TheRealPika
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2019
- Messages
- 1
What is your favourite smash game? I'd like to know. Mine is Brawl.
-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
What is your favourite smash game?
- Thread starter TheRealPika
- Start date
MG_3989
Smash Lord
Ultimate by far. I was too young for Melee and it’s not for me competitively while I love Ultimate at a competitive level. It’s just such an amazing game and I haven’t felt that “magic” feeling in a game for a long time but Ultimate makes me feel that at 26 years old
Brawl is a close second but for different reasons. It’s the nostalgia, the time of my life, the friends I played it with, being a senior in high school and not having a care in the world but going home, maybe doing a questionable activity, and then just playing Brawl for hours with my friends. Nothing can compare to that those were some of the best times of my life. Ultimate is a better game though
I’d rank them
1.Ultimate
2. Brawl
3. Melee
4. 64 (I was thinking of ranking this higher because it was my first smash and one of my favorite N64 games as a kid but I didn’t quite understand it as an 8 year old)
5. Smash 4 (didn’t even play. Found it very boring)
Brawl is a close second but for different reasons. It’s the nostalgia, the time of my life, the friends I played it with, being a senior in high school and not having a care in the world but going home, maybe doing a questionable activity, and then just playing Brawl for hours with my friends. Nothing can compare to that those were some of the best times of my life. Ultimate is a better game though
I’d rank them
1.Ultimate
2. Brawl
3. Melee
4. 64 (I was thinking of ranking this higher because it was my first smash and one of my favorite N64 games as a kid but I didn’t quite understand it as an 8 year old)
5. Smash 4 (didn’t even play. Found it very boring)
Last edited:
MattySlice
Smash Rookie
1) Ultimate
2) Melee
3) Wii U
4) Original 64
5) Brawl
I know many people like it, but for some reason brawl just doesn't do it for me gameplay wise. I believe it opened up a whole new world for smash to grow and flourish into what it is today though.
(never played Project M or 3DS one much)
2) Melee
3) Wii U
4) Original 64
5) Brawl
I know many people like it, but for some reason brawl just doesn't do it for me gameplay wise. I believe it opened up a whole new world for smash to grow and flourish into what it is today though.
(never played Project M or 3DS one much)
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2008
- Messages
- 11,489
- Location
- The 90's
- NNID
- staindgrey
- 3DS FC
- 0130-1865-3216
- Switch FC
- SW 1248 1677 4696
Ultimate. Not really a question anymore.
Orlando BCN
Smash Ace
Ultimate, and I don’t even own the game yet. That’s how good it is.
Melee was previously my favorite.
Melee was previously my favorite.
MG_3989
Smash Lord
It’s just so good. I understand why certain people like Melee better (the competive scene is really awesome in Melee and the things you can do are insane) but I don’t think anyone can say it’s objectively the better game. Obviously it’s between those two and I think Ultimate is clearly better. Anyone other than competitive Melee players who disagrees is probably disagreeing off nostalgia or a character they liked in a certain game but as an overall game it’s not close
Last edited:
Michael the Spikester
Smash Obsessed
Ultimate because of 
D
Deleted member
Guest
I do not want to pick favorites when it comes to Smash since they are all fun to play, but Smash 4 receives most of my attention as of late with Ultimate soon to follow.
Sayonara
It makes me feel better that I am not the only one missing out.
Sayonara
Mogisthelioma
Smash Master
Go down the list.
1. Ultimate
2. Smash 4
3. Brawl
4. Melee
5. 64.
I placed Melee as 2nd worst. Fite me.
1. Ultimate
2. Smash 4
3. Brawl
4. Melee
5. 64.
I placed Melee as 2nd worst. Fite me.
The Animator
Smash Journeyman
This, but before that it was 64 because the sound effects had the most punch and it was cool to hear the audience scream as someone makes it back on stage.Ultimate because of
ultimate of course I mean it's the ultimate game 
1.)PM
2.)Ultimate
3.)Melee
4.)smash4
I love pm because the mechanics aren't too hard to pick up and the kills/combos are really fun. Also the fact that you can mod it into the ground with whatever you want. Ultimate is fun for me but combos are limited with swordsman and kill confirms can be pretty tough at times.
2.)Ultimate
3.)Melee
4.)smash4
I love pm because the mechanics aren't too hard to pick up and the kills/combos are really fun. Also the fact that you can mod it into the ground with whatever you want. Ultimate is fun for me but combos are limited with swordsman and kill confirms can be pretty tough at times.
Gryphon827
Smash Apprentice
For my top 5, I'd say
1: Melee
2: 64
3: 4
4: Brawl
5: Ultimate
1: Melee
2: 64
3: 4
4: Brawl
5: Ultimate
UltimateXsniper
Smash Ace
Melee is sick
But seriously I play both Melee and Ultimate regularly and while I'll say that I have been playing Ultimate more and it's amazing, Melee always have me coming back. I don't say that for other smash games like Brawl and I haven't even touched 4 since Ultimate came out. In all honesty I currently feel that Ultimate is better but I've said the exact same thing to Smash 4 when it came out and that opinion went from being better, to about even, and finally eh Brawl still has something for me to come back to. I don't think I'll feel the exact same way later with Ultimate but I do think my hype of it will die down which is why I'll say Melee is my favorite as I haven't stopped playing it since I was a little child.
But seriously I play both Melee and Ultimate regularly and while I'll say that I have been playing Ultimate more and it's amazing, Melee always have me coming back. I don't say that for other smash games like Brawl and I haven't even touched 4 since Ultimate came out. In all honesty I currently feel that Ultimate is better but I've said the exact same thing to Smash 4 when it came out and that opinion went from being better, to about even, and finally eh Brawl still has something for me to come back to. I don't think I'll feel the exact same way later with Ultimate but I do think my hype of it will die down which is why I'll say Melee is my favorite as I haven't stopped playing it since I was a little child.
MarioMeteor
Smash Hero
Brawl is my favorite but I acknowledge that Ultimate is the better game.