SmashBoards Roster Evolution (11-1, break)

[Smasher 101]

Can I make a small change to my roster? I'd like to take out Ridley for Wario.

 

[SmasherMaster]

I cahnged my roster for a bit. I took out the Mii and replaced it with Diddy Kong. I figured that Diddy would be a better choice than the Mii.

I plan on adding Mii, and Luigi in the next round if they apply.

 

[SmasherMaster]

CURSE YOU DOUBLE POST!

Edit: Of course my 900th post would have to be a double post

 

[Shorts]

What, you can take away characters?

 

[LoneKonWolf]

What, you can take away characters?

I allowed that in my game, don't see why it couldn't here in axle's game

 

[Shorts]

Yoshi, Wario, Bowser, Ridley, Diddy

Slowly I am filling in all the shoe in choices. After this round is when things get more interesting

 

[YoshiandToad]

Okay, this was tight, but I just about made it:

Newcomers:

• Olimar and Pikmin are dying to battle. In the case of the Pikmin; literally.
• Ness, the Smash64 star finally debuts
• Popular Smashboards favourite Little Mac punches his way repeatedly into the roster
• As promised last time; My personal favourite Toad and ...
  
• ...everyone's favourite Kirby newcomer Bandana Dee have finally escaped the tyranny of their respective monarchs and are playable in this version.

Looks like a lot of rivalries are forming.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Okay, this was tight, but I just about made it:

Newcomers:

• Olimar and Pikmin are dying to battle. In the case of the Pikmin; literally.
• Ness, the Smash64 star finally debuts
• Popular Smashboards favourite Little Mac punches his way repeatedly into the roster
• As promised last time; My personal favourite Toad and ...
  
• ...everyone's favourite Kirby newcomer Bandana Dee have finally escaped the tyranny of their respected monarchs and are playable in this version.

Looks like a lot of rivalries are forming.

another awesome roster mate
its juat awesome and beautiful

 

[SmasherMaster]

Okay, this was tight, but I just about made it:

Newcomers:

• Olimar and Pikmin are dying to battle. In the case of the Pikmin; literally.
• Ness, the Smash64 star finally debuts
• Popular Smashboards favourite Little Mac punches his way repeatedly into the roster
• As promised last time; My personal favourite Toad and ...
  
• ...everyone's favourite Kirby newcomer Bandana Dee have finally escaped the tyranny of their respected monarchs and are playable in this version.

Looks like a lot of rivalries are forming.

Looks awesome!


Came up with an awesome idea for a challenge round. Instead of Nintendo character, the round would be a roster for another company, a company of the roster maker's choosing.

IE (Sony, Disney, Miscosoft, Square Enix, Etc)

 

[Shorts]

Girls, girls, settle down. Link is taken.

Spoiler

 

[Natz~]

new one =D

added Yoshi, ness, captain falcon, Olimar, and villager, five different series

 

[Gunla]

We still have some missing rosters. Or I missed them.
Warning to:
@ Louie G.
@ Autumn ♫
@ josh bones
@Keybladeguy
Either create a roster by 8:00 PM Central Time, or remind me that you made it by quoting this post. Failure to follow this will either result in a delay or a disqualification and automatic elimination.
Guys, if I missed any, please show them to me.

 

[Louie G.]

Here's mine.

I tried to add characters from unrepresented franchises, and a new character for Mario and Zelda just because.
So I added Rosalina for Mario, Toon Link for Zelda, Villager for Animal Crossing, Olimar for Pikmin, and Marth for Fire Emblem.
I would TOTALLY draw my roster like YoshiandToad does, but frankly I'm not good at making art on the computer, nor do I have a program for it.
Yet.
EDIT: I replaced Mac with Villager, since AC is already represented in the Smash universe.

 

[SmasherMaster]

Here's mine.
View attachment 7558
I tried to add characters from unrepresented franchises, and a new character for Mario and Zelda just because.
So I added Rosalina for Mario, Toon Link for Zelda, Little Mac for Punch Out, Olimar for Pikmin, and Marth for Fire Emblem.
I would TOTALLY draw my roster like YoshiandToad does, but frankly I'm not good at making art on the computer, nor do I have a program for it.
Yet.

I would to, except I can't because the process would take more than two days.

 

[Louie G.]

I would to, except I can't because the process would take more than two days.

Well I mean, Y&T does it just fine.

