Disco Room from the Disco Room! DGames Reject Copy

[Requiem]

wait what if they would have killed the survivor and not a townie?

 

[Purple]

It wouldn't matter, they would still win, survivor is third - party yes, but is shown as a townie.

By the way, there was no survivor.

I read overall what everyone did here so i thought i would give out some pointers.

Exn, with all of your information, you need to learn to take charge when you're townie, if bunglefever happened to be mafia, you guys would have lost faster than you did (actually, that's impossible lol, bunglefever gave you the fastest way imaginable to lose XD). But you had very good leads, KevinM generally played very tipsy turvy, he stopped asking questions after day 1 and in general ignored questions, while he may ahve generally overlooked them, town would be more interested in discussing with other town than that. You pretty much had everything set for day 2, but you need to be aggressive.

Bunglefever, you generally lead very well, and understand how the game works, but you had bad choices. This setup was from the get-go different than usual (10 people). You should've expected the worst possible scenario. Leaving two mafia and EIGHT TOWNS PEOPLE (any smart survivor would side with town). Leads you to have *counts on fingers* three random lynches. That's entirely unfair to mafia and you truely shouldn't have expected that that was the setup. shame shame.

Fragbait, you don't know how to play a good town from what i saw. If you don't want to give too much information that would kill one of your comrades, ask questions just like everyone else, remain calm, and give a finger of suspicion to someone from 'evidence' you gathered through questioning. You will not only seem helpful, but you won't be hurting mafia either, after all, it was just a mess up decision on your part right? . Also if someone accuses you, getting frantic would hurt more than help, however i've found it best to ask questions and try to fully understand why someone thinks you're mafia, and discuss it. Instead of saying "NO THAT'S WRONG! YOU'RE WRONG!", tell them you understand and explain your reasoning. Hell, counter claim and give the same logic back if it helps, but remain calm and active in situations like that, they are critical to help the vote remain off of you.

RocketPSIence, you generally want to make sure you don't give out your role day 1, regardless of whether or not you'll be lynched or not. Do not play overly helpful, as you will be a threat to mafia that way, however play helpful enough to where you aren't of suspicion, it's a very thing line, and i apologize that you had to take your first game into a power role, but it's a lesson learned.

KevinM, i'm not sure how you generally play, but you consistently switched back and forth, i don't see how bunglefever didn't personally catch you in that, but whatever ; your scum record remains untarnished :D

Wingz, you seemed a bit too hesitant to change your emotions to get vote off of you, i'm not sure if it was because you were inactive at the time or not, but generally speaking i can't even remember much of what you did in mafia. You seemed to blend in with the general activity of the game, this would be great for mafia-sided ideals, but not town-sided.

​

 

[Requiem]

lol nice mindgame

 

[Purple]

i think i explained that wrong, third-party members generally aren't added as scum. Think about this scenario, all mafia members were dead and only the survivor and townies were left; survivor wouldn't be considered scum correct? In fact, he still wins. Third party members just have different ways of winning that can help/hurt both sides of a mafia game.​

 

[Xivii]

Well that was fun. Thanks for the intro Roxy. I'll definitely play again.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Survivor like you said is a third party, he doesn't count towards either. I wasn't going to assume 8v2. I was assuming 7v2v1 where it could be 8v2 7v3.

I admit my read Rei was wrong, I pushed a bad lynch. I started getting an odd feeling from Kevin when he was agreeing with me on Wingz, and a bad feeling in general about everyone that was joining the lynch. I'm generally used to more time to work things out than what we had. No Johns though, I played a bad game.

yeah any smart survivor would begin to side with town d1. Mislynch once + night kill you're down to 5v3v1, now how od oyu side with? It's not hat simple. If i had felt, as survivor, mafia was playing the better game (which they would have been in thsi case) i would've sided iwth them even if the numbers weren't quite in my favor, as another mislynch = a win for me.

My thoughts were based on the assumption that there was a survivor in the game, which, I admit, wasn't good to begin with, but I felt justified in my actions because of it.

Generally i find 10 people is a weird number to work with for straight up town vs mafia. But that's just me.

I think the minimum number for 3 mafia should be 11 and the max for 2 should be 9 so..*shrug*

 

[rPSIvysaur]

Thanks Roxy.

