I disagree with your argument. I think Scarlett would be more willing to have a conversation because she seems more down-to-earth.
I guess you could think this Olivia person would be more willing to have a conversation with you if you like girls saying "Oh you play Smash Brothers? I LOVE THAT GAME!"
Personally, that's a turn-off ^ Girls shouldn't have to try to keep your attention by pretending they like what you do
Also, girls making out with girls is hardly "hot" to me, others might disagree, though. Is that appropriate or not?
What makes you think Olivia is that kind of girl? From my understanding, shes the kind of girl who seriously enjoys what she enjoys and does not pretend to be into things to appeal to guys(ex: the girls who say "Yea I love video games!" but don't play anything besides WoW. Rough example, but you get the point).
Olivia is pretty down to earth as well. Shes pretty natural and can have honest conversations with you.
I'd take Scarlet as a trophy wife though.
Anyways. Lets quit arguing about apples and oranges and show appreciation to the appropiate girl in the appropiate thread. If you like scarlet, post in the scarlet thread(same with Olivia). If you like both, post in both. But lets quit silly apples and oranges comparisons and talk about one or the other.