This is probably going to sound like a ridiculous question to most of you, but does anyone miss the days when Ridley wasn't in Smash? I know we tend to associate those times with the detractors and all the hate Ridley supporters had to deal with, but I have to admit, I kind of miss the traffic and activity Ridley used to have when everyone was talking about how he'd play, what he'd look like, and how big he'd be - you know, typical speculation. I miss those Ridley memes, the heated debates, and even the ridiculous trolls who kept reminding us that Ridley was too big.
I dunno. I guess the Direct is making me nostalgic. After all this time, it still feels weird not wondering if Ridley will be revealed as the next character.
I do not. After Brawl's release, there were two characters I heavily devoted time to supporting, Ridley and Roy. I also really wanted to see Mega Man in and Mewtwo to return, but there was far less detractors for those two characters so there was no need to really speak up for them.
Ridley in particular was a character that seemed like he should have been added for Brawl, so it really seemed like Smash 4 was going to be his time at long last (I rationalized Ridley not making Brawl's roster as a result of so many other major Nintendo characters being ahead of him). I also supported Ridley for Melee and there was a large support base during that epoch as well (Ridley's appearance during the E3 2001 trailer for Melee made many think he was going to be on the roster). Ridley not making in onto Melee's roster was not a disappointment because I felt he had an uphill battle there since Metroid's last game was all the way back in 1994.
I felt with all the Metroid titles released between Melee and Brawl's announcement, that Ridley was likely for Brawl. Brawl confirmed so many other characters that I wanted for Smash Bros., that I was not disappointed with the roster.
I couldn't be happier. I love Sakurai's interpretation of Ridley, and he's better than I ever imagined.
But the flipside to that is me knowing that the character I've wanted for nearly a decade is finally in. I don't have to bother gathering evidence or debating with other users anymore, which in a weird way, is something I want back. Almost feels like the end of an era.
Yes, I also really like the interpretation of Ridley that Sakurai and his team came up with for Ultimate.
It is definitely the end an of era with Ridley's (and K. Rool's) confirmation for Ultimate. Personally, I do not miss all the debates and arguing with other users though.
You need to keep in mind that just as every story has a beginning, it also has an end. I actually thought that the end of Smash 4 where Sakurai himself stated that he thought Ridley was "too big" was possibly the end to that story (the story of Ridley's journey to Smash Bros.'s roster). As a matter of fact, after Roy's confirmation as Smash 4 DLC in June 2015, I had only made two more posts after June 2015 (until my return on April 2018). You should be grateful that Sakurai did a 180 on Ridley so soon. It is frankly a very big miracle that Ridley was added to Ultimate, a game developed very soon after Smash 4 and had very few newcomers in it (if you told me those parameters about Ultimate before Ridley's confirmation, I would have been even more pessimistic on Ridley's prospects than I already was going into E3 2018).
Aside from Ridley, Ultimate gave me many things I never expected to happen in a Smash Bros. title after Smash 4. Every veteran returning. And Castlevania joining the roster (since the "core"/"Smash bubble" did not seem to care at all about that series or talk about it). Ironically, the only thing that did not happen with the roster that I personally hoped for was Dixie Kong, which was probably the only thing among all the ones I listed that most speculators thought, prior to Ultimate's announcement, had a realistic chance of happening.
Ultimate basically realized so many dreams I had for the series that I thought would never be realized.
The only character left I feel a real passion for that is not yet in is Dixie Kong. Honestly, I do not feel like sticking around for another speculation period (Ultimate post-DLC) just for her. I am getting older, and I have a lot less free time. After Roy's confirmation for Smash 4, I basically left for three years. Ultimate happening the way it did (and being announced so soon after the conclusion of Smash 4 DLC) was the primary reason why I am even as active as I am right now.
I am posting less and less now that the game has been released. However, I do want to put out a Dixie Kong essay in support of the character that fans of the character can use for the next speculation cycle.
It was almost entirely due to him being too big. He was originally intended for Melee iirc, but Sakurai cut him for that reason.
Since then, he was continually argued to be too big. It made zero sense, as you have said.
Also hi! I enjoy this character, mostly due to Metroid love. Bowser is my usual heavy, but Ridley is fantastic.
Ridley was not planned for Melee or any other games prior to Ultimate. Sakurai clarified after Smash 4's release though that the reason Ridley was not playable yet was due to size and scaling issues. Sakurai actually said in a recent interview that Ridley was among the most challenging characters he made.
There is a certain nostalgia about those days, and the memes, flame wars, and lengthy circular arguments, but I can't say I really miss it. The anticipation over what role Ridley would have was never fun either. Yeah the hype has died down, it's natural though. The traffic Ridley attracted at his prime was legendary (has any support thread gotten anywhere near 2,000 pages?) though, but even this cycle it was way less.
.
The journey with Ridley was truly legendary indeed. Ridley and K. Rool were in a league of their own. There really has not been a character that is up to their level in terms of both popularity and historical importance to their franchises left. Dixie Kong, Bandana Dee, and Toad/Captain Toad/Toadette are the only major side characters left to be included in my opinion. However, most of the "Smash bubble" core does not seem to have much passion for them for whatever reason.
It is still incredible to me that we got a title where not only both of them got confirmed, but we also got every veteran back as well as Castlevania. It is truly amazing.