Game: Who would you rather have?

[Kamiko]

Mido literally has no moveset potential, while Groose has enough to sustain a character. Also, who in the heck cares about Mido?

Cole from Infamous or Alex Mercer from Prototype?

Definitely Cole.

Stalfos or Space Pirate?

 

[Gilius Thunderhead]

Stalfos or Space Pirate?

Space Pirate.

Banjo&Kazooie or Pac-man?

 

[Gam3rALO]

Space Pirate.

Banjo&Kazooie or Pac-man?

PAC MAN!!!!!!!

Wolf or Krystal?

 

[Opossum]

Wolf in a heartbeat.

Kellam or Frederick?

 

[loganhogan]

Wolf in a heartbeat.

Kellam or Frederick?

Frederick or who?



Kellam

Patricia Wagon or Shantae?

 

[Hank Hill]

Shantae (I'm still questioning GameInformer giving them a 3/10...)

Roy or Ike?

 

[Opossum]

Ike for me. We like Ike, after all.

Snorlax or Genesect?

 

[KingofPhantoms]

Shantae (I'm still questioning GameInformer giving them a 3/10...)

Roy or Ike?

Roy, because Ike would be prepared to get cut.

Ike for me. We like Ike, after all.

Snorlax or Genesect?

Genesect would be epic to play as.

Sora or Cloud?

 

[Forde]

Roy, because Ike would be prepared to get cut.



Genesect would be epic to play as.

Sora or Cloud?

Cloud, because watching a Cloud vs Link/Cloud vs Marth/Cloud vs Ike/Cloud vs Any swordsman would be awesome. And, imho, is a lot cooler than Sora. And is probably in my top 10 if not 5 favorite characters.

Blaziken vs Lucario?

 

[DukeofShorts]

Cloud just because he would be a lot cooler as a playable character.

Funky Kong or Pianta

 

[Zuby]

Blaziken for a Hoenn rep.

Funky Kong, for the prospect of zipping about in the barrel plane.


Flannery with no Pokémon or Ashley Robbins?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Blaziken for a Hoenn rep.

Funky Kong, for the prospect of zipping about in the barrel plane.


Flannery with no Pokémon or Ashley Robbins?

I... I mistakenly tried to look up "Ashley Robbins".

Is there a video game character? Because the name is definitely more strongly associated with a more pornacious pursuit.

Ah, finally found her video game character. She seems interesting... I'm a bit biased because I like seeing female protagonists and, as someone who's half white/half Asian, I really like seeing mixed heritage characters like her.

Also, what's the point of Pokemon trainers without their pokemon?

In honor of the Castlevania games I've been playing... Trevor Belmont or Soma Cruz?

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Belmot!

Gotta rep that family somehow!

COD Dog or Battlefield Tank?

 

[DukeofShorts]

Tank—because it's a tank.

Hammer Bro or Ephraim?

 

[KingofPhantoms]

Tank—because it's a tank.

Hammer Bro or Ephraim?

Hammer Bro., because throwing hammers at people would be fun, we've only ever been able to swing hammers in Smash.

WALL-E or Johnny-5?

 

[Oracle_Summon]

Hammer Bro., because throwing hammers at people would be fun, we've only ever been able to swing hammers in Smash.

WALL-E or Johnny-5?

WALL-E, because I believe Johnny-5's design would make some kids cry since it looks pretty scary.

Dixie Kong or Palutena?

 

[MoonlapseOpethian]

WALL-E, because I believe Johnny-5's design would make some kids cry since it looks pretty scary.


Dixie Kong or Palutena?

Palutena. KI franchise deserves a new rep after Uprising, and Dixie looks too much like Diddy. Can't have another Ness/Lucas incident.

Waluigi or Chrom?

 

[Opossum]

Chrom definitely. He's awesome.

Tingle or Groose?

 

[Gilius Thunderhead]

Chrom definitely. He's awesome.

Tingle or Groose?

Tingle because he's actually had his own game.

Dante or Bayonetta?

 

[loganhogan]

Bayonetta at least one of her games will be on a Nintendo console.

A Nintendodog or Nintendocat?

 

[Gilius Thunderhead]

A Nintendodog or Nintendocat?

Nintendog

Ristar or Starfy?

 

[Opossum]

Starfy. He's just awesome.

Tempo or Dillon?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Dillion. He seems like a good Sonic replacement.

Speaking of:

Sonic or Snake?

