Super Smash Bros. 4's Top Roster Candidates v2 ~ Begins!

[Zap tackle]

Toad, Roy, Pichu, Tails, Slime

 

[Holder of the Heel]

He can replace Young Link Plus it's technically Deku/Zora/Goron Link. Then there's room for Ghirahim as a 5th Zelda Rep.

Isaac, Geno, Victini, Majora's Mask Link, and Little Mac

You mean Toon Link would be gone?! D: Sad times man, sad times!

 

[SmashKing201]

Oh No! Duck Hunt Dog is falling off the charts.

Needs more Dog

 

[SwordmasterR]

Vote for today: Isaac, Geno, Saki, Majora's Mask Link, Victini

 

[toadfan64]

Toad
King K Rool
Waluigi
Shy Guy
Mona

 

[KittyCat13]

You mean Toon Link would be gone?! D: Sad times man, sad times!

I'd like all three Links in the next one! Majora's Mask Link would be different from the other two Links because he can change into deku/goron/zora so it wouldn't really be like having 3 of the same character. If only they would make the next game have so many characters that we could have more than 4 or 5 from Zelda.

 

[Holder of the Heel]

I'd like all three Links in the next one! Majora's Mask Link would be different from the other two Links because he can change into deku/goron/zora so it wouldn't really be like having 3 of the same character. If only they would make the next game have so many characters that we could have more than 4 or 5 from Zelda.

Yeah, it WOULD be like having three Links. Link, Toon, and Young. That is three. And Majora's is one that isn't long running. Toon and Normal Link are the only ones that have there own reoccurring appearances. Young Link was in two, and Majora's Mask is just one game. Zelda has too many characters to choose another Link for the roster. Not to mention the other franchises that could use that slot to bring in an original and complete character.

 

[Shorts]

Krystal
Mona
Ashley
Captain Syrup
Genesect

 

[kikaru]

Yeah, it WOULD be like having three Links. Link, Toon, and Young. That is three. And Majora's is one that isn't long running. Toon and Normal Link are the only ones that have there own reoccurring appearances. Young Link was in two, and Majora's Mask is just one game. Zelda has too many characters to choose another Link for the roster. Not to mention the other franchises that could use that slot to bring in an original and complete character.

It's simple.
Skyward Sword Link (Obvious)
Ghriahim
Majora's Mask Link (Replaces Young/Toon Link)

Ghirahim has also only appeared in one game as well. There have also been talks about remaking Majora's Mask for the 3DS so Mask Link might make a return but on the 3DS.

And no it would not be like having three links even if all three were in. At least Mask Link will have a COMPLETELY different moveset than Link/Toon Link/ Young Link because he will assume the forms of Deku/Goron/Zora who have appeared in many Zelda games.

 

[Tacket]

Slippy
Joshua
Bandanna Dee
KK Slider
Duck Hunt Dog

 

[Ussi]

Waluigi
Starfy
Lip
Isaac
Phoenix Wright

 

[Deleted member]

Just remember that the main point here is to vote. That isn't to say you can't discuss, but the main point should be about voting.

Anyway, vote count will come tomorrow afternoon.

 

[Holder of the Heel]

It's simple.
Skyward Sword Link (Obvious)
Ghriahim
Majora's Mask Link (Replaces Young/Toon Link)

Ghirahim has also only appeared in one game as well. There have also been talks about remaking Majora's Mask for the 3DS so Mask Link might make a return but on the 3DS.

And no it would not be like having three links even if all three were in. At least Mask Link will have a COMPLETELY different moveset than Link/Toon Link/ Young Link because he will assume the forms of Deku/Goron/Zora who have appeared in many Zelda games.

Ghirahim is not a Link though, and has potential references to other characters and objects seen several before, even possibly referencing the Gilded Sword in Majora's Mask with his cloak, but that is off the point.

Toon Link is too well liked, and could easily be given a new move-set since there are three Toon Link games, and a fourth one coming out next on the 3DS, with the Majora's Remake being a maybe, and a remake at that. Hardly warrants a character in a franchise of Nintendo representatives if you ask me.

