he was the least likely on the list. But barring you, Slick, Kary and Smasher, he's next on my list. I've got a null lean there, but you specifically asked who the THREE mafia were.

 

[Kaladin]

I'll be back in 20-30 minutes. After that I'll talk about Kary's doctor post and why, assuming Kary is not cheating and smart, it makes him most likely scum.

 

[RadicalRat]

HOLD IT!

TAKE KOOPA OFF MY MAFIA LIST
AND PUT J ON IT INSTEAD

KARY'S DOC REQUEST... AN ATTEMPT TO PUT J IN OUR MINDS AS THE DOCTOR, AND THEREFORE NOT MAFIA.

IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW.

I mean, it's either that, or Kary cheated by communicating outside of the game.

 

[Kaladin]

HOLD IT!

TAKE KOOPA OFF MY MAFIA LIST
AND PUT J ON IT INSTEAD

KARY'S DOC REQUEST... AN ATTEMPT TO PUT J IN OUR MINDS AS THE DOCTOR, AND THEREFORE NOT MAFIA.

IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW.

I mean, it's either that, or Kary cheated by communicating outside of the game.

No that's stupid. Kneejerk reaction to that is "how do you know?" He was fishing for a reaction/read on J.

 

[Kaladin]

@TheKingofKoopas Your thoughts?


Anyways now I'll be back in 30.

 

[RadicalRat]

For conveniences sake:

Wolves: Generic/Slick
Mafia: Kary, Smasher, and J
Town: Zalak and Rosalina
Null: Everyone else.

 

[SlickWylde]

I mean, you're technically right, but I don't like you helping RR try to reverse rhis.

Don't worry, I'm not. I partly wanted a read on him, and I wanted to see if he'd just resort to pointing at other people again.
And also I want other people to notice this. If on the .0001% chance he flips town, everyone else needs to know that it's a terrible, anti town idea to do what he did. (As mafia I don't think it's a great idea, but it could help them figure out who the WW are, I suppose.)

Also I'm pretty sure Kary was joking...

 

[RadicalRat]

No that's stupid. Kneejerk reaction to that is "how do you know?" He was fishing for a reaction/read on J.

I can't think of a single role that would even respond to that message. At least, not one in this game.

 

[Zalak]

idk I think Kary was trying to communicate something to the actual doctor.

 

[RadicalRat]

Don't worry, I'm not. I partly wanted a read on him, and I wanted to see if he'd just resort to pointing at other people again.
And also I want other people to notice this. If on the .0001% chance he flips town, everyone else needs to know that it's a terrible, anti town idea to do what he did. (As mafia I don't think it's a great idea, but it could help them figure out who the WW are, I suppose.)

Also I'm pretty sure Kary was joking...

Why would she mention J's name specifically in the joke though? Also, aren't jokes supposed to have some sort of humor to them?

 

[Zalak]

like, I just assumed she wanted to be healed.

 

[RadicalRat]

idk I think Kary was trying to communicate something to the actual doctor.

Again, why specifically mention J? Why not just say "Doc"?

She and J are scheming, or she cheated.

 

[Zalak]

Why would she mention J's name specifically in the joke though? Also, aren't jokes supposed to have some sort of humor to them?

it was pretty silly and out of left field though. It definitely could be a joke. It could also be a .....

I think we need to calm down about Kary for a sec and just let her expain herself.

 

[Zalak]

Again, why specifically mention J? Why not just say "Doc"?

She and J are scheming, or she cheated.

That isn't very OPEN-MINDED.

 

[Zalak]

I sincerely doubt she's cheating.