 

[Opossum]

Dillion. He seems like a good Sonic replacement.

Speaking of:

Sonic or Snake?

Snake. He has such a nice moveset.

Maxwell from Scribblenauts or Bayonetta?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Maxwell in a heartbeat.

Ike or Lucario?

 

[Cheezey Bites]

Bayonetta; Maxwell comes from a game where almost anything is possible, to deny any of those possibilities (as would be needed to make a moveset) would be disappointing, plus Gun shoes are kinda cool.

SNIPED!

I like Ike

Plusle and Minun OR Pikachu Coloured Pichu and Spiky Eared Pichu?

 

[Diddy Kong]

I think Pichu is cuter than both Plusle and Minun. And he got into Melee. So I'm probably choosing the Pichus. Hard choice however. As I also like Plusle and Minun, and they'd be a great way to 'rep the 3rd Gen' and all that gibberish.

Takamaru or Mach Rider?

 

[Opossum]

As much as I like Takamaru, I have to say Mach Rider. Dat theme.

Tamagon or Lip?

 

[loganhogan]

I never played either game but Lip has an interesting design, Takamaru looks like a Fire Emblem character.

Lip

Mallo or Dillon?

 

[Gilius Thunderhead]

Dillon.

Captain Rainbow or Captain N?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Captain Rainbow. I'm no American so I hold no vallue / nostalgia for Captain N (nor MegaMan). At least Captain Rainbow looks somewhat interessting. And, he'd make a nice rival for Captain Falcon.

Isaac or Shulk?

 

[Gilius Thunderhead]

Isaac. Golden Sun should have been repped already anyways.

*1st party character of your choice* or *3rd party character of your choice*?

 

[Opossum]

Isaac, definitely. He's awesome.


Drat. First Party.

Aeron or Zael?

 

[Groose]

It's tough, because I'd rather have Shulk than either of them. I haven't really even considered either of them. I guess I'll go Aeron because he's just a bit cooled in my opinion.

SS Zelda and SS Impa or Brawl/TP Zelda/Sheik?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Impa baby!!

Groose or Midna?

 

[Pacack]

It's tough, because I'd rather have Shulk than either of them. I haven't really even considered either of them. I guess I'll go Aeron because he's just a bit cooled in my opinion.

SS Zelda and SS Impa or Brawl/TP Zelda/Sheik?

SS Zelda and SS Impa because SS's ending involving Impa was beautiful :')

EDIT: Drat. Midna because she was more important than Groose.

Megaman X or Classic Sonic?

 

[Groose]

SS Zelda and SS Impa because SS's ending involving Impa was beautiful :')

EDIT: Drat. Midna because she was more important than Groose.

Megaman X or Classic Sonic?

Midna because I actually don't support Groose for Smash.


Classic Sawnik. I mean, one Mega Man is good enough and I'd like to make sure Sonic is a definite, too.

Rawk Hawk or Wobbuffet?

 

[Sane.]

SS Zelda and SS Impa because SS's ending involving Impa was beautiful :')

EDIT: Drat. Midna because she was more important than Groose.

Megaman X or Classic Sonic?

Classic Sonic since they're already using Classic Mega Man and I hate clones.

ChaCha from Monster Hunter Tri or Bomberman?

Midna because I actually don't support Groose for Smash.


Classic Sawnik. I mean, one Mega Man is good enough and I'd like to make sure Sonic is a definite, too.


Rawk Hawk or Wobbuffet?

Rawk Hawk, since Wobbuffet doesn't seem active enough for SSB playstyle.

ChaCha from Monster Hunter Tri or Bomberman?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Both are awesome. Hard choice. Yet, Rawk Hawk has this awesomeness going for him. Also, am glad to see new Impa supporters. But yeah, Rawk Hawk.

Speaking of:

Paper Mario or Geno

NINJA'D heavily... Oh the shame...

Anyway, Cha Cha was awesome, so Cha Cha.

 

[KingofPhantoms]

Both are awesome. Hard choice. Yet, Rawk Hawk has this awesomeness going for him. Also, am glad to see new Impa supporters. But yeah, Rawk Hawk.

Speaking of:

Paper Mario or Geno

NINJA'D heavily... Oh the shame...

Anyway, Cha Cha was awesome, so Cha Cha.

Geno, because his moveset would be an epic magic based one, and I don't want a second Mario. Dry Bowser should be a second Bowser.

Birdo or Waluigi?