Also, it IS three Links. It doesn't matter if she has a huge move-set involving many move-sets of transformations, it is still a third Link character, that is who it is, the rests are masks. It is simple. I'm not referencing moves. I'm talking about the person. Three of the same dude is not okay to me, and probably many others. Might as well throw in Wolf Link with Midna on his back, he is well-liked, and so is she. TP is more recent as well.

Just remember that the main point here is to vote. That isn't to say you can't discuss, but the main point should be about voting.

Anyway, vote count will come tomorrow afternoon.

No worries, I shall be voting still, just discussing the results.

 

[codebracker]

I volte for Tails, Waluigi, Knuckle joe, celebi
Especially for tails

PS:what is the score on tails?

 

[smash puffle]

Hmm...
-All the 5 melee chars (except for dr.mario)
-Geno
-Waluigi
-Ridley
-Megaman
-Shadow
-Deku Link
-Snivy
-Baby Bowser
-Scott Pilgrim
And more.

 

[DiamondFox]

K. Rool
Bowser Jr.
Tom Nook
Ridley
Mewtwo

 

[Xhampi]

-Duck hunt Dog
-Starfy
-Bandana Dee
-Paper Mario
-Sandbag

 

[Deleted member]

Hmm...
-All the 5 melee chars (except for dr.mario)
-Geno
-Waluigi
-Ridley
-Megaman
-Shadow
-Deku Link
-Snivy
-Baby Bowser
-Scott Pilgrim
And more.

You can only select five characters a day. So this post will be disregarded unless you limit your choices to five.

 

[Aurane]

-Victini
-Young Link
-Ridley
-PKMN Trainer 2nd Gen (That's part of the selection, right?)
-Lucario

I chose Ridley this time. Why? *shrugs* Go with the flow XD

 

[Deleted member]

@asage94: First off, veteran votes cannot be counted aside from the Fallen Five. Also, this is a poll to vote for who you want, not what other people support. If you don't want Ridley, don't waste your time voting him.

 

[Aurane]

@asage94: First off, veteran votes cannot be counted aside from the Fallen Five. Also, this is a poll to vote for who you want, not what other people support. If you don't want Ridley, don't waste your time voting him.

Oh, ok, vets on the side, gotcha. And I'm inching to Ridley because of the flow. People always want him. THe reason why I want him is so that I can beat his @$$ all the time *True Story*

But, yeah, here's a better list:

1. Victini
2. PKMN Trainer 2nd Gen
3. Zoroark
4. PKMN Trainer 3rd Gen
5. Deoxys

As for vets, Young Link only.

That better?

 

[Deleted member]

@asage94: Better, but you cannot vote cut vets separately. When I say you cannot vote for more than five characters, you cannot vote vote for more than five characters, period.

 

[KittyCat13]

Also, it IS three Links. It doesn't matter if she has a huge move-set involving many move-sets of transformations, it is still a third Link character, that is who it is, the rests are masks. It is simple. I'm not referencing moves. I'm talking about the person. Three of the same dude is not okay to me, and probably many others. Might as well throw in Wolf Link with Midna on his back, he is well-liked, and so is she. TP is more recent as well.

Well, if you say so. I think that a same character with a very different moveset is enough of a different playing experience that it's worthy of being considered. But if there can be only two Links, I'd rather have Majora's Mask Young Link replace Toon Link or even adult Link, that way there wouldn't be two Link characters with matching moves, and that is why he gets my vote. As for Ghirahim, he is only in one game, less games than Young Link is in, so if there's a second villain to be added Vaati really makes the most sense since he's the only other recurring villain besides Ganondorf. But this about who we want, not who makes the most sense, so if you want Ghirahim then vote for him, and I will vote for Majora's Mask Young Link!

And sorry, I will stop discussing this and wait for my turn to vote again =3

 

[Aurane]

@asage94: Better, but you cannot vote cut vets separately. When I say you cannot vote for more than five characters, you cannot vote vote for more than five characters, period.

I know

Spoiler

Actualy, I didn't. I was haf asleep typing, my bad.

 

[Dr. Hengelhoffer]

Sooo! Letse go!!

Captain Syrup, Banjo Kazooie, Porky, Whispy Woods and Simon Belmont.

 

[Deleted member]

@asage94: I think that means pick five you want and stick to it for today.

