Wow, the tension on this thread is so thick, I can like, cut it with a....+6 sword.
I like most of your decisions except for a few:
Balloon Fighter: Lower. I don't care how good or cool or bad*** or whatever these generic enemies are. They will remain generic as long as the number 8 is larger than 7.
Ridley: Lower. But that's just because the idea of him being in Smash doesn't sit well with me. I'm not denying he would probably have a good moveset.
Hector: Higher. Hector and Lyn are on the top of the list right after Ike (apparently). Of course, if it was up to me, Ike would be in that Pit of Doom as well.
Stafy: WTF?!!? Lower.
Paras: In all seriousness.....
.
.
.Butterfree kicks the living s**t out of Paras. GOT IT???
.(Had to give you a little bit of heads-up McFox)
.
.
Who cares about Spore when you can have a Snorlax with Blizzard and Swift (pretty sure it was Swift)!!?! NO ONE, THAT'S WHO.
WAIT: Ike shouldn't be in the Pit of Doom, he needs to be the first one to go up in flames. And since he sucks SO much, he just gravitates all the other losers towards him. Don't forget he started it.
WAIT#2: The entire time reading your post, I was wondering where you got those pictures. Man, if I knew how to draw that good.................Actually, if I knew how to draw a stick figure........that would be an improvement. Good Job!