Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Its the reason why i came out with it when J claimed.
Why Darkpit when Maven has literally had only one post?
He's been around to conceivably use night actions.
Assuming no one counterclaims vig, LoneKon and J are both town. Kon brought up good points, but that's only assuming all three mafia followed the same general pattern (which would be a little foolish.) Poke's defense of Moydow was pretty good, and leads me to be inclined to think that if nothing else, Chu probably isn't scum, as scum wouldn't benefit at all at this point from such blatant, heavy defense of someone. Still unsure about Moydow, but she has definitely contributed, like with her read of FireEmblem.Darkpit54 When you get the chance, I would like to hear your thoughts on the exchange between Moydow and LoneKonWolf goung on above.
I think definitely once mafioso is out, but I'm unsure about with both of them still here. I'd like to hear what others think, though.
In most setups the doc's night action does still work, unless otherwise specified. So I think we're good with that.
I think that's a good point, something I had been considering too. Most likely it points to someone who was being seen as suspicious at the time, or who had been inactive. Considering what we've seen in the last few hours, plus the state of the game during day one, to me that seems to narrow down the list of suspects to just Maven and you, or possibly Shish or FE (though I don't think anyone was suspicious of FE at any point in day one). I'm inclined to think the mafioso who got doc'd wouldn't raise this possibility, so I'm going with Maven.
Given what I said above, to me this question is basically "who do you think is the SK?". And since I don't know what I'm looking for there, that could really be any of us (except you and Kon, for as long as we don't get a third Vig claim). Once you remove those two that leaves my list of potential SK suspects at Bard, Shish, Chu, and FE, and I really can't choose between them at this point.
oh, never mind this, I'm just dumb, we already have our two Vig claims so the only remaining townies are all docs, whoops :p
I went with FE. I decided the less active players weren't worth protecting, which at the time excluded Opo, Ura, Darkpit, Chu, and Maven, and I didn't go with you or J since you seemed the most likely town-reads and I figured someone else would target you (I promise it wasn't out of bitterness over you targeting me, I try not to let things like that cloud my decision-making). That left Shish, FE, and Kon, and FE was the only one who had anything positive to say about me in day 1 so I went with him.
This comes off way too defeatist to me and is out of line with the rest of Moydow's posts today
Maybe because it's her first post today?
Doc, I protected Pokechu. Thought he didn't do much to make him scummy and was a likely target because everyone kills Pokechu, plus he hadn't posted much and we wouldn't get much information from him. If I was a vig I'd have vig'd Ura.
You are really defending Moydow and I just don't see it.Maybe because it's her first post today?
Vaan being Littlefinger had no bearing on his win condition whatsoever except for flavor. Just because he was Littlefinger doesn't mean he was more of a threat than any other place. I defended him then and I'd do it again.
I'd be more suspicious of him if there was more than 1 Mafioso alive but as it is now I don't see it as particularly scummy.
She hasn't done anything wrong. She had some interactions with Ura but that could just be bad luck and she still has managed to contribute some things, maybe not in D1 but definitely toDay. She hasn't done anything out of the norm for an inactive.
He was in a house by himself, but you blindly just trusted his win condition without a second thought. It’s easy to say in hindsight that defending him was fair game but you didn’t remotely question the integrity of his claim. It’s just odd is all.
But his win condition ended up being the same as the rest of us?
Yes, there was. They had the best town games out of ALL the townies.
What exactly are you trying to imply out of Chu's behaviour? That Moydow is actually scum and Chu is misguided? Because that's how I'm reading this.
Nah it’s clear that there are no connections here. It’s about identifying individual scummy plays at this point. Filtering out the fake from the legitimate.
What do/would you find suspicious about my defense of her?
You didn’t know his win condition until post-game. In the moment, when you didn’t know anything, you just haplessly followed along.But his win condition ended up being the same as the rest of us?
Or is this saying that I didn't consider his wincon being different? Which, I did. But the wagon against him was still 200% garbage.
Yes, there was. They had the best town games out of ALL the townies.
The simple fact you're defending Moydow REALLY hard.What do/would you find suspicious about my defense of her?
I didn't know his win-condition, but there was just as much evidence suggesting it was the same as everyone else's as it was for it being different. It's not haplessly following along, and I don't know why you think it is.
They were mostly being opportunistic scum, town just tunneled on other town that's why they lost mutton mafiaBut his win condition ended up being the same as the rest of us?
Or is this saying that I didn't consider his wincon being different? Which, I did. But the wagon against him was still 200% garbage.
Yes, there was. They had the best town games out of ALL the townies.
For example, Moy used the fact how I had the highest activity to put off lynching me. She was the only one to consider that a scum might not want that amount of attention when there's some townies who were barely making more than a post per day.
Moydow been defeatist all day.
It's not that I disagree with your points but behaviour like that is usually scummy due to creating connections.I'm not going to let garbage reasoning kill a townie.
What do you expect I do?