Halloween Party Mafia ~ Over! Who drowned bobbing for apples? Who won Best Costume?

[Vult Redux]

Yeah I just went back and read that.

Hmmm.

 

[Asdioh]

Mine has a traditional role name and so does DH. He's a plain ole' miller.

Same here.

If you guys really think Gheb is scum, lynch him. I'm not, so I won't.
Sadly, I don't know who else to lynch. Anytime I go after a suspicious inactive, they pop back in the thread and start looking townie (JTB)
So I don't know right now.

/useless

 

[Tandora]

Mine has a traditional role name and so does DH. He's a plain ole' miller.

Wouldn't the implication of a plain town role after flavorful town roles make miller look suspicious which is kinda the suck point of being a miller?


Not sure if people saying "I have a traditional role name" are implying VT or some PR. Don't think you guys should be doing that if you are PRs since it gives scum targets. =(

 

[Tandora]

It also occurs to me that Asdioh never role claimed Ran's slot. He only confirmed the character which really doesn't mean anything since Ran already claimed his costume and we know scum have safeclaims.

 

[JTB]

'Cause I don't want to get into a nitpicky argument over someone who I don't think is in danger of being lynched. The Asidoh wagon has no momentum, so I don't need to go out of my way to defend against it.

We have plenty of time left in the Day. There being 'no momentum' in his wagon is a stupid cop out, I want to know why you don't like my case.

I don't like this post.

Gheb, can you at least character claim, in some way, shape, or form?

Same here.

If you guys really think Gheb is scum, lynch him. I'm not, so I won't.
Sadly, I don't know who else to lynch. Anytime I go after a suspicious inactive, they pop back in the thread and start looking townie (JTB)
So I don't know right now.

/useless

If you didn't like me saying lynch Gheb and I'll keep reading through the Night, why do you later say the same thing (albeit, with a bit different wording)? Your reasoning for letting the Gheb lynch slide is just awful.

I believe Gheb's claim and to lynch him because his role "doesn't match up with other revealed roles" is completely ********. Vult instantly jumping on that reasoning and saying to hammer Gheb because of it is scummy as ****.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Can we lynch Asdioh nowplease? Or at least aussie to get rid of the last flat-out inactive player?

 

[X1-12]

Yeah will post sometime when I can. Have been busy due to packing to move into new uni accommodation. I'll also be pretty inebriated for the first couple of days at least when I'm there so don't expect any miraculous bursts of activity

 

[Asdioh]

unvote
Vote: asianaussie

@_@

 

[Tandora]

Guys, don't screw around. Deadline is 3:30 on Monday. I don't know about the rest of you, but I'll be at work and won't be able to read much less post all of Monday. My activity will be done Sunday night. I might be able to post on Monday during lunch, but it is not reliable. So if a vote is needed for a last minute lynch wagon, you will not be able to depend on me.

Asdioh, I want stated reasons from you for your AA vote.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Asdioh, I want stated reasons from you for your AA vote.

Are you kidding me? lol

 

[Vult Redux]

and yet if I pushed scumpicks that others wouldn't vote, wouldn't that also be considered scummy?

"he's pretending to have content by pushing people that have no chance of getting lynched blah blah"

Wow, lynch this scum.

You are playing to survive right now. You are more worried about people finding you scummy than pushing your scumpicks and helping town win.

No. It's perfectly reasonable to not waste your time looking into a player whom the Town is averse to lynching, especially if the Town already has a direction.

EBR demonstrated this on D2 by hooting and hollering over my wagon even though it was clear no one was buying it. It was a waste of his time and he probably was doing it deliberately to give himself something to concentrate on.

Though I'll give you that Asidoh saying that X1 and Smoth are "mostly considered Town" is really false. He's completely on-the-ball by saying it's a good idea to look in a similar direction as the rest of the Town. Otherwise, everyone would be after someone different and votes would scatter. There's no reason for him to bring up X1 or Smoth when we have perfectly good options on the table right now (Gheb and AA, I mean - though I personally wouldn't mind seeing an X1 wagon).

 

[Tandora]

Are you kidding me? lol

No, I'm not. If we do go with an AA lynch, then I want to be able to make connections to everyone who voted for him. I am not satisfied with "Well, he was inactive" as the main line of reasoning at this point in the game.

 

[Shadow Moth]

We're not lynching AA.