Anyway, here's what was official. It's a good thing I died b/c I requested to see what Bungle was.
Exn (T)
Wingz35 (T)
-Rei- (T)
BungleFever (M)
Vrael (T)
Fragbait(MAF)
Ndayday (T)
KevinM (MAF)
Sinz (MAF)
RocketPsience (COP)

 

[rPSIvysaur]

We should do another one soon.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I was vacaville? lame.

If you guys give me a week or so I can come up with a set up that's got a little bit more to it if you want.

 

[Sinz]

It wouldn't matter, they would still win, survivor is third - party yes, but is shown as a townie.

By the way, there was no survivor.

I read overall what everyone did here so i thought i would give out some pointers.

Exn, with all of your information, you need to learn to take charge when you're townie, if bunglefever happened to be mafia, you guys would have lost faster than you did (actually, that's impossible lol, bunglefever gave you the fastest way imaginable to lose XD). But you had very good leads, KevinM generally played very tipsy turvy, he stopped asking questions after day 1 and in general ignored questions, while he may ahve generally overlooked them, town would be more interested in discussing with other town than that. You pretty much had everything set for day 2, but you need to be aggressive.

Bunglefever, you generally lead very well, and understand how the game works, but you had bad choices. This setup was from the get-go different than usual (10 people). You should've expected the worst possible scenario. Leaving two mafia and EIGHT TOWNS PEOPLE (any smart survivor would side with town). Leads you to have *counts on fingers* three random lynches. That's entirely unfair to mafia and you truely shouldn't have expected that that was the setup. shame shame.

Fragbait, you don't know how to play a good town from what i saw. If you don't want to give too much information that would kill one of your comrades, ask questions just like everyone else, remain calm, and give a finger of suspicion to someone from 'evidence' you gathered through questioning. You will not only seem helpful, but you won't be hurting mafia either, after all, it was just a mess up decision on your part right? . Also if someone accuses you, getting frantic would hurt more than help, however i've found it best to ask questions and try to fully understand why someone thinks you're mafia, and discuss it. Instead of saying "NO THAT'S WRONG! YOU'RE WRONG!", tell them you understand and explain your reasoning. Hell, counter claim and give the same logic back if it helps, but remain calm and active in situations like that, they are critical to help the vote remain off of you.

RocketPSIence, you generally want to make sure you don't give out your role day 1, regardless of whether or not you'll be lynched or not. Do not play overly helpful, as you will be a threat to mafia that way, however play helpful enough to where you aren't of suspicion, it's a very thing line, and i apologize that you had to take your first game into a power role, but it's a lesson learned.

KevinM, i'm not sure how you generally play, but you consistently switched back and forth, i don't see how bunglefever didn't personally catch you in that, but whatever ; your scum record remains untarnished :D

Wingz, you seemed a bit too hesitant to change your emotions to get vote off of you, i'm not sure if it was because you were inactive at the time or not, but generally speaking i can't even remember much of what you did in mafia. You seemed to blend in with the general activity of the game, this would be great for mafia-sided ideals, but not town-sided.

​

I get no shout out =(

 

[Xivii]

Sinz is too good. I probably wouldn't have suspected him. I was 90% sure Bungle was town. I went into super deep sage mode thinking with the Aladdin pic. I started doubting myself when he started siding with kevin and started pushing for Wingz, but I figured Kev was just gaming him. I kind of hoped that once Wingz agreed to his own lynch everyone would see he was town and then we could go for Frag and possibly Kevin.

Messed up bad with Rei. I couldn't get off of him. ~_~

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Sinz did super well with his bussing of Fragbait, kudos to you.

Hey everyone, Dgames is hosting a game (SwordsRBroken to be specific) that's supposed to be pretty basic and I think those of you who are interested in more mafia should go join! You'd get a ton more experience. You can go to the mafia sign up thread an /in for Sword's game.


/selfless promoting of dgames

 

[rPSIvysaur]

So what would it take to hold another mafia for DR?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Interest, that's about it.

 

[rPSIvysaur]

I'm in for another one, I want more experience.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Let's see how others respond, in the mean time ill try to put something together, unless Roxy wants to again.

 

[Xivii]

Another DR one would be great. I'll check out that one in Dgames Jungle.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Cool

I just drew up a pretty good set up.

I'll give it a couple days and then maybe start isgnups in Roxy's original thread?

unless of course he wants to mod again

 

[Requiem]

And Roxy, you're quite right. I'm almost always anti town in games ^^;

this was actually my first time as town I now remember o_O; So I guess I sucked monkey balls.
I'll do better next time.

