What if Smash stayed 100% canon to the source material?

[MidwesternHawk]

Would barely be able to harm any of the human characters (maybe Link/Zelda as well since they are elves which are similar to humans, maybe including Pit and Pittoo since angels could be considered similar to high entia) but Mega Man and ROB wouldnt stand a chance

He wouldn't be able to kill any characters that are LIVING BEINGS, but I think that he is in more of a Monado II state in this game so throw that out of the question, but Buster would be an actual attack in any case

would actually use his gun
When knocked down, punching would recover health
/Would be able to heal themselves, PK Flash for both, which can be a OHKO, create shields at will that take three hits to break and deflect damage at the opponent, and each would have PK Rockin/Love respectively. Also they are / worst nightmare, and it doesn't help / with Franklin Badges

 

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

All I can say is that Rosalina would be ridiculously powerful as a whole. Her forcefield pretty much repels any kind of physical attack, and even Bowser had to find an indirect approach to stealing her home's Power Stars; if Bowser had to resort to indirect tactics, that could strongly imply that Rosalina is too powerful for Bowser to handle.

 

[Khao]

He wouldn't be able to kill any characters that are LIVING BEINGS, but I think that he is in more of a Monado II state in this game so throw that out of the question, but Buster would be an actual attack in any case

In early Xenoblade, characters always spoke of the Monado being unable to hurt homs, not living beings in general. A huge majority of enemies in the first half of the game (Colony 9 and Tephra Cave have absolutely no mechanical enemies for one) are living beings and you have no problems hurting them with the Monado.

 

[MidwesternHawk]

In early Xenoblade, characters always spoke of the Monado being unable to hurt homs, not living beings in general. A huge majority of enemies in the first half of the game (Colony 9 and Tephra Cave have absolutely no mechanical enemies for one) are living beings and you have no problems hurting them with the Monado.

Still, he should be in the second half of the game, with the Monado II

 

[Deleted member]

Can this be a modded game called "Lame Smash" or something?? These ideas stay so true to their characters or series, it hurts.

I'm planning on starting a project for just that. Well, not 100 percent like the way things are described in this thread though.

Here you can find info about it:
http://forums.kc-mm.com/index.php?topic=75968.msg1353525#msg1353525

 

[MidwesternHawk]

I'm planning on starting a project for just that. Well, not 100 percent like the way things are described in this thread though.

I can't wait for the uber-broken characters

 

[Deleted member]

I can't wait for the uber-broken characters

Don't worry, it'll be balanced haha. I still need to find some people who are interested in helping out though.

 

[MarioMeteor]

Ryu'd be busted as hell cause he could cancel his special moves with Focus Attack.

 

[Deleted member]

Not related to Smash 4 only, but Falco would be taller than Wolf. Falco would also be faster than Fox, but slower than Wolf.

Good point about Falcon. Is it just me or is he really cocky and stuck-up in Smash Bros?

 

[FamilyTeam]

After playing Awakening, I can safely say this:
's Levin Sword would be able to cast electricity up to quite a surprising distance. It'd also hurt. Extremely badly. Robin would also have access to a lot of tomes, and he'd be extremely powerful considering my Robin pretty easily 2HKOs even the sturdier of bosses, and he 6HKOd the final boss.
And would be even stronger and get a crap ton of critical hits (even in the later chapters, my Lucina's chance of getting critical hits was never below 20%) and due to Aether, she'd also be able to heal constantly while dealing extremely strong blows.

I genuinely get the feeling those two would be the strongest characters in the game that aren't some sort of divine entity or monster like Bowser, Rosalina, Palutena etc.

 

[Blargg888]

For Non-Japanese audiences, Lucas and Roy would never have been in the game.

Any time that Mario, Luigi, Rosalina, or Peach jumps on a Green Shell 8 times in a row and on, they gain a stock in Stock matches, and a point in Time matches.

Whenever Bowser uses his down-b he'd break through the stage slightly, until he fell down into the pit and died.

More of the FE characters would have their weapons break after a certain amount of uses, and they wouldn't come back.
Ever.


ALso, this next one is just for fun, but...

Spoiler

Every single time that a character is released and added to Smash, a new Smash Bros comes out when their game is released to add that character and it is released on the system that character originated from.
The first Smash Bros would be on the Game & Watch, and only had one character: Mr. Game & Watch, and one stage: Flat Zone.
The Next 2 Smash Bros would be on arcade machines, and add PAC-MAN, and Mario/DK.

 

[Bayonettaismynewmain]

Bayonetta's boobs would be bigger.

 

[Kenith]

Bayonetta's boobs would be bigger.

Eh...not by much.
She would be even more broken than Brawl Meta Knight though.

 

[itsmeMOB]

Bayonetta's boobs would be bigger.

Long legs and the booty would be too real. Also, everyone would probably be dead. Pit especially.

 

[Putuk]

would have a cool moveset that isn't just a fart joke.

