Roy Vs. Ike

[Frank West]

I liked Roy better than Marth in melee, but he was basically just a more powerful clone of him. Now in Brawl Ike is nothing like Marth but in a way he served the same purpose as Roy. There is no room for 2 powerful Fire Emblem characters so Ike had to go.

 

[Demon_Fox]

I like Ike much better than Roy. I played FE Path of Radiance and FE Radiant Dawn so Ike pretty much won me over. Also Roy wasn't that different from Marth, thus Ike is a good replacement IMO.

 

[Falco (MOP)]

Ike is cool

But Roy was just as cool.

Personally, I think they should've kept Roy, but Ike is cool too

--MOP