Villains Mafia - Bad enough dudes! - ENDGAME - HERO + RAM VICTORY!

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

But honestly, Juri has a hider/linker made no sense.

She'd fit more as a vig or arguably a bodyguard with one-shot bulletproof (latter makes sense if you saw the Juri OVA)

 

[Ura]

Who would have ever thought it would be Veggietales that screws with everyone's head in the game and lead to Mafia's victory?

 

[Swamp Sensei]

After all these comments, I'm starting to wonder if I did anything right.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

After all these comments, I'm starting to wonder if I did anything right.

I mean, in all fairness, a lot of what's wrong came from some spur of the moment decisions where you had to come up with some roles quickly.

And the game ended up bigger than planned too.

So really, just take it as a lesson about planning ahead next time you host.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

I mean, in all fairness, a lot of what's wrong came from some spur of the moment decisions where you had to come up with some roles quickly.

And the game ended up bigger than planned too.

So really, just take it as a lesson about planning ahead next time you host.

Yeah that... just kind of confirms it was kinda crap.

Which I was worried about.

Sorry we went out with a stinker everyone.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Yeah that... just kind of confirms it was kinda crap.

Which I was worried about.

Sorry we went out with a stinker everyone.

I mean, that's not entirely your fault.

Town really didn't play well in this game either.

And mafia was mostly just tripping itself and somehow managing to make things work.

A lot of players need to share the blame with you on this one.

Myself included for essentially putting a target on my head before the game even began, then making my case even worse as the game actually went on.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

I mean, that's not entirely your fault.

Town really didn't play well in this game either.

And mafia was mostly just tripping itself and somehow managing to make things work.

A lot of players need to share the blame with you on this one.

Myself included for essentially putting a target on my head before the game even began, then making my case even worse as the game actually went on.

Not helping.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Not helping.

Well, helping's never been a big strength of mine.

But either way, don't worry too much about it. You did what you could with the cards you were dealt with.

No matter the result, that's worth some respect.

 

[Natz~]

I mean, that's not entirely your fault.

Town really didn't play well in this game either.

And mafia was mostly just tripping itself and somehow managing to make things work.

A lot of players need to share the blame with you on this one.

Myself included for essentially putting a target on my head before the game even began, then making my case even worse as the game actually went on.

pretty much lol, we all kinda screwed things up here

 

[Natz~]

Well, helping's never been a big strength of mine.

But either way, don't worry too much about it. You did what you could with the cards you were dealt with.

No matter the result, that's worth some respect.

that too

ya made a god damn 23 mafia game

and made it work, a lotta things got crumbled but it still damn worked

 

[Deleted member]

There were issues with the balancing, yes, but I don't think this was a broken mess. It was still fun, even if it ended rather anticlimatic(well, that's on us, actually).

 

[vaanrose]

After all these comments, I'm starting to wonder if I did anything right.

Is this a pattern? Every time the game ends the person who made it has to apologize about it being broken?

Like, I said it last time I'll say it this time, too. So much of this game is up to the players that a broken ability can go completely unused and a seemingly useless ability can suddenly turn the whole game on its head.

It was fun, that's all that matters.




I still say I should have gotten both Shish and Praline's abilities, tho.

 

[Natz~]

Is this a pattern? Every time the game ends the person who made it has to apologize about it being broken?

self deprecation can be a ***** :V

butt ya just how people are, when ya create something ya want it to run the way ya imagine, and when it doesn't peeps first thoguths are "i made it so i didn't make it right" just how people thoughts tend to go towards, something ya realize when ya play tabletops, ya just also need to realize ya playing something with many other people and its not your full responsiblity, everyone has their own actions in it and so its responsible to everyone not just one person, don't take it all against yourself, espeically when peeps still had fun~

 

[Deleted member]

self deprecation can be a ***** :V

butt ya just how people are, when ya create something ya want it to run the way ya imagine, and when it doesn't peeps first thoguths are "i made it so i didn't make it right" just how people thoughts tend to go towards, something ya realize when ya play tabletops, ya just also need to realize ya playing something with many other people and its not your full responsiblity, everyone has their own actions in it and so its responsible to everyone not just one person, don't take it all against yourself, espeically when peeps still had fun~

Your tabletop comparison made me think of a role idea lol
Hmmm........

 

[Holder of the Heel]

There were issues with the balancing, yes, but I don't think this was a broken mess. It was still fun, even if it ended rather anticlimatic(well, that's on us, actually).

If we're given the option to get rid of suspects in bulk it's hard for a lot of people to resist doing so. Better for the option to not exist. When the idea first came up, the door opened for us to try and game the system and that is a door nearly impossible to close.

 

[Natz~]

Your tabletop comparison made me think of a role idea lol
Hmmm........

glad to assist lol, i'll send my other idea in time, katts kinda tired after getting off work so will take nap first

 

[vaanrose]

Your tabletop comparison made me think of a role idea lol
Hmmm........

You are "The Rules Lawyer", third party.

Your win condition is to successfully convince the GM that they're misinterpreting a rule.

 

[Deleted member]

If we're given the option to get rid of suspects in bulk it's hard for a lot of people to resist doing so. Better for the option to not exist. When the idea first came up, the door opened for us to try and game the system and that is a door nearly impossible to close.

Honestly, on Day 2, we should have just tied in the vote between everyone but the ones from Red's riddles and Red himself. Of course, while having some people on lookout for last minute voting shenanigans. This would have ended with Opossum, Coricus, you, Red, RamOne, Yellow and Zeb living and it would be incredibly easy for you guys to just repeat the process with those three the next Day.
See? I broke the game!

