Like I said, it's a sterotype, but there is no reason to favor melee fighters over sword fighters outside of this weird stigma the "community" has toward them. Like I also said, Soul Calibur is a thing. Fighting games don't have to use melee fighters, and Smash is already pretty much its own genre. "Being a fighting game" is not enough reason.
Hmm, maybe that wasn't a direct quote I saw then.
And the definition of "new" can vary from person to person. Like, to the laymen, they may not consider the Byleths very unique, but they are quite so even if they don't have a gimmick like "GO," Arsene, MP/Command Menu, or (to a lesser degree) Wonder Wing.
Well, the Heroes and Byleths make sense with the Heroes potentially being part of the DQ deal or at least a promotion. Banjo and Kazooie appeals to their fans though I would have liked if we got Banjo & Kazooie (and Tooie) on Switch as part of the deal. Not sure what Terry adds as...well, at this point, what does SNK have to offer? Then there's Joker. What benefit does Nintendo get with this one? A Warriors spin off? In return, Joker gets the crowning jewel for all the appearances Atlus pushes for him and gains the distinguish of getting a likely permanent boost to his remembrance as, even when Persona moves on from P5 (eventually), Joker's in Smash. Especially if he comes back.