 

[YoshiandToad]

Well I mean, Y&T does it just fine.

I'm pretty speedy but it still took me a good five hours for this one, due to the amount of characters and trying to work out their interactions. Had I not ran into some sudden free time today I think I might have been in trouble of not being ready for this round...;;

 

[Autumn ♫]

Here's my roster!

I added Luigi, Ganondorf, Meowth, Ness, and Olimar.

 

[Gunla]

@ josh bones and @Keybladeguy are left. I don't want to delay, but I don't want to eliminate two.. What do you guys think?

 

[Gunla]

Both have not been on since at least Tuesday. They will be eliminated.
If either of you are reading this, I implore both of you to join next game.

Update will not be tonight, sadly. A little late for me, I'm not in great shape to make an update. I'll aim for tommorrow morning or Friday afternoon, Central Time at the latest.

 

[Starbound]

If you've eliminated both Josh Bones and Keybladeguy, will there still be an elimination?

 

[Gunla]

If you've eliminated both Josh Bones and Keybladeguy, will there still be an elimination?

There still will be an elimination. Regardless of when I start it it will end on Saturday evening.
If I went to another break, the flow would collapse. Don't want @ YoshiandToad 's works going for nothing, either...

 

[SmasherMaster]

There still will be an elimination. Regardless of when I start it it will end on Saturday evening.
If I went to another break, the flow would collapse. Don't want @ YoshiandToad 's works going for nothing, either...

Can't we have a disadvantage or penalty for the person in last place? That way we don't lost three people in one round and @ YoshiandToad 's work won't be for nothing.

Like if the next round had no special requirements, then last place needs to follow a random requirement.

 

[YoshiandToad]

Ah, no. Seriously don't worry about my workload. ;;

If you want to go to the next round I merely ask I can reuse that roster but add the newcomers for that round to it.

 

[Gunla]

Boom! Elimination IV! Err... Razor?
Yes, we auto-eliminated two already, but in vein of Mario, things must come in three.

You've got a little more than 24 Hours to Vote this time! Remember to say who you voted for and why in a post below!

CLICK ME TO VOTE!
​

@Fortanono
@ Louie G.
@ GreenReaperGod
@Angelglory
@ Tepig2000
@ Autumn ♫
@ Starbound
@ Shorts
@Kon
@ Golden Icarus
@ Jakor
@ SmasherMaster
@ YoshiandToad
@ Smasher 101
@ Natz~

New Rosters!

Spoiler

-Fortanono-

-Louie G.-

-GreenReaperGod-

-Angelglory-

-Tepig2000-

-ScatmansWorld25-

-ThatWasPeachy-

-Shortiecanbrawl-

-Kon-

-Golden Icarus-

-Jakor-

-SmasherMaster-

-YoshiandToad-

-Smasher 101-

-LumaOkami-

ELIMINATION IV BEGINS NOW
YOU HAVE UNTIL SATURDAY EVENING TO VOTE.​

 

[Tepig2000]

Voted Shortiecanbrawl because of Kalos Trainer.

 

[josh bones]

My internet was down all week, I thought I had a chance to win, YoshiandToad, I give my best regards.

 

[Gunla]

My internet was down all week, I thought I had a chance to win, YoshiandToad, I give my best regards.

You want me to add you to the queue for the next game? I can at least do that.

 

[josh bones]

Sure wynaut?

 

[Autumn ♫]

It was a hard choice this round for the first time, but I chose Shortie due to the Kalos Trainer and Krystal.

 

[Jakor]

I voted for Golden Icarus because of Duck Hunt Dog. I also believe personally that there are more interesting characters to add at this point than Little Mac.

 

[GreenReaperGod]

Voted for Shortiecanbrawl because of Krystal and Kalos Trainer. Also because Wario is present but not Luigi

 

[Shorts]

I voted for Golden because Duck Hunt Dog

RIP guys. I do hope YoshiandToad keeps his drawings up, otherwise

 

[SmasherMaster]

Alright, this is how my thoughts went this time.

Each roster would be based on if the following characters were included: Mario, Luigi, DK, Link, Samus, Kirby, Yoshi, Fox, Pikachu, Jiggylpuff, Ness, Captain Falcon, Pit, Peach, Zelda, Bowser, Olimar, Marth, Wario, and Villager. These characters were either the original twelve, two of the main nintendo females, most important character to a main series or iconic. Here is how the roster when. If a character is missing but another character from the said series is there, then I will give half points.

