Fact: X1 claimed Dixie Kong, Town Day Cop. (See X1's
#407)
[collapse="Reason #1 that X1 is scum"]Let's take a look at J's #596:
X1-12 is town to me because of his obnoxious behavior this game. He is trying to scum-hunt but the only thing that scares me about this is the fact that he played the exact same way as an indie in B&F. However he also claimed DayCop iirc which can be easily tested so we will see what happens. Still skeptical on two cops in one game but I'm not lynching claimed PRs.
J said this. So why the flip did this happen:
Seems someone used their DayCop on me.
Are you claiming scum, then?
No, but let's let it play out.
I feel like having fun.
J knew X1 "claiming Day Cop" was a gambit or trick that X1 used before. Soon after posting 596, J falls for X1's "gambit" if you will... but does so in a very obvious fashion. Did J seriously just say "Seems someone used their DayCop on me" followed by "No [I'm not claiming scum], but let's let it play out
"
For town, this looks amazing at this time; X1 found scum with his gambit. Whoo! However, this is way too coincidental and weird. Out of all the people to choose to try and hit with his gambit, he went for J. Lucky? I think not. After the flip J turns up Mafia Goon. Convenient for scum? Totally worth the trade for scum to lose a goon that doesn't want to play anymore to ensure X1 looks like town.
* I took out the colors in the quotes cause they annoying for me (as J knows) and changed it to black text instead
.[/collapse]
[collapse="Reason #2 that X1 is scum"]Let's take a look at X1's #604:
@Anyone who knows the flavour: Would it make sense flavour-wise for there to be a closed (non-recruiting) mason pair in this game?
This is after Soup claimed Night Cop and X1 claim Day Cop but before X1 revealed to us he was lying. From the point of view of town, there is no reason to ask this question. Town knows that two cops have claimed, why the flip would a mason pair exist in the same game?
Here's the kicker.
I'm Tiny Kong and I'm masoned with Diddy Kong. We have safe claims so that we don't get outed as masons (for example, Asdioh could be my mason partner even though he claimed TipTup. And no I'm not telling you my safeclaim, and if you ask you're scum.) If Dixie Kong existed in this game wouldn't it make so much more sense to have that character masoned with Diddy Kong... not my character? X1 is scum and his safe claim is Dixie Kong. Do you see the beauty in his play?[/collapse]
@Town, thanks for wasting the early part of this day hastily by harassing me about my play style, calling me scum for not playing like you want, and causing a mason claim which would have been extremely helpful later. =( There was NO REASON to force me to out my information when I was wanted to use it later in the Day. And you know I'm not ******** to wait til near the deadline and cause panic.
Also, I'm not the most experienced player and enjoy playing mafia games to get better. I really didn't appreciate the "you're playing town wrong" comments at all even if I was in your eyes.
Unvote
Vote: X1