Batma(n)fia 2 | Ever had your *** kicked by Batman?

[#HBC | Mac]

cool story. good stuff.

but there's no conflict between me and gheb. everyone understands gheb is just being gheb and that im town

lol I understand this

still funny how noone agreed with gheb about omni


and steel pretty good post. Def made me think more about JF. Really weird that he has yet to mention KevinM much today. It was also odd when he like attacked me when I was lightweight defending him and shedding suspicion on KevinM. Which didn't realy make any sense for him to do.

Considering the KevinM bussing. Similar to what was done in Monster Mafia. Ever since then, whenever kevinM pushes a case on someone with little to no reasoning. And starts early and keeps with it, I will always consider bussing to be a strong possibility.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

also Kevin is still scum and needs to die.

vote not leaving him today. You guys should follow me. Gheb/Omni/Steel/anyone else. trust.

and BF, if yur not scum, yu shud vote Kevin. I find your whole he was scum in BWM so i'm wary thing to be pretty dumb. Especially coming from you. Not sure why I think this though. Maybe cuz I figured that since you played scum with me in that game, you'd know when I was being un genuine.

 

[KevinM]

Cool since I guess I have to verify for Mac to stop tunneling like an idiot.

Ronike visited Macman last night.

Ronike may you verify that for me?

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Kevin, do you have a name safeclaim?

Still seems to be overpowered town with all that's been uncovered so far and tracker. In other words, the claim actually may have slightly raised Kevin on my scumdar a little.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Kirbyo, now is actually a great time to claim. Don't see why you'd say that. True, KevinM needs to die, but why the hell would his claim put him higher on your list.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

dun dun dun

i think i know how this is gonna end

*keeps watching*

also, kirbyo don't claim until ronike responds

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

dun dun dun

i think i know how this is gonna end

*keeps watching*

also, kirbyo don't claim until ronike responds

Wait, wha? Who suggested Kirbyo claim before the KevinM wagon has dissolved?

???

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

EBWOP:

**** Mac. That avatar is b****in sweet.

 

[Ronike]

Yeah, but i really don't like that you made me reveal that. Mafia tracker isnt that uncommon. I still want to lynch Kevin.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

oh **** i forgot the doc died

hrmmrmrmm

hope yu weren't dumb and wasted some sort of investigation on me.
jussayin

don't respond to that

still wanna lynch kevin

n1 Kev?

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Agreed.

@Kevin - Why the mad scramble to defend Cello on D2? What made you think he was town?

 

[#HBC | marshy]

Vote Count
KevinM (4) - Macman, §teel, Ryker, Omni
Kirbyoshi (2) - Gheb_01, Bunglefevah

Not voting (4): Nix2100, KevinM, Ronike, Kirbyoshi

Activity
3/2 - Ryker, Macman, Ronike, Kirbyoshi, KevinM, Gheb_01, Nix2100, Omni, Bunglefever
3/1 - §teel
inactive -

----------

with 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch!

deadline = 3/11 midnight

 

[Nix2100]

There does seem to be a lot of PR's coming out early, and it seems a bit odd. Kvein "soft" claimed saying he wanted to protect the other PR rules, so in order to clear yourself...you ousted a possible PR? The mafia either did a NK last night (which would be unusual) or hit a BP, and seeing as macman still wants to lynch Kevin instead of Ronike, I will assume macman isn't a BP.....and the more I think about it, the more im liking Ronike's conclusion that Kevin is indeed a mafia tracker....bah but at the same time Ronike could be another Mafia PR role....I find myself still a bit comfortable with the Kevin lynch however.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

am I a bp?
hehe

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

There does seem to be a lot of PR's coming out early, and it seems a bit odd. Kvein "soft" claimed saying he wanted to protect the other PR rules, so in order to clear yourself...you ousted a possible PR? The mafia either did a NK last night (which would be unusual) or hit a BP, and seeing as macman still wants to lynch Kevin instead of Ronike, I will assume macman isn't a BP.....and the more I think about it, the more im liking Ronike's conclusion that Kevin is indeed a mafia tracker....bah but at the same time Ronike could be another Mafia PR role....I find myself still a bit comfortable with the Kevin lynch however.

So in other words what did your big circle there accomplish.

I think this, but then there's this, which leads to that, but this might be true. Aw screw it, I'm going with what I thought originally.

What do you want to know right now? I want to see what's going on in your head, because, atm, you can go after Kevin and Kirbyo as far as I'm concerned.

 

[Nix2100]

So in other words what did your big circle there accomplish.

I think this, but then there's this, which leads to that, but this might be true. Aw screw it, I'm going with what I thought originally.

What do you want to know right now? I want to see what's going on in your head, because, atm, you can go after Kevin and Kirbyo as far as I'm concerned.

It means im a bit split at the moment, logic tells me that its possible Ronike is scum but at the same time I get the gut feeling that Kevin is indeed mafia. Was hoping for some more posts from them both before throwing a vote on Kevin which would put him at -1.

Kirby lost some of the suspicion...my main problem was he seemed to have known that Tom was mason and I didn't notice that even being mentioned before, but Ronike pointed out the neighbor in Tom's role so it kind of fixed that issue for me. Although i still dont like the fact that he put Cello at -1.