 

[Swamp Sensei]

If we're given the option to get rid of suspects in bulk it's hard for a lot of people to resist doing so. Better for the option to not exist. When the idea first came up, the door opened for us to try and game the system and that is a door nearly impossible to close.

Killing everyone in the tie was meant to make people NOT want to vote for ties.

You didn't get rid of suspects in bulk. Only days that applied were the lynchproof test and the final derp.

You folks were just too confident that you'd have one mafia dead, let's be honest.

 

[Deleted member]

You are "The Rules Lawyer", third party.

Your win condition is to successfully convince the GM that they're misinterpreting a rule.

GM: "A large boulder is blocking the entrance to the cave."
Guess who: "I flirt with it."

 

[Holder of the Heel]

Killing everyone in the tie was meant to make people NOT want to vote for ties.

You didn't get rid of suspects in bulk. Only days that applied were the lynchproof test and the final derp.

You folks were just too confident that you'd have one mafia dead, let's be honest.

I'm not saying we were right, it wouldn't matter whether or not the tie rule was right or nor if we weren't trying to abuse it in the first place. That's why in my game I was tight lipped about ties (and discouraging about it in the flavor) because I wanted everyone to just focus on the one decision and not be tempted by anything more.

Honestly, on Day 2, we should have just tied in the vote between everyone but the ones from Red's riddles and Red himself. Of course, while having some people on lookout for last minute voting shenanigans. This would have ended with Opossum, Coricus, you, Red, RamOne, Yellow and Zeb living and it would be incredibly easy for you guys to just repeat the process with those three the next Day.
See? I broke the game!

Dude I said that (basically). I mean, it was posed as a joke, but I mean if we were going to try and break mafia we should have tried to shatter it in pieces or stick to one a day, two at most. Though the problem is, like you bring up, the thinner we spread out the votes the easier it is for the mafia to end game things in their favor by messing with the tie at the last second. It'd have to be planned out well and the more people involved the more likely they might resist the idea (quite reasonably) and threaten the entire balance of votes.

 

[vaanrose]

Killing everyone in the tie was meant to make people NOT want to vote for ties.

You didn't get rid of suspects in bulk. Only days that applied were the lynchproof test and the final derp.

You folks were just too confident that you'd have one mafia dead, let's be honest.

I stand by my reasoning that killing King proved who the mafia were whether he was in it or not. Killing myself was just meant to prove it to everybody else.

 

[A Distant Demon]

Late but the game itself was great. There were some possible fears with the third parties but they didnt actually wind up happening lol.

Making such a great game out of 23 roles is pretty impressive.

 

[AmericanDJ]

While I didn't play at all this game, this certainly was an entertaining finale to the group. (I'll try and post more in depth thoughts in the graveyard later)

Also, since I realize I never said it once this entire game despite all of the mistakes that the town made, allow me to say it now:

This town is garbage, you factoring hectopascals!

 

[Ura]

You did a pretty good job Swamp. I had a blast playing this game.

 

[CrusherMania1592]

Worth a game playing! Sucks that the town keeps ****ing up this time around

 

[praline]

After all these comments, I'm starting to wonder if I did anything right.

I thought it was great! Even if I lost I think you did well, and you had no host errors either!

 

[God Robert's Cousin]

Life firmly grasped me the past week. Not in a bad way--just getting responsibilities done and calls to family/friends--but it was enough to keep me busy from any kind of social media browsing until today more or less.

I was a proven member of Town and had a lot of information that could have helped change the favor of the game's result, but I was too inactive to make any use of it and help those of you who reached out to me. For what it's worth, I'm sorry about that guys.

Good job Heroes! Looking forward to (actually) participating in a Mafia game in the future with you all.

 

[Ura]

Just curious...

If GRC used his primary or secondary on me would that have blown my cover? Or was I immune to that ability?

 

[praline]

Just curious...

If GRC used his primary or secondary on me would that have blown my cover? Or was I immune to that ability?

I imagine it would have blown your cover.

 

[Ura]

I imagine it would have blown your cover.

I remember my teammates telling me that I was useful is screwing with GRC's rolecop abilities which led me to believe I was immune to that.

Either way it's great he took a hiatus around the time I was "revived" lol.

 

[A Distant Demon]

if he used the "reveal entire role" I imagine you were ****ed. Fake PM only changes the flavor for you "dying"

Checking your media would not have done anything since. . .the fake claim was the same as the real one.

 

[Ura]

Damn GRC could have pinned me down and screwed our chances at victory lol.

For what it's worth he was the townie who was most suspicious of me whereas everyone else was focused on other things.

 

[A Distant Demon]

Damn GRC could have pinned me down and screwed our chances at victory lol.

For what it's worth he was the townie who was most suspicious of me whereas everyone else was focused on other things.

?

GRC was a confirmed townie. He was one of the least suspicious. Only person even with him was Holder of the surviving players because he was confirmed by the riddler.

 

[praline]

?

GRC was a confirmed townie. He was one of the least suspicious. Only person even with him was Holder of the surviving players because he was confirmed by the riddler.

He said that GRC was the only townie suspicious of him.

 

[A Distant Demon]

oh derp. This is why I shouldnt be up at midnight

 

[Ura]

Happens to the best of us. I misread things a lot myself.

 

[ranmaru]

meta dive is a go

 

[Swamp Sensei]

meta dive is a go

And your results?

 

[ranmaru]

And your results?

I have yet to get to the game start page.