Game: Who would you rather have?

[loganhogan]

Birdo, I dislike detest Waluigi

Paper Luigi or Paper Bowser?

 

[Zuby]

Paper Luigi with alternate costume.

Pyrrhon or Ashei?

 

[DukeofShorts]

Pyrrhon because he is fire

Indiana Jones or James Bond

 

[Groose]

Indiana Jones. A whip based fighter would be better than a gun based fighter. Probably.

Master Hand or Sandbag?

 

[KingofPhantoms]

Indiana Jones. A whip based fighter would be better than a gun based fighter. Probably.

Master Hand or Sandbag?

Master Hand, because I've always wanted to fight smaller beings with my hand he has epic powers, is fought at Final Destination, and doesn't need combos.

Darth Vader or General Grievous?

 

[Pacack]

Indiana Jones. A whip based fighter would be better than a gun based fighter. Probably.

Master Hand or Sandbag?

Sandbag. Let him get his revenge >:-)

Derp. Just noticed the ninja...Darth Vader because he sounds like my cat(who has asthma)

King K. Rool or King Dedede?

 

[SuperBrawler]

King K. Rool.

Pac Man or Bomberman?

 

[Gam3rALO]

King K. Rool.

Pac Man or Bomberman?

PAC MAN!!!!!!!

Roy or Ike?

 

[shinhed-echi]

PAC MAN!!!!!!!

Roy or Ike?

Roy's our boy!


Lyndis or Micaiah?

 

[Groose]

Micaiah. She'd add more variety.

Duck Hunt Dog or Sheriff?

 

[SuperBrawler]

That's a toughie, I'll have to go with DHD.

Lip or Mach Rider?

 

[LaniusShrike]

That's a toughie, I'll have to go with DHD.

Lip or Mach Rider?

I'll go with Mach Rider, just out of personal preference for character design. And because I've made a moveset for him/her.

Van Helsing (the famed vampire hunter) or Boba Fett (the famed bounty hunter)?

 

[Opossum]

Tough one, since they'd both be neat, but I have to say Mach Rider. He's awesome, and so is his theme song.
Darn. Boba, because he's cool.
May as well keep a retro theme going. Muddy Mole or Lip?

 

[SuperBrawler]

I'd choose Lip, I always liked her moveset,

Little Mac, or Knuckle Joe?

 

[KingofPhantoms]

I'd choose Lip, I always liked her moveset,

Little Mac, or Knuckle Joe?

Little Mac. Nuff said.

Again, Darth Vader or General Grievous?

 

[SuperBrawler]

I'm the only person here so...

Darth Vader, He's awesome.

Samurai Goroh, or Black Shadow?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Little Mac. Nuff said.

Again, Darth Vader or General Grievous?

Grievous, because we don't have a rapid, multi-armed combatant yet.
Also, it'd irritate people that he got in but more important Star Wars characters didn't.

Edit: Sniped!
I'ma go with Black Shadow. For reasons. Ganondorf adjacent reasons... also, he's funny.

Your (whoever responds to this) most recent ex or your parents as a duo character?

Spoiler

GETTIN' PERSONAL NOW!

 

[SuperBrawler]

Oops we posted at the same time, lawl.

My parents, not to beat them up, but to play as them. XD

As I said, Samurai Goroh, or Black Shadow?

EDIT: oops, confusion, sorry, Takamaru or Saki?

 

[Opossum]

Goroh, definitely. Heck, I made the support thread.

Hades from Kid Icarus or Hades from Hercules?

 

[SuperBrawler]

Goroh, definitely. Heck, I made the support thread.

Hades from Kid Icarus or Hades from Hercules?

We're all getting confused because of that,

Anyway, Hades from Kid Icarus,

So Takamaru or Saki?

 

[Cheezey Bites]

My ex so I could beat him up.

Spoiler

Also, I only have one parent

EDITVERY sniped due to internet issues, I'm surprised it even upped.

and I've been sniped after tool; whoop!


Falling block puzzle battle!

Lip, Dr Mario OR Arle Nadja

(considered Pac-Attack, Yoshi and Wario's Woods, but then the other wouldn't get a look in)

 

[LaniusShrike]

Oops we posted at the same time, lawl.

My parents, not to beat them up, but to play as them. XD

As I said, Samurai Goroh, or Black Shadow?

EDIT: oops, confusion, sorry, Takamaru or Saki?

Goroh, definitely. Heck, I made the support thread.

Hades from Kid Icarus or Hades from Hercules?

Replyin' to both since Brawler changed the characters.

I say Takamaru, simply because he's got a bit more moveset fodder, but I'm pretty ambivalent about it. They'd both be slick additions.

I am inclined to say Hades from KI simply because, well, he's actually eligible in the first place. Maybe someday Square Enix will make a Kingdom Hearts brawler game and James Woods Hades can be in that one.

Edit: @Cheezey
I want the Doc as an alt. costume, so I'm gonna go for Lip. As for Arle... well, I've never heard of her, but looking her up I have to say I'm not too fond of Japan's habit of sticking prepubescent girls in miniskirts.

Mascot battle!
Jack of Jack in the Box or Wendy from Wendy's?

 

[shinhed-echi]

We're all getting confused because of that,

Anyway, Hades from Kid Icarus,

So Takamaru or Saki?