@macman - if you are a bp then you better be claiming so we don't lynch the wrong person -_-

 

[Ronike]

Nix's circle logic + keeping all options open + going with the popular opinion = bad scum player, or WORST scum player?

 

[Ronike]

Oh and now role fishing, awesome. Nix has gotta go too.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

@Nix - Your suspicious of Ronike putting the scum at L-1 after a BS claim? Or Kirbyo? I couldn't decipher it.

 

[Nix2100]

Now im confused o_O when did Ronike put who at -1? There was Cello that was put at -1 by Kirby, and then there is Kevin who is sitting at -2. And how in the world could you not decipher what i wrote? Are you purposely trying to make it look like what i write is complicated?

@Ronike - How am I role fishing? Kevin who claimed tracker says he saw you visiting macman. There was no Kill last night, so either a NK or a hit BP. If macman was a BP and got HIT, it would only be logical to assume that you are indeed scum and Kevin is the real town tracker.

And like i said Ronike, my logic tells me both options are plausible which is why I wanted to see some more info.

 

[Ronike]

And it would out a BP. Convenient for scum, no?

 

[Nix2100]

If it was a BP that got HIT, how would it matter? Mafia would already know it.

 

[Ronike]

seriously, Kevin and Nix are our scum. If Im wrong, kirbyoshi's scum.

 

[Nix2100]

Your not answering my question, if macman is a hit bp, then Scum already know it. All I am asking is whether or not Mac got hit last night, Im not saying to tell his role just whether or not he was hit. How is that a problem?!

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Don't get Nix as scum at all.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

What do you get from him then? o_O

To me, the question isn't scum, it's freaking lynch order. >.>

 

[Ronike]

Then you aren't lookin man.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I'm not getting Nix as scum either, just his general reliance on PRs.

 

[Ronike]

Nix, lets say Macman was the hit order last night. At this point, him not dying could mean just about anything: mac being a BP, someone bussing mac and a bp, a roleblocker, or any other number of roles. It doesn't really tell us anything, even if he would know he was the hit target last night.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Okay Nix, if Kevin is lynched, who should we lynch tomorrow assuming no further information from Night Phase? Your pick on both possible flips.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Nix, lets say Macman was the hit order last night. At this point, him not dying could mean just about anything: mac being a BP, someone bussing mac and a bp, a roleblocker, or any other number of roles. It doesn't really tell us anything, even if he would know he was the hit target last night.

I don't understand this. Elaborate plz.
Is already dead.
Like?

If Mac is truly BP then Mafia has this info as well. The doctor is dead and yet the kill still failed. Unless you can tell me other possibilities it's safe to assume that Macman is BP. I don't want to go into more detail about my thoughts here because it would reveal too much for now.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Also, I still think Kirbyo is a much better lynch toDay than KevMo

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

I don't understand this. Elaborate plz.
Is already dead.
Like?

If Mac is truly BP then Mafia has this info as well. The doctor is dead and yet the kill still failed. Unless you can tell me other possibilities it's safe to assume that Macman is BP. I don't want to go into more detail about my thoughts here because it would reveal too much for now.

1.) Bus Driver role
2.) Wasn't dead last night
3.) Ronike has pro-town role?

Seems pretty obvious to me.

 

[Steel]

uh kevin claiming tracker is not soft claiming. you could easily be a mafia tracker. There was already a cop, and this is a 13 player game. you need to name claim and I find it suspicious that you avoided name claiming. wouldn't you have name claimed first, and then role claimed?

 

[Ronike]

Busser role (there are other names too): Selects two targets and switches any actions used on one with the other and vice verca

Im talking about a town Roleblocker, sometimes they stop kills, like if mafia has to choose someone to do the kill. Its all up to the mod.

As for other roles, you can use your brain, you've been in enough mafia games to A) Know there are other ways kills get stopped and B) Know of the existence of Mafia Scum wiki. My point is, if mac was the target, theres no way to know if he is BP since so many other things could have happened.

 

[Nix2100]

I think Ronike was saying that its possible the mafia killer got roleblocked not the other way around.

@Ronike - Point taken....I suppose i tunneled into the idea of having a BP, I didn't consider the other roles, thats my mistake.

@Ryker - If Kevin flipped town, I would suspect Ronike no doubt about it...actually now that I think about it. Ronike if you wanted to lynch Kevin and are town, why did you say that you did indeed visit someone last night? We have no doc so that leaves you wide open to being attacked by mafia unless you already KNOW you won't be attacked by them.

 

[Steel]

also i have no idea why this macman bp talk is going and i think it needs to stop because it isnt healthy discussion.

also kevin you NEED to post your night 1 results. there is no doctor and if you really are town you would fear dying tonight and should reveal the results

 

[Ronike]

Because I did visit him. Lynch all liars. Better to be targeted by the mafia than to lynch Kevin, have him really be a town tracker, and be caught in a pointless lie.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

uh kevin claiming tracker is not soft claiming. you could easily be a mafia tracker. There was already a cop, and this is a 13 player game. you need to name claim and I find it suspicious that you avoided name claiming. wouldn't you have name claimed first, and then role claimed?

Missed that. Now I feel dumb.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

bump btw real men use 40 ppp