 

[Deleted member]

[COLLAPSE=Character pool to pick from]
Super Mario Bros.
Bowser Jr. - 54
Toad - 143
Paper Mario - 77
Waluigi - 81
Rosalina - 24
Daisy - 11
Dr. Mario - 12
Fawful - 5
Birdo - 5
King Boo - 2
Dimentio - 11
Rawk Hawk
Pauline - 43
Ludwig Von Koopa - 1
Prince Peasely - 1
Professor E. Gadd - 1
Cackletta - 1
Foreman Spike - 5
Boo - 1

Donkey Kong:
King K. Rool - 144
Dixie Kong - 31
Funky Kong
Cranky Kong
Diddy and Dixie Kong - 2
Lanky Kong - 1
Tiny Kong - 5
Chunky Kong
Stanley - 2
Penny- 1
Wanda- 1

Yoshi:
Kamek - 23
Baby Mario & Baby Luigi - 1
Shy Guy - 7
Baby Bowser - 1

Wario:
Captain Syrup - 73
Ashley - 11
Mona - 25
Jimmy T - 3
9-Volt - 1
Kat & Ana
Shake King - 6
Merelda - 4

The Legend of Zelda:
Young Link - 15
Majora's Mask Link - 67
Ghirahim - 58
Tingle - 45
Toon Zelda & Toon Sheik/Tetra - 1
Vaati - 6
Midna - 9
Zant
Skull Kid - 15
Wolf Link & Midna - 10
Ralph - 1
Impa - 5
Demise- 4
Majora's Wrath - 1

Metroid:
Ridley - 121
Dark Samus - 17
Anthony Higgs
Sylux

Kirby:
Bandana Dee/Waddle Dee - 81
Knuckle Joe - 2
Dark Matter - 7
Rick - 1
Prince Fluff
Nightmare - 3
Magolor
Galactia Knights - 1
Whispy Woods - 3

Star Fox:
Krystal - 47
Leon - 13
Slippy - 12
Peppy - 1

Pokemon:
Zoroark - 14
Victini - 99
Genesect - 7
Meloetta - 1
Keldeo
N - 1
Zorua
Mewtwo - 173
Meowth - 22
Mew - 1
Dragonite - 1
Pichu - 68
Heracross - 1
Scizor
Celebi - 1
Deoxys - 7
Plusle & Minun - 16
Gardevior - 1
Jirachi
Blaziken - 1
Darkrai
Gallade
Pokemon Ranger - 1
2nd gen Pokemon Trainer - 3
3rd gen Pokemon Trainer - 3
4th gen Pokemon Trainer
5th gen Pokemon Trainer - 1
Mixed-Up Pokemon Trainer (Three Pokemons with one per gen of your choice) - 4
Female Pokemon Trainer (Any gen) - 13
Todd Snap - 1
MissingNo - 1

F-zero:
Samurai Goroh - 21
Black Shadow - 16
Jody Summers
Deathborn
Pico - 5
Dr. Steward

Mother:
Masked Man/Claus - 14
Poo - 9
Paula - 1
Jeff - 3
Ninten - 2
Porky - 14
Flint - 1
Kumatora - 1

Fire Emblem:
Roy - 107
Krom - 4
Lyn - 35
Hector - 5
Elliwood - 1
Ephiram - 4
Micaiah - 2
Soren
Black Knight - 6
Sigurd
Celice
Caeda - 47
Leaf - 2
Liz - 1
My Unit
Elincia - 11
Eirika - 4
Joshua - 2

Kid Icarus:
Palutena - 87
Medusa - 71
Magnus - 4
Eggplant Wizard

Pikmin:
Louie - 2
The President

New Series:
Little Mac - 72
King Hippo
Isaac - 132
Matthew - 5
Saki Amamiya - 64
Isa Jo - 2
Starfy - 71
Ray - 30
Shulk - 38
KOS-MOS - 13
Kanan - 1
Elza - 2
Ende - 1
Tom Nook - 38
Animal Crosser - 8
K. K. Slider - 6
Mii - 19
Kalas - 31
Alexandra Rovias - 15
Pious Augustus - 1
Chibi-Robo - 13
Andy - 3
Sami - 12
Dillon (previously Jiro) - 1
Jill Dozer - 8
Captain Rainbow - 1
DeMille - 1
RV Cards- 2
Water - 1
Magical Starsign Hero(ine) - 1
Saki (Batien Katios) - 1
Sandbag - 1
Barbara Bat - 1

