Character Discussion Thread

[MagnesD3]

I have a question for you. Did you enjoy Star Fox Adventures? Do you think that game is a good game in the series?

Yes I think its a great zelda game with dinosaurs having starfox characters randomly thrown into the mix, it was old rare's last good game. Most people hate it and blame it for the downfall of starfox even though its a good game.

 

[Deleted member]

So am I the only one who wants Casino Luigi in HD glory? Yeah? Oh...OK

 

[?????????????]

Considering the last bit of the thread has been filled with your inane holier-than-though masturbation, I'd say it's perfectly on topic.

"Oh look at me, I'm more than twenty but I still think commenting on people's age gives me an intellectual edge in the discussion. Oh, look how I take one word out of the dictionary as uber literal ****ing gospel. Gotta respect them trigger-words! Oh, look how I, the bigger man, will respond to public call-outs publicly but insist that confrontation be performed in private where people won't become privvy to how much of a ****wad I am."

Give me a break.

I don't believe my age gives me an intellectual edge, though I do believe it accounts for less than mature comments made by those younger.

This thread is for SSB discussion. Although my posts may be...insulting to you for some reason (?), they were all in regards to the topic of SSB characters.

You are the only one to bring up personal attacks against anyone else.

 

[Niala]

Yes I think its a great zelda game with dinosaurs having starfox characters are randomly thrown into the mix, it was old rare's last good game. Most people hate it and blame it for the downfall of starfox even though its a good game.

Heh, it is quite similar to Zelda games, isn't it? I had never made the comparison.

Thank you for answering.

 

[Morbi]

So am I the only one who wants Casino Luigi in HD glory? Yeah? Oh...OK

Not only do I want a Casino Luigi in HD glory, I want a "Casino" variant of every single character in the game. This includes Wolf.

 

[pupNapoleon]

I don't wanna sound mean but snake really doesn't belong in smash (even tho I want him back since he made it in the first place). Wolf is a Nintendo character who deserves to be in, him being cut says he wasn't important enough to be included and that can drive a fan crazy (also I want to see wolf in hd and I want him buffed)

Ps I'm a huge mgs fan.

Perhaps you may want to consider that some people felt this way about Wolf being in the game, that he did not belong because it over represented Star Fox (or for some other reason).

 

[Kriven]

I don't believe my age gives me an intellectual edge, though I do believe it accounts for less than mature comments made by those younger.

This thread is for SSB discussion. Although my posts may be...insulting to you for some reason (?), they were all in regards to the topic of SSB characters.

You are the only one to bring up personal attacks against anyone else.

Because harassing an individual for their poor word choice and personal connection to a specific aspect of the game isn't an ad-hom attack.

Please.

 

[Deleted member]

Not only do I want a Casino Luigi in HD glory, I want a "Casino" variant of every single character in the game. This includes Wolf.

Shall I throw in Snake or Big Boss as well? Oh wait...I sadly can't. Thanks Kojima!

 

[MagnesD3]

Perhaps you may want to consider that some people felt this way about Wolf being in the game, that he did not belong because it over represented Star Fox (or for some other reason).

Honestly I think that starfox sells enough and is popular enough to have 4 reps (but no more).

Heh, it is quite similar to Zelda games, isn't it? I had never made the comparison.

Thank you for answering.

Do you like star fox adventures?

 

[Morbi]

Honestly I think that starfox sells enough and is popular enough to have 4 reps (but no more).

I certainly agree with this sentiment; however, the notion is subjective. Some delusional nut-case somewhere believes that Wolf AND Falco (and Fox) should be cut because Star Fox was dormant.

 

[?????????????]

Because harassing an individual for their poor word choice and personal connection to a specific aspect of the game isn't an ad-hom attack.

Please.

My intention was not to harass; all I ever did was respond to posts made on here. I have not continued to "harass" this individual as they have not responded to my last post directed towards them. It's back-and-forth: discussion.

My entire point is that I believe it's ridiculous to discredit the entire game because one character is missing. That's an opposing opinion related to the topic of the thread.