Gheb is at L-1 and he's still scummy. Why would we listen to the guy we're ready to lynch for being scummy when he says "hey guys let's lynch this person just because they're inactive." That's a very basic scum maneuver to get pressure off your wagon.

Unless someone who doesn't have their vote on Gheb is able and willing to hammer on Monday I think it would be in our best interests to consider Sunday the deadline.

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Sang, is your vote on me a pressure vote, or do you actually believe I'm scum?

A bit of both. I'm pressuring you to get back in here but I'm not convinced you are town.

What is up with this argument about Gheb having a "normal" role being a scum tell? Really? Either you believe him or you don't, but that is a stupid reason not to.

Asdioh, what's up with your AA vote?

I won't be able to vote come Monday, either, so we're gonna have to wrap this up before tomorrow night it seems like.

Vult, do you think X1 is scum or town? Why?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Gheb is at L-1 and he's still scummy.

I am not scummy.

 

[July]

What is Madam Pomfrey if not a nurse?

A safeclaim.


Claim changed nothing, Gheb is still scummy and still needs to die, my vote is staying right where it is the rest of the Day and the rest of the goddamn game if he's not lynched toDay >: (

 

[Tandora]

I am not scummy.

You realize that's not the same thing as saying you're not scum, right?

 

[Asdioh]

though I personally wouldn't mind seeing an X1 wagon

ToMorrow, perhaps.



Only willing to lynch Gheb if it's clear nothing else will happen. Sorry if you're town

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Are we really arguing semantics again? July, outside of Gheb, who else do you think could be scum? I can't recall your other scum reads.

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

EBWOP: The first part was directed towards Tandora.

 

[Asdioh]

An AA or JTB lynch is perfectly reasonable toDay, may I remind you. Should we happen to lynch town toDay, that puts us who knows how close to mylo, which puts lynching inactives out of the question, and possibly costing us the game.

Which is why you should have lynched at least one inactive starting D2 (remember that No Lynch that I don't remember because I wasn't here? yeah.)

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

That NL shouldn't have happened and those that stopped it were either stupid or scum. Asdioh, do you want both JTB and AA dead because you think they are scum, or because they are inactive and you think they will be a liability to the town? Also, upon a flip of these people, is there anything you would gain? What about on a Gheb flip?

 

[Gova]

Actually, assuming a 4 man scum team, it will be lylo tomorrow.

 

[Gova]

Wait, nvm. I suck at math.

 

[July]

Are we really arguing semantics again? July, outside of Gheb, who else do you think could be scum? I can't recall your other scum reads.

Town
July
Asdioh
Vult Redux
Tandora

Leaning Town
Shadow Moth
JTB

Null
X1
Sang

Leaning Scum
Gova
AA

Scum
Gheb

Shadow Moth was in EBR's list as deff town, and I agree with Swiss that Shadow Moth is likely town based on that and his interactions with EBR in general. JTB I still think was a super easy switch for both EBR to make in terms of starting a wagon against an inactive, I don't think it was bussing. A Gheb scum flip would reinforce both these reads.

X1 and Sang have been hard for me to read. X1 seems to be thinking and acting with town in mind, but I always worry I'm not reading him deep enough; definitely deserves a reread later. Sang waivers for me, but the thing that sticks with me was coming in after the lynch yesterDay and being totally against it, even though her vote was on the wagon, but she just didn't get to change it. I wouldn't mind either of these people being investigated but they are not people I would like to lynch toMorrow.

AA has been short to comment on anything, to provide reads on anything, to pursue anything; not just when he's inactive, but when he's here I don't see motivation from him to do anything. Gova has been inactive/lurking, and honestly I just haven't gotten much from him but. EBR mentioned him only once in reference to inactivity, which was a big thing for him in trying to avoid his lynch and aimed for Acro/JTB instead. Between the more inactive/lurky players my lynch-list from most lynchable to least goes aa>gova>jtb.

Gheb is scum, obviously you all know that read. Btw Asdioh, Gheb never addressed the issues you had with his play and interactions with RR and Tandora, which were contradictory.

Also this is my surge of activity/insight for a little while, trying to balance classes and mafia kicking my *** a bit lately.

An AA or JTB lynch is perfectly reasonable toDay, may I remind you. Should we happen to lynch town toDay, that puts us who knows how close to mylo, which puts lynching inactives out of the question, and possibly costing us the game.

