So, I was coin farming Mario Party 1 today in order to get the "No Koopa" and "No Boo" items, for the sake of completion, and forced the CPU and I to not get any stars during the normal rounds. It turns out that there is a minimum star amount that needs to be met in order to be considered a Superstar. (Complete with replacing "You are the Superstar" with "You are a winner" in smaller text.)
That means that it's possible to do a full game on Yoshi's Tropical Island and not rescue the pink Yoshi stranded in the ocean, among other things like endding the Bob-Omb war. I guess Nintendo wanted to make players feel bad for being cheap. lol
Yeah, not trying to advertise, but I have a video of that if anyone wants to see:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jfTAJzgWXk
My opinion on MP9... it's hard to say. I love the style and all and the Mini-Game, oh Lord, one of the best Mini-Game lists I've seen in a Mario Party. But the overall luck and no control (unless your captain) I really don't like. Mario Party has always been luck, but there has also been skill, there's not a lot of skill involved on the main board, and Mini-Game payouts are ehhhhh now (I don't like how I win a mini-game just for the 2nd place player to get 2 less than me), so it's like Viper said, everything is down to Luck/Chance. I'd give the game like a 6/10, 7/10 just for the Mini-Games.
I would definitely not mind if the style was to come back. There needs to be some improvements made, imo, though.
-Try more Skilled-based events (Of course we need some Luck games as well, but have some events where people actually have to do well instead of it being chance).
-Add More Characters (just a small complaint, but I expect more characters than MP8, not less =P).
-Add Passing Events (Maybe like a shop where you can buy stuff?)
-Add Items (just that alone gives players control over themself and others, I mean ITEMS, not those DiceBlocks).
-Make Boards longer (DK's Jungle Ruins was so short... I finished that in 15 Minutes.)
-Instead of losing Half your Mini-Games, set it to like 10/15/20 (don't make players lose so many Mini Stars so easily).
-Fix Mini-Game Pay-Outs (I would not make the payouts so close together, but if they really want it like that, then at least do it like this: 1st: 10, 2nd: 3, 3rd: 1, 4th: 0).
But yeah, these changes need to be done in the next Mario Party imo. If it's going to continue like MP9 with all that Luck, then I'd just prefer a classic-style game, to be honest.