 

[Masonomace]

I hope that there are in fact more characters left to be unlocked, but I could also see it staying as is. My thoughts on that are that Sakurai may want us to experience as many characters as possible right from the outset. There may be plenty of different reasons for this, one of them being an attempt to be more "open." Essentially, if Sakurai and Nintendo reveal nearly all the characters to us prior to the game's release, then the leakers can't beat them to the punch. They've technically already failed on that front, but I could see this as Sakurai employing this as a strategy to combat the internet and get ahead of the curve to avoid what happened with Brawl. It's more like 'here are these amazing characters. Have fun with them right away and enjoy yourself.' Obviously this ignores the fact that a lot of the fun and challenge in the game comes from seeing the "New Challenger Approaching" screen and unlocking them yourself.

That's just my take on things.

I hope & feel there may be more unlockable fighters as well. I however do not wish to neither see, accept, nor want the 48 slot roster remained locked. If the starting roster is at a huge 36 based from the Japanese Demo, & there's really only 12 slots left, then I am eggstremely satisfied not buying a 3DS only for Sm4sh,as that game aspect to 'enjoy all of this' does not appeal to me. I envision all of the right positives of opening up the roster that much from the start for whatever Sakurai's said reasons are. Yet my fancy is not tickled for Sm4sh. Hopefully 5mash will be better for me in the unlocking category.

 

[Deleted member]

I have a question for you. Did you enjoy Star Fox Adventures? Do you think that game is a good game in the series?

I thought it was pretty cool (So it takes note from Zelda, big deal)! Then again, I thought the later games after 64 weren't so bad (Until Command arrived but I don't talk about that).

On the plus side, its quite convenient that I don't have to pause the game every time I want to switch items!

 

[pupNapoleon]

Because harassing an individual for their poor word choice and personal connection to a specific aspect of the game isn't an ad-hom attack.

Please.

Kriven, I'm not at all in agreement with pizza often, but he is certainly not the one doing harassing here.
Reread your flaming posts and try to declare they are anything other than a blunt attack of character, an completely uncalled for.

If you have a dispute, a public forum is not the place to get into such a vulgar and directly irrelevant way.

 

[Kriven]

I certainly agree with this sentiment; however, the notion is subjective. Some delusional nut-case somewhere believes that Wolf AND Falco (and Fox) should be cut because Star Fox was dormant.

I'll be the opposite delusional nut-case and say that I want the whole of Team Star Fox, plus Wolf, plus General Scales, plus Bill.

 

[Niala]

Honestly I think that starfox sells enough and is popular enough to have 4 reps (but no more).


Do you like star fox adventures?

I do. I think the game refreshed the series with some new aspects and characters. There were certainly aspects of the game that I strictly did not like, but I enjoyed playing through it as a whole.

 

[Kriven]

Kriven, I'm not at all in agreement with pizza often, but he is certainly not the one doing harassing here.
Reread your flaming posts and try to declare they are anything other than a blunt attack of character, an completely uncalled for.

If you have a dispute, a public forum is not the place to get into such a vulgar and directly irrelevant way.

No, you're right. I am definitely attacking his character.

That doesn't mean he is innocent of doing the exact same thing just two pages back.

 

[MagnesD3]

I certainly agree with this sentiment; however, the notion is subjective. Some delusional nut-case somewhere believes that Wolf AND Falco (and Fox) should be cut because Star Fox was dormant.

Yeah its stupid (as popular as they are for as long as the games are apart should say something for how awesome the series can be), I cant help that nintendo keeps fubleing the ball/throwing it out of bounds... It still confuses the hell out of me that nintendo doesnt know how to approach star fox as a series...

 

[pupNapoleon]

Honestly I think that starfox sells enough and is popular enough to have 4 reps (but no more).


Do you like star fox adventures?

I understand you do, but MANY an active fan do not feel this way.

You also mentioned that Wolf is a necessary all star.