Retro:
Lip - 113
Takamaru - 35
Mach Rider - 3
Duck Hunt Dog - 53
Sheriff - 4
Diskun - 1
Balloon Fighter - 29
Alice - 3
Sukapon - 7
Muddy Mole - 11
Prince of Sable - 3
Prince Richard - 1
Bubbles - 2
Wild Gunman - 1
Mike Jones - 10
Excitebiker- 1

Third-Party:
Mega Man (Classic, X, Volnutt, EXE, Starforce) - 91
Mega Man Zero - 3
Proto Man - 3
Bass
Zero - 3
Ryu (Street Fighter) - 2
Zack & Wiki
Phoenix Wright - 28
Leon Kennedy
Chris Redfield
Jill Valentine - 1
Albert Wesker - 10
Majini - 1
Viewtiful Joe - 3
Amaterasu - 4
Neo G. Red - 1
Geno - 110
Mallow - 7
Neku Sakuraba - 1
Black Mage - 4
White Mage
Lloyd Irving - 6
Cless Alvien
Marina Liteyears
Crono - 21
Magus
Duke Nukem - 1
Slime - 22
Sora - 3
Cloud - 11
Chocobo
Moogle - 4
Hero (Dragon Quest) - 1
Lightning - 6
Professor Layton - 2
Ryu Haybausa - 2
Tails - 9
Knuckles - 11
Shadow - 9
Dr. Eggman - 3
Grey Fox
Bomberman - 7
Simon Belmont - 9
Alucard - 2
Dracula - 2
Soma Cruz - 2
Goemon - 1
Rayman - 1
Travis Touchdown - 16
Pac-Man - 3
Crash Bandicoot - 4
Spyro - 1
Earthworm Jim - 2
Brian - 2
Nightmare - 3
Ivy Valentine
Banjo-Kazooie - 18
Fulgore - 4
Sho Minamimoto - 5
Tetris Block - 2
Glover - 3
Cortez - 1[/COLLAPSE]As of 3:30 PM CST on 12/14/2011. Here is the current ranking:

1. Mewtwo (173)
2. King K. Rool (144)
3. Toad (143)
4. Isaac (132)
5. Ridley (121)
6. Lip (113)
7. Geno (110)
8. Roy (107)
9. Victini (99)
10. Mega Man (91)
11. Palutena (87)
12. Bandana/Waddle Dee (81)
13. Waluigi (81)
14. Paper Mario (77)
15. Captain Syrup (73)
16. Little Mac (72)
17. Starfy (71)
18. Medusa (71)
19. Pichu (68)
20. Majora's Mask Link (67)
--
21. Saki Amamiya (64)
22. Ghirahim (58)
23. Bowser Jr. (54)
24. Duck Hunt Dog (53)
25. Krystal (47)
26. Caeda (47)
27. Tingle (45)
28. Pauline (43)
29. Shulk (38)
30. Tom Nook (38)

Day Thirteen will end at 6:00 PM CST today with Day Fourteen starting immediately afterwards.

 

[Shorts]

Krystal
Syrup
Ashley
Mona
Kanan

 

[Jet300]

Or he/she could mean Leon from StarFox, which is just as likely.

Ohhhh, Leon the lizard guy. I forgot all about him. I would love to see him in SSB4

 

[Deleted member]

Krystal
Syrup
Ashley
Mona
Kanan

Day Fourteen does not start until 6:00 PM CST today. It is still Day Thirteen, in which today you have voted once before.

 

[~ Valkyrie ~]

- Lip

- Medusa

- Starfy

- Victini

- Toad

 

[Disfunkshunal]

Bomberman
Dillon
Krystal
lip
Paper Mario

 

[Deleted member]

GameFAQS original thread can no longer go on due to it nearly reaching the 500 post limit, so a new thread has been made to continue it. Just a heads up for those watching.

Day Fourteen has begun and will end at 6:00 PM CST tomorrow (in which Day Fifteen begins).