Which is why you should have lynched at least one inactive starting D2 (remember that No Lynch that I don't remember because I wasn't here? yeah.)

Well then, we shouldn't lynch town toDay, which I think we have a much greater chance of doing if we lynch AA or JTB toDay rather than Gheb.

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Sang waivers for me, but the thing that sticks with me was coming in after the lynch yesterDay and being totally against it, even though her vote was on the wagon, but she just didn't get to change it.

I was not totally against it. Actually, before that, I was all for it and was willing to go for an Asdioh lynch. But, as the day wore on, I had started having doubts on the validity of my read but was unable to post all that often. When I came back to voice these doubts, RR had already voted and I was unable to do anything.

Regardless, thank you. Could you give me a reason for your town read on Vult?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

You realize that's not the same thing as saying you're not scum, right?

He said I'm scummy but I'm not so I tell him I'm not scummy.

PS: I'm not scum either.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Votecount 5-4

6/11 to lynch.

Gheb [5]: July, Shadow Moth, X1-12, Vult Redux, Tandora
Asdioh [2]: Gheb, JTB
asianaussie [2]: SangfroidWarrior, Asdioh

Not voting: Gova, asianaussie

------------------------------------------------------------

[collapse=Vote Log] X1-12 > Gheb
Gova
JTB > Asdioh
Gheb > Asdioh
July > Gheb
Vult Redux > JTB > Gheb
Asdioh > JTB > asianaussie
asianaussie
Shadow Moth > Gheb
SangfroidWarrior > asianaussie
Tandora > Gheb > JTB > Gheb
[/collapse]

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

If this keeps going on nothing is gonna happen but a Gheb lynch. I can't tell if people just aren't here or if scum are content that they don't have to do anything. This is really going knowhere fast.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I don't wanna play this game anymore.

Unvote Vote Gheb

 

[asianaussie]

I've had a bad cold for the past few days and didn't want to contribute if all it meant was fluff (because I'm already a serial inactive, after all).

I hope I get nightkilled. You hear me, scum?

 

[Asdioh]

I hear you.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Votecount 5-5

6/11 to lynch.

Gheb [6]: July, Shadow Moth, X1-12, Vult Redux, Tandora, Gheb
asianaussie [2]: SangfroidWarrior, Asdioh
Asdioh [1]: JTB

Not voting: Gova, asianaussie

------------------------------------------------------------

[collapse=Vote Log] X1-12 > Gheb
Gova
JTB > Asdioh
Gheb > Asdioh > Gheb
July > Gheb
Vult Redux > JTB > Gheb
Asdioh > JTB > asianaussie
asianaussie
Shadow Moth > Gheb
SangfroidWarrior > asianaussie
Tandora > Gheb > JTB > Gheb
[/collapse]

A lynch has been reached!

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Night 5!

"Aguamenti!"

For the first time in days, everyone had a shower. Magic truly is a wonderful thing. The partygoers all shot their wands into the air, a toast to the return of their memories. Then they turned their wands to Gheb and shot him in the face.

Gheb_01 was dressed as Bridget's Mum, as seen in Bridget Jones's Diary (2001). He was really Madam Pomfrey, Town Nurse.​

Immediately after murdering her by face explosion, the partygoers mourned the loss of this matronly sub-character and retreated to their new beds (which had previously been piles of books ironically referred to as beds). Three cheers for magic!

Night 5 starts now and lasts 48 hours.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Day 6!

The sun rose over the Black Lake and the Forbidden Forest. No longer were these elements of the setting namelessly hinted at by the narrator, but instead they were overtly named! Also, in the morning there was a pool of blood, and someone missing. But where was the corpse?

asianaussie was ???, ??? ???.​

The author reused his last Day's dialogue, the lazy sot. But the partygoers weren't at all bothered by this, and continued with their standard daily activity of killing one another.


Day 6 starts now! Deadline is October 4th at 12 p.m. Eastern.
With 9 players left, it's 5 votes to lynch.

 

[Tandora]

I've been looking over AA's posts and I have no idea why he was NK.

 

[asianaussie]

thanks scum, you're cool

go town etc

 

[SangfroidWarrior]

Probably because 1) he asked for it and 2) he hasn't done much and no connections can be gained from killing him.

 

[JTB]

Vote: Asdioh

 

[JTB]

Not opposed to a mass claim with 3 scum left probably.