To this I will just assert how disrespected Pokemon Trainer is, and the fact that he is without a doubt one of Nintendo's biggest All Stars, yet he is considered such an obvious cut that people don't even list him on their cut list.

I will still be buying the game.

I'll be the opposite delusional nut-case and say that I want the whole of Team Star Fox, plus Wolf, plus General Scales, plus Bill.

I really wanted Andross to be playable

 

[?????????????]

Back on topic, I would like to say that I enjoyed Star Fox Adventures.

Also, on Wolf; I believe that Wolf is a Nintendo All-Star, that he is deserving to be in SSB, and that it'd be a shame for him to go. But I wouldn't call him a necessity as far as Nintendo All-Stars go. I would say the same about Toon Link, Ice Climbers, ROB, Olimar, Falco, Jigglypuff, Ike, Lucas, any 3rd Party character, and any of the newcomers of this game.

 

[Deleted member]

I do think theres a conspiracy going on with Smash 4...Sakurai's been teasing us all this time! How could you not see this?!

This is what Luigi looks like

Now what if I changed it a bit...

Micheal Jackson outfit confirmed!

 

[Morbi]

I'll be the opposite delusional nut-case and say that I want the whole of Team Star Fox, plus Wolf, plus General Scales, plus Bill.

No General Pepper? But he is one of the most prominent characters to ever grace the series!

 

[FalKoopa]

Drop this flaming before it spirals out of control.

 

[ActionHankBeard]

Kriven, I'm not at all in agreement with pizza often, but he is certainly not the one doing harassing here.
Reread your flaming posts and try to declare they are anything other than a blunt attack of character, an completely uncalled for.

If you have a dispute, a public forum is not the place to get into such a vulgar and directly irrelevant way.

I agree. Please drop it.

 

[MagnesD3]

I understand you do, but MANY an active fan do not feel this way.

You also mentioned that Wolf is a necessary all star.

To this I will just assert how disrespected Pokemon Trainer is, and the fact that he is without a doubt one of Nintendo's biggest All Stars, yet he is considered such an obvious cut that people don't even list him on their cut list.

I will still be buying the game.


I really wanted Andross to be playable

I do consider Red an all star but I dont like how sakurai approached the pokemon trainers design. It didnt feel like a team effort, everybody just used their favorite out of the three, there needed to be alot more strategy and depth involved if he was to be properly represented (hell I wanted blue to be added to the game.) Then there is also the fact that sakurai didnt reference red by name so my attachment was also less. (They could have given red a bit more character as well)


Also on Andross, its possible but IMO its even harder to represent him as a character than ridley. (like andross would be a thousand times harder to make work than ridley).

 

[Niala]

Back on topic, I would like to say that I enjoyed Star Fox Adventures.

Also, on Wolf; I believe that Wolf is a Nintendo All-Star, that he is deserving to be in SSB, and that it'd be a shame for him to go. But I wouldn't call him a necessity as far as Nintendo All-Stars go. I would say the same about Toon Link, Ice Climbers, ROB, Olimar, Falco, Jigglypuff, Ike, Lucas, any 3rd Party character, and any of the newcomers of this game.

Really? All of them? That's quite a statement. I'm curious to hear why Little Mac and Villager, for example, don't meet your credentials. Those two in particular struck me as very appropriate, nearly irrefutable additions.

 

[pupNapoleon]

How perfect would it be if Sakurai DID in fact spread the leak?

It would be ridiculous to assume Sakurai did not know the likelihood of a leak, given many factors, but predominantly the huge fandom of the game and the fact that there was a precedent for it in the last game.

What if he in fact leaked this roster, and Dark Pit and Dr Mario are actually Paper Mario and Medusa?

 

[Morbi]

Drop this flaming before it spirals out of control.

Do you mean... barrel rolls out of control?!

I accept my infraction.

Back on topic, I would like to say that I enjoyed Star Fox Adventures.

