ok, so, yesterday, I got that....he might have more chance than I think he has.
But let me do replies
Paper Mario for life, my frontrunner
Hey! welcome to the boards
You know, if you ever want to talk about his awesomeness here, feel free to (also on the group which I invinted you already).
Thanks for support
Haha, I'm pretty sure already on the supporter list, I made some posts a couple months back. But yeah, I have no problem with you using that part of the sig! TTYD is my favorite game of all time, so it'd be a dream come true to see him in the game, and people seem to be voting for him a lot.
i completely forgot so your name was duplicated for some days, but it`s fixed since yesterday. Also, thanks, I`ll be sure to have the icon in the OP
But now on he gets lots of votes.....this is my main point: he does.
and I mean I looked at the polls and generally, it was decent, but not the best.
However, relatively....it`s insanely good for him.
I've always said that he was mostly top 10, not top 5. I never saw him top 5, didn`t expected it and I don`t even think it would happem.
The problem is that it's actually false, he was top 5 all this time.
Yesterday, the poll on reddit that we know got boated got the results released.....and they were unboated:
http://nm.reddit.com/r/smashbros/comments/32mcez/final_results_the_smash_bros_dlc_reddit_survey_is/
13k people on reddit.
Now, I know you will look at this and say that it doesn`t make any sense....but it actually does. If BK is that high, that`s because of uneccessary hype that happened lately. Same for shovel knight, we know it has been uneccessarily hyped about. Wolf being that low is just because everyone expects him which kinda make sense, but is ironic.
Overall these results are just accurate, but there's something weird about them....
Paper Mario is 7th which is the first time I saw this.
Now, according to some people in the character thread, if you checked the votes, they made sense except for the boat waves. What this means is that we shouldn`t say it's untrusted, but it still has stuff that is weird which is when I'm coming to.
We can clearly see there's useless data. BK, we know is just not going to happen because even if Sakurai would want to, you first has to deal with MS which is already seemingly impossible for me, but remember guys, rare is pretty much dead. It's really a totally different problem because he's third party. I know it's sad, but I think it make sense to say that he shouldn't be considered in this position in the poll. The poll only tells popularity ONLY.
You have to merge these reaults with stuff like chances and the character itself in smash.
But then, you would come to somethinglike eliminating these:
banjo kazooie
shovel knight
bayonetta
and maybe snake, but imo, he`s so unlikely.
What this means is that if you remove these, Paper Mario is 4th or 3th, but what's more impressive is KKR and isaac are the only one that tops him and they ARE considered popular already.
So, that sounds awesome right?
it's even more.
In the OP, I linked the @
PushDustIn
polls (btw, push, there's a reason I tag you, I would need your take further in this post). These were made before the direct, but here they are:
JP:
https://sourcegaming.wordpress.com/2015/02/19/perception-of-smash-dlc-in-japan/
rest of the world (but mostly America):
https://sourcegaming.wordpress.com/2015/04/01/smash-poll-smash-dlc-results/
So, top 10....yeah, but that's because the polls are again ONLY showing popularity.
Take the JP polls, there's a lot of these that we can safely remove:
of course lucas for vey obvious reasons.
maybe snake (I would imo)
ice climbers because it's just implied to not happen and the fact it was explicitly said why, I would be ready to cut them out of the poll.
I would keep roy because it just might happen.
pichu is obviously not going to happen like seriosuly.
remove ridley because it's even worse than ice clinbers here.
dixie is interesting. I don't think most would see both kkr and dixie....but because kkr is over, I would be ready to say to keep kkr of course, but that would imply to cut dixe. The opposite being true, it wouldn`t change, but for the sake of the poll, I would cut dixie here.
Paper Mario is now 5th.....and that's assuming you consider crystal as a chance, but I kept her just in case.
again, the poll makes sense with 2 vets and 2 newcomer one being known to be popular, kkr. It's known that isaac situation is different in JP.
So, what can we conclude out of this?
He's still not top 5 in PURE popularity, but he is relatively to those who would be there. What I mean is that I onyl left characters that logically has a reasonable chance (and I again consider crystal is minimal, it`s still present). I do this because it's like a poll with goku winning.....it's just not to be taken as is because it just doesn't change the invalidity of him. Even though, all these are technically valid, some has chances too low.
Now, if we check the other poll, we could remove:
ice climber
lucas of course
snake
rayman is just no, you really have to be worth it to be in third party and the problem is that if it took pac man, mega man or sonic, it's just not the same standard. imo, if there was one I could think of, it would be BK, but the problem is what happened after MS boguht rare....yeah I really don't think any third parties are likely now tbh (even snake chances got quite down a bit).
BK
bayonetta and bomberman for the same reasons....it's jsut nto the standard a third party would be worth the effort to have it.
midna is AT, we can be sure it's very unlikely (even if you add the wolf, it's just not likely).
ridley for already told reasons.
Paper Mario is now 5th....again, below kkr, isaac and vets.
I think you see where I'm going, the polls all had biased in it because it was pure want. The pure want is just not telling the full story because if a character very unlikely for logical reaosons is very popular, it's just not going to change. Shovel knight got hyped but it doesn't change how unlikely he is.
Now, this is were @
PushDustIn
I would need your takes.
You said yesterday this on the character thread:
@
SmashChu wrote a great piece on why unknown characters in a particular reason
would economically be a bad choice for Smash DLC. Please read it, he makes a lot of great points.
Essentially, I don't think a character unknown in Japan (Like Shovel Knight is) nor a character that doesn't have actually popularity outside of Smash forums can make it as DLC. I almost think Paper Mario may have a higher chance than King K. Rool just because of his general popularity (Though I think it's highly likely that King K. Rool will Rule the Battle). For 3rd party characters, I think they have to be really important. Indie games marketplace is not as big as a thing as it is in the West. Japanese Wii U eShop got games from 2012 in the latest direct.
Ignore the first part, that was answering to someone, unrelated to my point.
Now, when I read this I was like thinking "wait, are you crazy?" because I just got for very good reasons that Paper Mario doesn't come even close to kkr. If most people would have the choice between the 2, I would expect most to pick kkr and it's just obvious for me. But as a standalone withotu even considering the other?
I would still think his chances aren`t THAT good.
But now that I checked the poll and tried to clean them....I see the opposite. he's actually closer than expected to kkr and I knew for isaac being about the same, but kkr is another story. There's far more going for him, it just makes sense kkr is always top 3.
So, @
PushDustIn
, my big question is:
What EXACTLY did you meant by "I almost think Paper Mario may have a higher chance than King K. Rool just because of his general popularity (Though I think it's highly likely that King K. Rool will Rule the Battle)."?
I'm serious, I'm the most biased person on Paper Mario on the whole site and I was thinking it was just a miracle if this was the truth.
Because the implication of him being realively top 5 is huge. it means that he could EVEN be considered "likely" which is something that feels extremely weird to admit.....
As for other things, the blog is still going well, I made a post with the TTYD pretty words images....it has like 160 notes, it's crazy