So I've been meaning to post my thoughts on Ridley here for awhile, but decided to wait and see if E3 brought any news about the next Smash, dispelling any chance Ridley might have. E3 did no such thing, so here it goes...
First, as I understand it, the general consensus is that Ridley will probably NOT be in the next Smash and that the rumored returning characters will probably be Wolf and Ice Climbers (and maybe Splatoon and ARMS characters), if the next Smash turns out to be a port. And I subscribe to this consensus for the most part. However,
I still think Ridley has a slight chance of being a playable character, even more so if the the next Smash game is an entirely new one.
Basically, I've always suspected that Ridley was originally planned as a character, and was partially developed, but in the end was relegated to a stage hazard due to development time constraints. I'm hoping that if Ridley was partially developed, he will be polished up and put in the next Smash, whether that is a port or a new game.
-----------------
Let me present some evidence...
First of all,
Bowser Jr. was almost cut from the game. Sakurai also mentions
there were cases where characters weren't able to make it in the end. Maybe Ridley was one of those cases?
Second, Ridley was given quite a few attacks for a stage hazard. Compared to Yellow Devil and Metal Face, he has a lot more comparatively. Furthermore, almost all of these attacks were derived from both of his Super Metroid and Other M counterparts in the original games**, which tells me someone did their homework on Ridley, just like many of the other playable characters have had done for them. He was also given pretty dynamic and fluid animations when executing them. Hell, he was also given a ledge grab animation! Basically, I'm saying that this seems like quite a bit for a mere stage hazard.
(**I can elaborate more on these attacks if someone wants.)
Third, despite stage-hazard-Ridley being based on his Other M version, the icon for him on the results screen is clearly based off of his Super Metroid version...
It makes me wonder if Ridley was originally designed based on his Super Metroid version. But why the change? Well, if he was originally a character, it would make more sense to have him based on his retro Super Metroid version as opposed to the less-aesthetically pleasing Other M version. But if he was indeed changed into a stage hazard for an Other M-based stage, exactly where he appeared in that game, then of course Ridley would have to reflect how he appeared at that point in Other M. I guess his icon here was an oversight? (His 'Super Metroid' icon not matching the design of his Other M stage hazard form has always bugged/annoyed me since the game came out...)
----------------
So, taking all three of these points in consideration... well, it just seems to me that Ridley was at least planned as a playable character, if not partially developed. To reiterate: Sakurai basically said that some characters' development had to be abandoned. Ridley also has many source-researched and well-developed attacks for a stage hazard relative to Yellow Devil and Metal Face, not to mention he also has an icon based off his Super Metroid form. As I mentioned, it would make sense to have a playable Ridley in his retro Super Metroid form... So yeah...
I know that there is a lot of speculation and straw-grasping in this post, but those three points I haven't really seen brought up yet by anyone and they fit together in my mind to point toward a partially-developed Ridley... I just hope that if work has truly already been done on Ridley as a playable character, the team for the next Smash game can take what has been done and finish him.
-----------------
As far as Ridley's chances of being included in the next Smash game... I want to point this out:
In the interview snippet I linked above, Sakurai says:
Each and every character has fans, we wanted to drop as few as possible. About the order of which character has priority, the characters that don’t have a new title coming up have an overwhelming disadvantage…
Since there wasn't much going on with Metroid at the time, this would be another explanation why Ridley was not given priority during development. (Assuming he was a character to begin with.) However, with the announcement of a Metroid II remake and Metroid Prime 4, hopefully this increases his chances. I know that Ridley was never in the original Metroid II, but it would be awesome if he was in Metroid Prime 4. If so,
and if a new Smash Bros game is being made, then scrapping the Pyrosphere stage entirely, along with stage-hazard-Ridley, and replacing it with a Metroid Prime 4 stage and Ridley as a playable character would be freaking awesome!
So yeah, there is it... Let me know what you think, fellow Space Pirates.