Smasher 101- 20/20
Louie G.- 19/20 (Missing Wario)
GreenReaperGod- 19/20 (Missing Wario)
Me- 19 (Missing Luigi)
LumaOkami- 19/20 (Missing Wario)
ScatmansWorld25- 18.5/20 (Missing Wario and Jigglypuff. Has Mewtwo and Meowth so +.5)
Shortiecanbrawl- 18.5/20 (Missing Luigi and Jigglypuff. Has Kalos Trainer so +.5)
Jakor- 18.5 (Missing Luigi and Jigglypuff. Has Pokemon Trainer and Mewtwo +.5)
Tepig2000- 18/20 (Missing Wario and Villager)
ThatWasPeachy- 18/20 (Missing Ness and Wario)
Kon- 18/20 (Missing Bowser and Wario)
Fortanono- 17.5/20 (Missing Peach, Jigglypuff and Wario. Has Pokemon Trainer and Mewtwo so +.5)
Angelglory- 17.5/20 (Missing Luigi, Jigglypuff and Wario. Has Mewtwo so +.5)
Golden Icarus- 17.5/20 (Missing Luigi, Jigglypuff and Ness. Has Mewtwo +.5)
YoshiandToad- 16.5/20 (Missing Jigglypuff, Captian Falcon, Bowser, Villager and Marth. Has Toad, Anna, Meowth and Mewtwo so +.5)

Sorry YoshiandToad. Your rosters are cool, but the long process does not lie. Second place would go to Golden Icarus at 17.5 for missing Ness.

 

[Golden Icarus]

Voted for shortie for reasons that others have already stated.

 

[Smasher 101]

Shortiecanbrawl, Kalos Trainer.

 

[YoshiandToad]

Alright, this is how my thoughts went this time.

YoshiandToad- 16.5 (Missing Jigglypuff, Captian Falcon, Bowser, Villager and Marth. Has Toad, Anna, Meowth and Mewtwo so +.5)

Sorry YoshiandToad. Your rosters are cool, but the long process does not lie. Second place would go to Golden Icarus at 17.5 for missing Ness.

I regret nothing!

Except I couldn't add Falcon or Bowser yet, that is.

I genuinely considered having Falcon and Bowser in over Toad and Bandana Dee, but I did promise I'd add them this round. Your system of voting each time is actually really interesting, and I like how much you consider each vote.

Unfortunately, and I'm going to be quite open with you all now; I'm afraid I may score lowly on this round's system for quite a few times in the future...Marth and Jigglypuff? Never happening on my roster. Sorry. Meowth replaces Jigglypuff as a more deserving anime based Pokemon rep, and Marth...

...okay, I'm not a big fan of Marth, so Anna is pretty much replacing him as a face of the series. I mean she does appear in the most Fire Emblem games technically.

Still not sure who to vote for myself yet. I know who I'm NOT voting for, and that is Shortiecanbrawl.

It may seem hypocritical for voting for Blue last time(It was Wii Fit Trainer and lack of Yoshi, sorry guy), but I prefer my rosters with variety. Therefore this time I will be excluding Kon, Scatman and also Golden for their inclusions of Dillon, Meowth/Robin(selfish I know, but c'mon; Meowth!) and Duck Hunt Dog as well as Shortie...

Picking between the rest is going to be a lot harder...

Edit: Luma also gets a free pass due to Lyn this time. No one else considered her.
Edit 2: Angelglory also safe due to Lip.

 

[Autumn ♫]

I regret nothing!

Except I couldn't add Falcon or Bowser yet, that is.

I genuinely considered having Falcon and Bowser in over Toad and Bandana Dee, but I did promise I'd add them this round. Your system of voting each time is actually really interesting, and I like how much you consider each vote.

Unfortunately, and I'm going to be quite open with you all now; I'm afraid I may score lowly on this round's system for quite a few times in the future...Marth and Jigglypuff? Never happening on my roster. Sorry. Meowth replaces Jigglypuff as a more deserving anime based Pokemon rep, and Marth...

...okay, I'm not a big fan of Marth, so Anna is pretty much replacing him as a face of the series. I mean she does appear in the most Fire Emblem games technically.

Still not sure who to vote for myself yet. I know who I'm NOT voting for, and that is Shortiecanbrawl.

