N
Narkelva
Hey dude, SFIII:3S fan here! So to give you a straight answer, mindless aggressive play would best suit
(though I don't really recommend playing without thinking LOL). But about
, yeah, it's true he's actually very difficult competitively, but think about it this way: By holding yourself back from the delicate details of this character, you could essentially be robbing yourself of the character who'd bring you the most enjoyment out of matches, and learning his ins and outs could end up improving your overall gameplay. The first thing I'd suggest is fully acquainting yourself with his recovery options; yeah, they're limited maybe, but the better you understand them, the more likely you are to succeed (wall jump can often be a life-saver). Little Mac has a similar footsie game to Dudley, except you have to create that footsie stuff more manually rather than inputting a command that makes Dudley basically do the work for you movement-wise. You can apply pressure, sure, but you want to try and command the center of the stage as much as possible while mixing up your footsie game (pivot tilts are very important for Mac). It sounds as though you could possibly be using his specials too freely rather than his plethora of useful normal attacks (some of which are armored, meaning even if you get hit, you won't suffer any interruptions to your own attack). Not sure if you know, but you can shorten the length of his side special by pressing the special button again (and you definitely want to limit yourself to using this facing the inside of the stage rather than the other way around LOL). Don't forget you have a great counter if things start getting scary. I'd recommend checking out the Little Mac board before giving up on him completely.
As far as some other characters I'd suggest looking into, while
isn't really the best for constant aggressive play (he's an odd combination of bait & punish and aggressive), he does make good use of his fists, and if you can (or can learn to) read your opponent well, I think you'll find him enjoyable.
is considered mindless by some, but I disagree... However, Yoshi can be played aggressively; definitely figure out his recovery options before getting serious (I'd suggest turning tap jump off to prevent accidental second jumps), and you'd have to force yourself to avoid side special (except perhaps on rare occasions when you want to catch your opponent off-guard with something absolutely ridiculous). I think Yoshi's at least somewhat easy to pick up at a low level similar to Mac, so you could ease yourself into his quirks with time.
s are rare since most tourneys don't currently allow them (or if they do it's only with the default 1111 moveset), and they're heavier on kicks, but you should at least give them a shot, I think. They're pretty dang fun to play, honestly, and the style is fairly aggressive.
I can definitely relate to being big on Street Fighter, but not so much
(in SFIII:3S, I gravitate toward Q and Yun, whereas Chun-Li's been a favourite/main across the series, so Ryu just doesn't fit me at all). Hope some of this helps you on your quest to find the perfect main!