Anyway, my vote goes to Victini, Mewtwo, Roy, Mega Man, and Genesect (also voted on GameFAQs and YouTube, so vote only count once).

 

[Zap tackle]

I vote for Toad, Roy, Pichu, Duck Hunt Dog, and Tails.

 

[Pichu Fan]

Toad, pichu, issac, bandana dee, slime.

 

[kikaru]

Isaac, Geno, Victini, Majora's Mask Link, and Saki

 

[SmashKing201]

Today I vote

Duck Hunt Dog
Midna (by herself)
Tom Nook
Balloon Fighter
Andy (Nintendo Wars series)

 

[Deleted member]

[COLLAPSE=Character pool to pick from]
Super Mario Bros.
Bowser Jr. - 54
Toad - 147
Paper Mario - 78
Waluigi - 81
Rosalina - 24
Daisy - 11
Dr. Mario - 12
Fawful - 5
Birdo - 5
King Boo - 2
Dimentio - 11
Rawk Hawk
Pauline - 43
Ludwig Von Koopa - 1
Prince Peasely - 1
Professor E. Gadd - 1
Cackletta - 1
Foreman Spike - 5
Boo - 1
Wart
Tatanga
Boom Boom
Plum
Goomba

Donkey Kong:
King K. Rool - 145
Dixie Kong - 31
Funky Kong
Cranky Kong
Diddy and Dixie Kong - 2
Lanky Kong - 1
Tiny Kong - 5
Chunky Kong
Stanley - 2
Donkey Kong Jr.

Yoshi:
Kamek - 23
Baby Mario & Baby Luigi - 1
Shy Guy - 7
Baby Bowser - 1

Wario:
Captain Syrup - 73
Ashley - 11
Mona - 25
Jimmy T - 3
9-Volt - 1
Kat & Ana
Shake King - 6
Merelda - 4
Penny- 1
Wanda- 1

The Legend of Zelda:
Young Link - 15
Majora's Mask Link - 69
Ghirahim - 60
Tingle - 45
Toon Zelda & Toon Sheik/Tetra - 1
Vaati - 6
Midna - 10
Zant
Skull Kid - 15
Wolf Link & Midna - 10
Ralph - 1
Impa - 5
Demise- 4
Majora's Wrath - 1
Byrne

Metroid:
Ridley - 121
Dark Samus - 17
Anthony Higgs
Sylux
Adam Malkovich

Kirby:
Bandana Dee/Waddle Dee - 83
Knuckle Joe - 2
Dark Matter - 7
Rick - 1
Prince Fluff
Nightmare - 3
Magolor
Galactia Knights - 1
Whispy Woods - 3
Gooey

Star Fox:
Krystal - 48
Leon - 13
Slippy - 12
Peppy - 1
Panther
Pigma
Andross
General Scales

Pokemon:
Zoroark - 15
Victini - 104
Genesect - 8
Meloetta - 1
Keldeo
N - 1
Zorua
Mewtwo - 175
Meowth - 23
Mew - 1
Dragonite - 1
Ditto
Pichu - 70
Heracross - 1
Scizor
Celebi - 1
Deoxys - 7
Plusle & Minun - 17
Gardevior - 1
Jirachi
Blaziken - 1
Darkrai
Gallade
Pokemon Ranger - 1
2nd gen Pokemon Trainer - 3
3rd gen Pokemon Trainer - 3
4th gen Pokemon Trainer
5th gen Pokemon Trainer - 1
Mixed-Up Pokemon Trainer (Three Pokemons with one per gen of your choice) - 4
Female Pokemon Trainer (Any gen) - 13
Todd Snap - 1
MissingNo - 1

F-zero:
Samurai Goroh - 21
Black Shadow - 16
Jody Summers
Deathborn
Pico - 5
Dr. Steward

Mother:
Masked Man/Claus - 14
Poo - 9
Paula - 1
Jeff - 3
Ninten - 2
Porky - 14
Flint - 1
Kumatora - 1

Fire Emblem:
Roy - 110
Krom - 4
Lyn - 35
Hector - 5
Elliwood - 1
Ephiram - 4
Micaiah - 2
Soren
Black Knight - 6
Sigurd
Celice
Caeda - 48
Leaf - 2
Liz - 1
My Unit
Elincia - 11
Eirika - 4
Joshua - 2

