Vote: X or Y to jump

[Vash619]

Both. I jump with X, personally, but I know people who jump with Y. It's a comfort thing and the more options given for something as important as jumping the better.

Agreed, but i think button configurations would fastly help the gameplay and harm it maybe to set up easy button combos for "said move".

 

[Keta]

X, what I started out using, I tried Y a few months ago, it's just way too different.

 

[Armygeddon Bomb]

I vote for x jump. What more is there to say.

 

[Wolfblade]

Yeah X is what I grew up on... I think, I should really pay attention.

 

[Daisuke no Kage]

I use Y for jumping, mostly because it's closer to A and B, so I can rest my thumb on A while having the tip on Y. I might start using X for short hopping though, I've tried it and it seems easier. I can't use X for wavedashing though. XD

 

[Supreme Pie Ninja]

X.

This is most definitely more than 10 characters.

 

[FlipTroopa]

Y, all the way. It's just what I happened to use at first, and it stuck. X is apparently better for short hopping and stuff, so I might try that out... someday.

 

[S P I K E]

Gotta' be Y. Y allows you quicker access to both A and jump at the same time seeing as your thumb is constantly on them. =P Up should certainly be kept as jump to still separate those who can execute the moves from those who can't. If you are complaining that you can't do up tilt... PRACTICE!!! You don't smash up... you tilt... Thats the effing point... That would just allow idiot newbs to close in on the pros through being lazy...

 

[Link226]

Y.....its closer 2 A and i dont have 2 really move it......X is just stupid and wierd

 

[SuPeRCuSsIoN]

can we vote for both? i use every button on the controller for different purposes.

 

[Ricky_kun]

I hardly use X and I don't use up. So I use Y, lol.

 

[ecstatic]

I think Y should be full jump and X short hop. (I don't think up should jump.)

 

[S P I K E]

Why shouldn't up be jump though? Can someone explain that to me? What would up be if it wasn't jump?

 

[Falco&Victory]

X all the way,easier for all jumping occasions.

 

[Armygeddon Bomb]

There is a good use for the up jump. The A button melee that disabled the B, X, Y, Z, L, and R buttons for beginers.

 

[S P I K E]

Well, that too... I was looking more along the lines of shortening fox's and falco's shines... Helping out with stuff like that. Not many people factor this in, but flicking the joystick up also helps with SH.

 

[BlueImpulse]

It's all about ... well actually... I use different buttons for different things... I use Y to short-hop... and X for regular jumpin...

 

[Kabyk-Greenmyst]

Wow, I can't even remember the buttons. I use the one on top of the A button and not to the side of it. This is ireally awkward, i believe it is X.

 

[Rock Lobsta]

I use up to regular jump into aerial moves when the oponnent is hit into the air, but when I want to sh, its Y. never ues X ever. I guess if anyone plays mario kart DD, they would use Y also, because you need to press a and y at the same time to go and throw stuff..with the same thumb.

 

[ChaosCore]

Well, I have no problem using Both, However I do generally use X more than Y. You can put your thumb on both X and A, just like you can put your thumb on both Y and A. I don't think Y's placement is an advantage over X's placement.

Customizing controls would be cool and and make many people happy. However this would mean that every time you go to your friend's house, a tourney or change controller ports, you would have to check and make sure your controls are set the way you want them. This could be annoying and time-consuming.

 

[Coo_Too_Tim]

It doesn't matter to me. Tho, I mostly use the x button to jump. The only character I use the control stick with is Fox so I can SHDL with him.

 

[Kevvviiinnn]

x for sh, up for full jumps.

 

[Slugma128]

I think I've never used Y for jumping. X seems more natural for me.

 

[Armygeddon Bomb]

Y is good for short hops, up can be used for pros, and x makes it good for most smashers.

 

[Hope]

the right 1 i dont know what 1 it is! :D

 

[Mubariz]

Put a god**** button mapping option in.

Seriously.

 

[Verde Coeden Scalesworth]

X or Y, doesn't matter. Just not Up. Mapping controls is the winner.(of course, it wouldn't be needed in Single Button...)

 

[REØ]

I'm placing my vote on X, and definitely not Up.

 

[Meleeruler]

I want X, Y, and Up.

 

[Chi's Finest]

Y. It's so comforatable and X just feels really weird.

 

[S P I K E]

After my recent tourney, I seemed to have changed my style a bit, I use Y for WD'ing and SH'ing, and about 40% of normal jumps, otherwise X. I use up to juggle and such. Up is also necessary for pro fox and falco users... helps anyways.

 

[FoxxMCcloud]

the x button the y button should be used for something else

 

[SuperSmashMistress]

I vote for X. I have small hands and my thumb doesn't reach the Y comfortably enough for me to use it to jump with commonly. Because of this I tend to hit A and Y at the same time.

 

[fluffy]

But Y is the choice of professionals.

psst (theyre making u believe that so we cant be professionals like them)

 

[Omega_Star]

I like using X, Y, and up to jump. Each has its diferent uses for different times for me.

 

[magar]

^ Up, PWnz All

 

[buddy9246]

i choose for both x and y

 

[Venom_7]

x please. y is too out of it

 

[keroku_the_thunderwolf]

i think X, Y, and up on the analog are all essential since they give you more of a choice of a jump command to go along with your style of play. they all focus on the total smash community, not just one area or person. none of these are useless....some people like using all the button and other prefer one. i use X primarily myself and never use Y because my style of play is speedy fingers, and what better way to make my fingers (more of thumbs) faster than to choose X since i move my thumbs more than would Y.

 

[Shaolin-Ninja]

That'd suck, No good fighting game lets you do that

Umm... Why not? Well I wouldn't like it, but... I vote for all three buttons as jumps!

I use Y, but when I JC Fox's shine, I use up on the controllstick.