It may seem hypocritical for voting for Blue last time(It was Wii Fit Trainer and lack of Yoshi, sorry guy), but I prefer my rosters with variety. Therefore this time I will be excluding Kon, Scatman and also Golden for their inclusions of Dillon, Meowth/Robin(selfish I know, but c'mon; Meowth!) and Duck Hunt Dog as well as Shortie...

Picking between the rest is going to be a lot harder...

Edit: Luma also gets a free pass due to Lyn this time. No one else considered her.

I'm surprised you didn't catch my unique addition of Robin.

 

[YoshiandToad]

I'm surprised you didn't catch my unique addition of Robin.

Just edited that in actually!

 

[LoneKonWolf]

I regret nothing!

Except I couldn't add Falcon or Bowser yet, that is.

I genuinely considered having Falcon and Bowser in over Toad and Bandana Dee, but I did promise I'd add them this round. Your system of voting each time is actually really interesting, and I like how much you consider each vote.

Unfortunately, and I'm going to be quite open with you all now; I'm afraid I may score lowly on this round's system for quite a few times in the future...Marth and Jigglypuff? Never happening on my roster. Sorry. Meowth replaces Jigglypuff as a more deserving anime based Pokemon rep, and Marth...

...okay, I'm not a big fan of Marth, so Anna is pretty much replacing him as a face of the series. I mean she does appear in the most Fire Emblem games technically.

Still not sure who to vote for myself yet. I know who I'm NOT voting for, and that is Shortiecanbrawl.

It may seem hypocritical for voting for Blue last time(It was Wii Fit Trainer and lack of Yoshi, sorry guy), but I prefer my rosters with variety. Therefore this time I will be excluding Kon, Scatman and also Golden for their inclusions of Dillon, Meowth/Robin(selfish I know, but c'mon; Meowth!) and Duck Hunt Dog as well as Shortie...

Picking between the rest is going to be a lot harder...

Edit: Luma also gets a free pass due to Lyn this time. No one else considered her.
Edit 2: Angelglory also safe due to Lip.

heck as long as you add ike, i'm not voting for you when it comes down to fire emblem,
though I might still depending for other things, but so far I agree and like them form a smash point of view for now, still love the drawing
also I've voted for shortie, sorry I didn't want to vote with the pack, but i'm a pro red(kanto) guy, I can't agree with kalos with the way these roster looks like now, sorry mate

 

[SmasherMaster]

I regret nothing!

Except I couldn't add Falcon or Bowser yet, that is.

I genuinely considered having Falcon and Bowser in over Toad and Bandana Dee, but I did promise I'd add them this round. Your system of voting each time is actually really interesting, and I like how much you consider each vote.

Unfortunately, and I'm going to be quite open with you all now; I'm afraid I may score lowly on this round's system for quite a few times in the future...Marth and Jigglypuff? Never happening on my roster. Sorry. Meowth replaces Jigglypuff as a more deserving anime based Pokemon rep, and Marth...

...okay, I'm not a big fan of Marth, so Anna is pretty much replacing him as a face of the series. I mean she does appear in the most Fire Emblem games technically.

Still not sure who to vote for myself yet. I know who I'm NOT voting for, and that is Shortiecanbrawl.

It may seem hypocritical for voting for Blue last time(It was Wii Fit Trainer and lack of Yoshi, sorry guy), but I prefer my rosters with variety. Therefore this time I will be excluding Kon, Scatman and also Golden for their inclusions of Dillon, Meowth/Robin(selfish I know, but c'mon; Meowth!) and Duck Hunt Dog as well as Shortie...

Picking between the rest is going to be a lot harder...

Edit: Luma also gets a free pass due to Lyn this time. No one else considered her.
Edit 2: Angelglory also safe due to Lip.

My judging went with everybody having a perfect score. Lacking a certain character but they have another character from the series will get -.5. If the series does not have any character, then they get -1.

The lack of Captain Falcon and Villager cost you both -1. Bowser, Jigglypuff and Marth each lost -.5 because Toad, Meowth and Anna were there.

Either way, I choose Mario, DK, Yoshi, Link, Samus, Kirby, Fox, Pikachu, Marth, Captain Flacon, Ness, Villager, Olimar and Pit were in the poll because they were the main characters of their series. Peach and Zelda were in because they were the iconic females (and there was a round where only females could be added). Luigi and Jigglypuff are staples to the series so I put them. Bowser is the main Nintendo villain. Wario was just there because he was his own series and I needed another character.