Also, on Wolf; I believe that Wolf is a Nintendo All-Star, that he is deserving to be in SSB, and that it'd be a shame for him to go. But I wouldn't call him a necessity as far as Nintendo All-Stars go. I would say the same about Toon Link, Ice Climbers, ROB, Olimar, Falco, Jigglypuff, Ike, Lucas, any 3rd Party character, and any of the newcomers of this game.

I feel the same exact way, minus the part about Wolf not be a necessity.

 

[Kriven]

My intention was not to harass; all I ever did was respond to posts made on here. I have not continued to "harass" this individual as they have not responded to my last post directed towards them. It's back-and-forth: discussion.

My entire point is that I believe it's ridiculous to discredit the entire game because one character is missing. That's an opposing opinion related to the topic of the thread.

Well, a fine job of gentlemanly discourse you did.

Devastated? Don't joke about the word. Devastated is losing someone important in your life. Devastated is losing everything you hold dear. Devastation is war and death and starvation.

This is a ****ing video game.

Super. Then I think of you as a whiny kid.

but it seems to me that you are young.

On what planet does:

A: Ridiculing a person's honest reaction
B: Acting dismissively of a person's emotions and beliefs
C: Bringing up a person's age when it is not at all pertinent to discussion

Accurately, factually dismiss the opposition's arguments in ways which are not character defamation? How do those comments relate to the topic of the thread?

How does removing those comments from your posts detract from your position?

 

[?????????????]

Really? All of them? That's quite a statement. I'm curious to hear why Little Mac and Villager, for example, don't meet your credentials. Those two in particular struck me as very appropriate, nearly irrefutable additions.

I love them both, and their series (obviously), but I don't think they're absolute necessities.

Villager makes an awful lot of sense for how big Animal Crossing has become, but to me, it's still comparatively new and smaller than Mario, Zelda, DK, Kirby, Pokemon, Star Fox, blah blah blah... Hence why I feel similarly about Olimar and Shulk. Perhaps, however, Animal Crossing IS that big, but perhaps I still have a stigma about customizable-appearing avatars as Nintendo All-Stars. I was more of a Tom Nook fan, so there may definitely be personal bias there. Even so, I don't think an Animal Crossing character in SSB is an absolute necessity.

Punch-Out is a small series that isn't overly popular internationally (specifically in Japan, where SSB is made). Although it is one of my favorite, if not my absolute favorite Nintendo series, I don't think any series of it's size and lack of exposure is an absolute necessity.

 

[Kalimdori]

Back on topic, I would like to say that I enjoyed Star Fox Adventures.

Also, on Wolf; I believe that Wolf is a Nintendo All-Star, that he is deserving to be in SSB, and that it'd be a shame for him to go. But I wouldn't call him a necessity as far as Nintendo All-Stars go. I would say the same about Toon Link, Ice Climbers, ROB, Olimar, Falco, Jigglypuff, Ike, Lucas, any 3rd Party character, and any of the newcomers of this game.

I agree with with the exception of Little Mac and ROB. Little Mac has been around more then long enough to be considered an All Star in my eyes, and ROB's a big part of the reason the gaming industry was able to get back on it's feet.

 

[Headcrab Jackalope]

But I wouldn't call him a necessity as far as Nintendo All-Stars go. I would say the same about Olimar

HNNNNNNNNNG *twitch*

Okay, can I have some reasoning so I can debate this in a respectable and calm manner?

EDIT: Nevermind, you answered in a post above this one. Disregard this please. Fair enough I suppose, but I'll just have to disagree on it.

 

[pupNapoleon]

Well, a fine job of gentlemanly discourse you did.







On what planet does:

A: Ridiculing a person's honest reaction
B: Acting dismissively of a person's emotions and beliefs
C: Bringing up a person's age when it is not at all pertinent to discussion

Accurately, factually dismiss the opposition's arguments in ways which are not character defamation? How do those comments relate to the topic of the thread?

How does removing those comments from your posts detract from your position?

Dude, the conversation is over, all parties involved can let it go. Or keep it frozen. Does not matter, but this main board is not the place.

 

[?????????????]

