Even if you're mad about the outcome or are ridiculously excited for Bayonetta, you've got to admit, whether outwardly, or in that darkest crater of your mind where your true opinions, horrible or otherwise rest, that there is ABSOLUTELY NO WAY, that she was in the top 5 in North America.
Top 10, sure. I personally don't believe it, but acknowledge the possibility. And forget the argument for "maybe Mickey Mouse and Goku and Shrek were in the top 5", they were'nt. they were thrown out. You can't honestly believe more genuine votes in NA went to her than Snake, Wolf and the Inklings plus some combination of Ice Climbers, Isaac, K. Rool, Dixie, Waddle Dee, and whoever else Nintendo already owns.
And I'm not "hurt" because my character didn't make it in. (I voted once for Bomber-man and left it at that). I'm just genuinely irked that they announced that she was the "winner".
Had they said of the highest requested submissions , she, to the development team, seemed most interesting, and that they chose her and were excited to present her to us, I would have accepted it. But to declare her the "winner" is indeed fishy.
There are the obvious legal and technical reasons why Snake, Inklings and the Ice Climbers were likely passed over, but as complicated and intricate as she appears, it's clear she was chosen, and not by us, by them.
And why not throw in how she did in the Japanese votes? Who did they want? They may worship Corrin and Cloud for all I know, but I bet none of the 3 were in their top 5 either.
"Of your top suggestions, this is who we chose". That's all I need to feel like something's not being kept from me.
They never had to make the winner, but that doesn't mean they can declare the most "realizable" character the "winner".