What would SSB be like if Ugrab and Dgrab were in it?

[Blue Yoshi]

too complicated and pointless. Grabbing upwards would make grabs even more broken than they are (imagine if DK had an upwards grab hitbox the size of his up-tilt or up-smash).

 

[kit]

but still wouldn't that be cool?

of course it would be broken and stupid but wouldn't you laugh if you mindgamed your opponent into rolling through you so you could grab them it'd be a nice slap in the face haha and i don't know what you're talking about dk SHOULD be allowed to grab up ITS **** DK king of the ****ed jungle yo


edit: removed a stray "if" haha

 

[Daedatheus]

of course it would be broken and stupid but wouldn't you laugh if you mindgamed your opponent into rolling through you so you could grab them

But... you can do that anyway...

Grabbing up/down would break the game. Makes techchasing obsolete and the whole "shielding on platform" dynamic would just get ***** by grabs. LESS MINDGAMES = WORSE GAME for me.