Kid Icarus:
Palutena - 88
Medusa - 74
Magnus - 4
Eggplant Wizard

Pikmin:
Louie - 2
The President

New Series:
Little Mac - 72
King Hippo
Isaac - 139
Matthew - 5
Saki Amamiya - 67
Isa Jo - 2
Starfy - 72
Ray - 30
Shulk - 38
KOS-MOS - 13
Kanan - 1
Elza - 2
Ende - 1
Tom Nook - 39
Animal Crosser - 8
K. K. Slider - 6
Mii - 19
Kalas - 32
Alexandra Rovias - 15
Pious Augustus - 1
Chibi-Robo - 13
Andy - 4
Sami - 12
Dillon (previously Jiro) - 2
Jill Dozer - 8
Captain Rainbow - 1
DeMille - 1
RV Cards- 2
Water - 1
Magical Starsign Hero(ine) - 1
Saki (Batien Katios) - 1
Sandbag - 1
Barbara Bat - 1

Retro:
Lip - 117
Takamaru - 35
Mach Rider - 3
Duck Hunt Dog - 55
Sheriff - 4
Diskun - 1
Balloon Fighter - 30
Alice - 3
Sukapon - 7
Muddy Mole - 11
Prince of Sable - 3
Prince Richard - 1
Bubbles - 2
Wild Gunman - 1
Mike Jones - 10
Excitebiker- 1

Third-Party:
Mega Man (Classic, X, Volnutt, EXE, Starforce) - 92
Mega Man Zero - 3
Proto Man - 3
Bass
Zero - 3
Ryu (Street Fighter) - 2
Zack & Wiki
Phoenix Wright - 30
Leon Kennedy
Chris Redfield
Jill Valentine - 1
Albert Wesker - 10
Majini - 1
Viewtiful Joe - 3
Amaterasu - 4
Neo G. Red - 1
Geno - 115
Mallow - 7
Neku Sakuraba - 1
Black Mage - 4
White Mage
Lloyd Irving - 6
Cless Alvien
Marina Liteyears
Crono - 21
Magus
Duke Nukem - 1
Slime - 23
Sora - 3
Cloud - 11
Chocobo
Moogle - 4
Hero (Dragon Quest) - 1
Lightning - 6
Professor Layton - 2
Ryu Haybausa - 2
Tails - 10
Knuckles - 11
Shadow - 9
Dr. Eggman - 3
Grey Fox
Bomberman - 8
Simon Belmont - 9
Alucard - 2
Dracula - 2
Soma Cruz - 2
Goemon - 1
Rayman - 1
Travis Touchdown - 17
Pac-Man - 3
Crash Bandicoot - 4
Spyro - 1
Earthworm Jim - 2
Brian - 2
Nightmare - 3
Ivy Valentine
Banjo-Kazooie - 18
Fulgore - 4
Sho Minamimoto - 5
Tetris Block - 2
Glover - 3
Cortez - 1[/COLLAPSE]As of 6:50 PM CST on 12/14/2011. Here is the current ranking:

1. Mewtwo (175)
2. Toad (147)
3. King K. Rool (145)
4. Isaac (139)
5. Ridley (121)
6. Lip (117)
7. Geno (115)
8. Roy (120)
9. Victini (104)
10. Mega Man (92)
11. Palutena (88)
12. Bandana/Waddle Dee (83)
13. Waluigi (81)
14. Paper Mario (78)
15. Medusa (74)
16. Captain Syrup (73)
16. Little Mac (72)
17. Starfy (72)
19. Pichu (70)
20. Majora's Mask Link (69)
--
21. Saki Amamiya (67)
22. Ghirahim (60)
23. Duck Hunt Dog (55)
24. Bowser Jr. (54)
25. Krystal (48)
26. Caeda (48)
27. Tingle (45)
28. Pauline (43)
29. Tom Nook (39)
30. Shulk (38)

Day Fourteen will end at 6:00 PM CST today with Day Fifteen starting immediately afterwards.

 

[Zzuxon]

Would you add Goomba? i'm voting for him tomorrow.

 

[Deleted member]

Done and done.