 

[MidwesternHawk]

would be confident, but not cocky
would take more than one move for copying, and if he eats, he can give some health to a teammate
would be too worried about everyone's well being, and would have more than just the Akanian Falchion (Levin Sword, Silver Sword, Stat-boosting Fire Emblem, elixir, etc.)
would be constantly worried about the fate of the world, and would have more than the Yllisian/Parallel Falchion (Levin Sword, various lances, Silver Sword, Elixir)
would have a 24/7 connection to the gods in his ear, and would have only one weapon at a time

 

[MioTinto]

//:

• Would take more damage from a Super-effective move and less damage from a Resistant-move

(ex. Water/Thunder attacks would deal more damage/knockback to Charizard but Fire ones would deal less)​

This was a thing with in Brawl, and it sucked.
Anyway

, , , , , /, , , , and would all have final smashes actally based on something from their home series
Dark Matter would invetiably hijack the match and possess sooner or later. (Now this is a headcanon, but I believe Dark Matter instinctively attacks royalty, and given how many royal characters smash has, that would probably increase the likelyhood of DM appearing)
would vocalise during his bthrow, namely by "so long, gay !"
and would be around 0.75 inches tall, and would be 8 inches tall, and would be 1'3" tall. would constantly change in size, due how inconsistent his size is in Mario canon.

 

[TheDarkKnightNoivern]

, , , , , /, , , , and would all have final smashes actally based on something from their home series

What would any of them have though? also I think Mario and to a lesser extent Peach, are based on mario rpg

 

[Putuk]

What would any of them have though? also I think Mario and to a lesser extent Peach, are based on mario rpg

could just be Masked Dedede, although I'd prefer that as an alt costume to be honest.
could summon to fire at enemies, except it's already a stage.
could do something involving the viruses.

 

[MioTinto]

What would any of them have though? also I think Mario and to a lesser extent Peach, are based on mario rpg

would have Masked Dedede. Since is based on his Twilight Princess incarnation, he'd have a transformation final smash involving Wolf Link. I'm not too sure about the others, I'm mosty just upset that Masked Dedede isn't in the game. None of 's final smashes have had any basis in canon, so I see no reason not to put Masked Dedede in the game as a final smash or at least as an alt

 

[FamilyTeam]

In the actual game, Jigglypuff does bugger all exceptional. She's not supposed to, she's just another second evolutionary stage Pokemon. Hell, Jigglypuff's most well known move, Sing, is far from exclusive to her. Pikachu is in the same boat, actually. Thunderbolt is anything but Pikachu's signature move, and Volt Tackle is the last thing your Pikachu needs. Oh, goodie, it's a physical Electric move with 120 base power and perfect accuracy, and it has a chance to paralyze! Too bad you also take 1/3 of the damage you just dealt and with Pikachu's less than optimal HP stat and wet paperbag-like defences, you will always set yourself up to death or even just outright kill yourself using it. Pikachu's bad Attack stat also ensures this isn't even gonna deal that much damage, but even then, if you use this move against a Lapras at full health, for example, you'll likely not kill it, and then lose 3/4 of your HP in the process.
Why am I even saying this? If you use Pikachu, you obviously don't care about competitive Pokemon battling.

...Well, if Smash stayed true to canon, Pikachu and Jigglypuff probably would be one of the worst characters in the game, and Pikachu would take ridiculous amounts of damage if he used Volt Tackle, specially if he got plenty of KOs with it.

 

[allison]

could summon to fire at enemies, except it's already a stage.

When playing on Halberd, Meta Knight summons a SECOND Halberd. Surprise!

 

[Geese]

Ganon would never die, just have to wait a while before he got back up, Bayonetta would stop time for everyone super often, Villager would just be there, any character could kill Olimar by stepping on him, Megaman would have the most moves out of any character ever, Sheik would have a bunch of song based moves, Fox would always have a final smash

 

[Shiida]

- more than 3 thorons, more than 8 levin swords, etc.
- actual real flutter jump, be able to hold onto people more with neutral b
- could only be hurt by the master sword and light arrows
- ability to pocket more than 1 thing, would have to wait 3 days for trees to grow
- an ike clone, would destroy ridley on that one stage
- would be able to use his fairy taunt to heal

...Well, if Smash stayed true to canon, Pikachu and Jigglypuff probably would be one of the worst characters in the game, and Pikachu would take ridiculous amounts of damage if he used Volt Tackle, specially if he got plenty of KOs with it.

jigglypuff is the worst character in the game

 

[Zethoro]

would have a 100-0 MU against every character in the game except for maybe and because Grima.

 

[Furret24]

Smash would be a horribly unbalanced mess of a game.

In other words, Smash would suck.

 

[Deleted member]

Smash would be a horribly unbalanced mess of a game.

In other words, Smash would suck.

So...

You called?

 

[Furret24]

So...

You called?

Atleast he doesn't win all but two matchups 100-0 in his favor, unlike canon Ganon.

 

[MidwesternHawk]

- an ike clone, would destroy ridley on that one stage

A sword/axe user is not the same as a sword/lance user,she would be fast as usual(Ike would be faster still) and Aether would be a Down B(ZSS/Sheik), and watch out for that javelin projectile, but I understand the Ike clone point, she would be more of a Marth clone anyways