Saki.

Laser Sword + Laser Gun = awesome.


Lark from Pilotwings VS Alice from Balloon Kid.

A battle of the skies.

 

[loganhogan]

Alice

Fire Emblem wyvern female riders out of these which do you pick?
Minerva, Altenna, Eda, Miredy, Vaida, Jill, or Cherche?

 

[Opossum]

Alice

Fire Emblem wyvern red headed riders out of these which do you pick?
Minerva, Altenna, Eda, Miredy, Vaida, Jill, or Cherche?

Cherche! She's awesome in Awakening.

To continue an Awakening theme: Lon'Qu or Say'ri?

 

[SuperBrawler]

Say'ri has good stats? Lol haven't played FE.

Slippy Toad, or Peppy Hare?

 

[Game&Watcher]

Ricken or Miriel? (Both from FE:A)

 

[Groose]

I hate Ricken's design, so I'm going with Miriel here.

Chrom, Lucina, Robin, or Owain? All are of Awakening fame.

 

[jaytalks]

Lucina!
Proto-Man, Bass, Shadow, or Knuckles?

 

[Cheezey Bites]

TAILS!

Spoiler

okay, Knuckles... but I think tails should be the priority second sonic character.

Luigi or Peach?

 

[Gingerbread Man]

Peach, nobody likes luigi.


sonic or snake?

 

[Game&Watcher]

Sonic, because if I were Sakurai, I wouldn't want to risk losing a lot of the consumer base by not including the Hedgehog.

A second Wario rep or a second Yoshi rep?

 

[Zuby]

Sonic, because if I were Sakurai, I wouldn't want to risk losing a lot of the consumer base by not including the Hedgehog.

A second Wario rep or a second Yoshi rep?

I disagree with your premise that Sonic majorly influences sales, and I continue to campaign for Dillion as a like for like replacement.
But that's a discussion for a different thread, so to answer your question:

A second Wario rep, because I think Waluigi is more deserving than any secondary Yoshi character. I can't even think of a Yoshi character off the top of my head apart from Kamek, and I've never really bought into the idea that Yoshi is a separate franchise to Mario.



Lyra, May, Dawn or Hilda? (each with an identical Pokémon team)

 

[IsmaR]

But that's a discussion for a different thread

I realize and agree with this above all else, buuuuuuuuuuuut

Wario rep

Waluigi

Lyra, May, Dawn or Hilda? (each with an identical Pokémon team)

Bustin' balls making me choose between the lot of 'em, but I think Dawn had the longest run/biggest impact. I just like her design (with May and Hilda not too far behind) and think that 4th Gen is going to get the most love this time around.

Marth and Chrom, or Lucina and Ike?
The only differences being aesthetics (meaning both pairs would have the same movesets as Brawl's FE reps).

 

[Cheezey Bites]

Dillion as a like for like replacement [to Sonic]

That would be an insult to Dillon. He has his own moves (Dynamite, Claws, Digging) and should play very differently to Sonic.


Marth and Chrom, 'cos Marth shouldn't be going anywhere.

Double Character tiem:

Bub and Bob (Bubble Bobble), Lolo and Lala (Adventures of Lolo), Chrom and Lucina (FE:A), Plusle and Minun or Pkachu Coloured Pichu and Spiky Eared Pichu (both pokemon)?

 

[LaniusShrike]

That would be an insult to Dillon. He has his own moves (Dynamite, Claws, Digging) and should play very differently to Sonic.


Marth and Chrom, 'cos Marth shouldn't be going anywhere.

Double Character tiem:

Bub and Bob (Bubble Bobble), Lolo and Lala (Adventures of Lolo), Chrom and Lucina (FE:A), Plusle and Minun or Pkachu Coloured Pichu and Spiky Eared Pichu (both pokemon)?

I'm gonna go with Bub and Bob. I loved the game, and I'm sure their moveset could open up some interesting mechanics. I'd probably prefer the character as a solo dino, but whateva.

Goomba or Shy Guy?

 

[Game&Watcher]

Shy Guy, he has more going for him, including incorporating Fly Guy as a recovery.

A second not-Waluigi Wario rep or a second Yoshi rep?

 

[Pazzo.]

Shy Guy, he has more going for him, including incorporating Fly Guy as a recovery.

A second not-Waluigi Wario rep or a second Yoshi rep?

Second Wario rep. Yoshi reps seem.. lacking. Maybe Ashley...

Scratch that, I remember Bandit from Yoshi's Island. Bandit FTW.

Majora or Vaati?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Second Wario rep. Maybe Ashley...

Majora or Vaati?

*Fun Fact*

I've actually never played a Zelda game all the way through... I'm trying Wind Waker.

Vaati. He's just more of a character and he's been in more games. Plus, I just like him more and I think a Wind Mage would be a fun gameplay addition.

The Spelunker from Spelunky or Quote from Cave Story?

 

[Pazzo.]

Vaati. He's just more of a character and he's been in more games. Plus, I just like him more and I think a Wind Mage would be a fun gameplay addition.

The Spelunker from Spelunky or Quote from Cave Story?

Quote, hands down. I love Cave Story, and I'm not familiar with Spelunky.

Henry from Fire Emblem: Awakening, or Fawful from Mario Superstar saga?