It's not that I'm saying they're insignificant characters, or that they aren't Nintendo All-Stars, but I don't believe they are "necessities" when it comes to creating a crossover game. Of course, I'm glad there's the time, room, fan support, and developer interest to have them!

I also forgot Lucario on my list.

 

[Deleted member]

How perfect would it be if Sakurai DID in fact spread the leak?

It would be ridiculous to assume Sakurai did not know the likelihood of a leak, given many factors, but predominantly the huge fandom of the game and the fact that there was a precedent for it in the last game.

What if he in fact leaked this roster, and Dark Pit and Dr Mario are actually Paper Mario and Medusa?

So he was basically pulling our strings as if he was a Batman villain? I shudder to think that thought...

Then again, Sakurai is quite a evil genius!

 

[Niala]

I love them both, and their series (obviously), but I don't think they're absolute necessities.

Villager makes an awful lot of sense for how big Animal Crossing has become, but to me, it's still comparatively new and smaller than Mario, Zelda, DK, Kirby, Pokemon, Star Fox, blah blah blah... Hence why I feel similarly about Olimar and Shulk. Perhaps, however, Animal Crossing IS that big, but perhaps I still have a stigma about customizable-appearing avatars as Nintendo All-Stars. I was more of a Tom Nook fan, so there may definitely be personal bias there. Even so, I don't think an Animal Crossing character in SSB is an absolute necessity.

Punch-Out is a small series that isn't overly popular internationally (specifically in Japan, where SSB is made). Although it is one of my favorite, if not my absolute favorite Nintendo series, I don't think any series of it's size and lack of exposure is an absolute necessity.

Interesting. While I may not agree with the limitations you place on the credentials to be considered an all-stat, your assessments are logical enough. Thanks for answering.

 

[Gre ninja'd]

Drop this flaming before it spirals out of control.

That's why sakurai dropped wolf

 

[Masonomace]

@ M MagnesD3 I was not quoted to give you a reply, but as a spectator of watching the game my best friend played, it looked quite fun & the action / fighting / scenes were fairly decent. I liked Star Fox Adventures, even though it wasn't supposed to be a Star Fox game.

Also the term "Nintendo All-Stars" is baffling me, I may need explaining about the term so I don't use it incorrectly. I thought all of these characters were Super Smash Brothers / Sisters that are all proud Nintendo All-Stars?

If Nintendo All-Stars is a term used for the history & merit Nintendo characters have earned, then all of these characters are worth having as All-Stars including more.

I also forgot Lucario on my list.

I was okay with your logic & posts until now. Your opinion is decent, but that last forgotten addition pains me pizzadude. Lets add codes on 5mash & I'll 1-1 you? I'll start with a 70% handicap for the fun of it too.

 

[?????????????]

I was okay with your logic & posts until now. Your opinion is decent, but that last forgotten addition pains me pizzadude. Lets add codes on 5mash & I'll 1-1 you? I'll start with a 70% handicap for the fun of it too.

Sure, sounds good! Lucario is my best friend's main, so I'm pretty used to fighting him.

Of course Lucario is a deserving Pokemon, but I don't think he's on the same level as Pikachu or Charizard.

 

[Gre ninja'd]

@ M MagnesD3 I was not quoted to give you a reply, but as a spectator of watching the game my best friend played, it looked quite fun & the action / fighting / scenes were fairly decent. I liked Star Fox Adventures, even though it wasn't supposed to be a Star Fox game.

Also the term "Nintendo All-Stars" is baffling me, I may need explaining about the term so I don't use it incorrectly. I thought all of these characters were Super Smash Brothers / Sisters that are all proud Nintendo All-Stars?

If Nintendo All-Stars is a term used for the history & merit Nintendo characters have earned, then all of these characters are worth having as All-Stars including more.

I was okay with your logic & posts until now. Your opinion is decent, but that last forgotten addition pains me pizzadude. Lets add codes on 5mash & I'll 1-1 you? I'll start with a 70% handicap for the fun of it too.

If all nintendo all stars made it, we would have captain n