Roxy, why 3 scum in such a small game? o_O;

 

[Purple]

And Roxy, you're quite right. I'm almost always anti town in games ^^;

this was actually my first time as town I now remember o_O; So I guess I sucked monkey balls.
I'll do better next time.

Roxy, why 3 scum in such a small game? o_O;

basically what i said earlier, three scum to 7 people is generally not that bad. you get a mislynch and then a lynch or lose scenario. In epic mafia games that tends to be how games work (or 6:2:1 traitor) and we never have problems winning either town or mafia.

But the main reason the game was ****ed up from the beginning was because i accidentally let another person join when i shouldn't have, it should've been a nine man group, with two mafia, a survivor, and the general 6.

I would like to play the next game, so bunglefever you can mod it. I'm sure you're better than i am anyways.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

hmm

how shoudl we go about gaining interest for a new one?

this game has to be unstickied?


Roxy maybe edit your other thread that i bumped tos ay 'new signups fornew game!' or something?

 

[Sinz]

Bungle just make a new thread.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I DONT WANNNAAA

right now

i'll do it later

 

[Requiem]

basically what i said earlier, three scum to 7 people is generally not that bad. you get a mislynch and then a lynch or lose scenario. In epic mafia games that tends to be how games work (or 6:2:1 traitor) and we never have problems winning either town or mafia.

But the main reason the game was ****ed up from the beginning was because i accidentally let another person join when i shouldn't have, it should've been a nine man group, with two mafia, a survivor, and the general 6.

I would like to play the next game, so bunglefever you can mod it. I'm sure you're better than i am anyways.

I was gonna make a post, but I forgot what it was when I found out you can make hitler smileys





: »(

 

[Sinz]

Roxyyyyyyyyyyy I wanna hear shoutout from you.

 

[-Rei-]

we lost =[

 

[Sinz]

Yeah, but it was staked against you guys to start with. =/

 

[Purple]

Sinz i'm going to make one soon chiilllll

that was only part one lol

 

[Requiem]

I kind of hoped that once Wingz agreed to his own lynch everyone would see he was town and then we could go for Frag and possibly Kevin.

Yeah I actually got that hint because of your question, it's 50% of why I went with it lol.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

There was absolutely no way with the little time we had left that we could've turned it around.

 

[Sinz]

In a best case scenario.
You would have lynched Frag then we nightkill exn or bungle. leaving 4 to 2. Then you would have attacked either wingz or kevin. assuming kevin it would have gone 3 to one. Then, it would have been me left. I had a big case left incase that came up.

 

[Requiem]

I blame Teran.

edit: Sinz, what was the case about? O:

 

[Sinz]

good choice.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I kinda disagree with what Roxy said about being overly helpful. You might get Nk'd yeah, but you're winning as a team, not as an individual. Honestly, there's nothign BAD about being overly helpful. You only hurt by avoiding questions, lurking, and trying to be reserved. If you're town you have absolutely nothing to hide.

Also, your first line of defense shouldn't be to out yourself as a power role, but if it's to save your skin you might as well. In a game without a doc it didn't matter, you would've died anyway, but there are many reasons to attempt to keep PR's alive from a mafia standpoint.

Generally this game I took charge because I wanted to get all you really into this game, and show you how fun it can be! I don't normally play like this and am i **** ton more reserved, Kevin will vouch. I think you guys learned alot just by playing and just need to keep on playing more!

 

[fragbait]

I had fun, and had 3 great teachers as well. Kev, Sinz, Bungle, I will be playing again soon. Thanks for the fun time!

*brofists all*

 

[ndayday]

Yeah that was fun.

I'd definitely be more...contributing? next time. I was suspicious of Today from the start but didn't have anything to back it up. I don't know. She played kind of aggressive and too townie imo. So then when she got switched with Sinz, I was really thrown off since he plays completely different. :I

I'd be up for another game too, but not anytime soon. I have so much work to do in school.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Wow this was really fun, even though town got *****.

Good **** Sinz, Frag, and Kevin. I never really suspected Sinz or Kevin at all.

I'll definitely be playing again whether it's here or in DGames.

 

[KevinM]

The thing is Roxy once I had bungle I no longer had to be cautious, because he's townieness just let me ride it out

 

[DtJ Jungle]

>: (

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Last DRoom game to be moved. Enjoy