I suppose that's true.
I don't think I'm the best one to make a call on Dark Souls avatars. I feel biased against the art style, it just seems bland to me. It's like all the subtle lighting and shading effects actually make the armor
more near-total monochrome, fuses everything
more together; it's just such a pain to see where things really stop and start. I see all the nifty little details in the armor. I see a lot of intricacies. I really want to like it. But some part of me is fighting it.
Agh. Drifloons.
I don't wanna hate on Dark Souls. I know the game's good and it don't deserve grief from a monochrome rat. I stand by my thoughts, but take my stance on 'em with one or two grains of salt. End of the day, your opinion matters most. Maybe if I actually played it some I'd understand it better.
I will say if you're going for an iconic knight look you picked the right one in the first lineup.
Lemme gab about the others and I'll leave it at that.
The contrast on Kireek makes him stand out very well - notice that light-on-dark-on-light-again going on, really gives everything some nice definition - and makes him fairly easy to identify at a glance. Ellie is similar but subtler. Midna and Lucina have the same advantage in contrast, but in a darker overall palette. And the Shulk has a pretty identifiable look overall as well, since Girahim!Shulk is a rarity.
It's also worth noting that brighter characters stand out better in Smashboards Dark, which as the default is most likely to be what you want to stand out against.
Phew.
I hope I could be of any help. Imma get some toast now.
[EDIT]: I'm ********. It's not the monochrome, it's that it's all desaturated and washed out.
I fiddled around in GIMP with a few of the knights and technically I can come up with something more vibrant - vibrant stands out better, of course - but besides the fact that you lose some fine detail, that's part of Dark Souls' look, on purpose, and I don't know your opinion on deviating from that.
That said I've prepared a demonstration. Look what happens when we teach a man to polish:
View attachment 49799