POLL: Who is Ike replacing?

[ChaoticTH]

Marth or Roy?

IMO, I think it's Roy. Roy WAS the slower, yet stronger clone. It makes sense for Ike to be replacing him.

 

[bluekitsune13]

Dude, what is it with those stupid links to that other message board? Stop spamming!

 

[Wight]

its not replacement, they are independent. I dont think you can really compare them. But regardless, i think neither Marth nor Roy will be in. No matter how much I want Marth back in, i don't see it happening.

 

[ChaoticTH]

its not replacement, they are independent. I dont think you can really compare them. But regardless, i think neither Marth nor Roy will be in. No matter how much I want Marth back in, i don't see it happening.

But dude, Marth's sword is the ICON of Fire Emblem.

 

[NES n00b]

Marth was stronger. The Roy thing being stronger is just a myth. Marth does more damage in all of his attacks and his fsmash has more knockback if tippered.

Ike is replacing Roy, though.

 

[greenblob]

Marth will be in. Roy's chances, especially with Ike's inclusion, are slim.

 

[ChaoticTH]

Marth will be in. Roy's chances, especially with Ike's inclusion, are slim.

More like 0%, nerr.

 

[Ryuuseiken Marth]

None. Roy has room for originality with teh ph1r3(and Lyn is an assist trophy), and Marth has a DS game coming out.

 

[ChaoticTH]

None. Roy has room for originality with teh ph1r3(and Lyn is an assist trophy), and Marth has a DS game coming out.

T3H PHIRE lulz

 

[Brentos4o8]

None. Roy has room for originality with teh ph1r3(and Lyn is an assist trophy), and Marth has a DS game coming out.

Yeah since Marth will be in the DS game, I doubt he'll be out.
Roy was a main character in FE6 and related to FE7 cause of Eliwood but if he is cut, that's like cutting main character from the roster but not too major.

 

[Zeela12]

Ike is not replacing anyone, he's a new character, just like how falco not replacing fox from SSB.

whether marth and roy will be in brawl or not, no one can say much about it.

 

[ChaoticTH]

Ike is not replacing anyone, he's a new character, just like how falco not replacing fox from SSB.

whether marth and roy will be in brawl or not, no one can say much about it.

Good opinion... :o

 

[Tobi-]

I think if both Marth and Roy were still in, it'd be cool to have small face-offs.

Marth + Roy VS Ike + Link/MetaKnight!!

Deadly swordsman show-down.

 

[Mega Inkydog]

Roy being in/out does not really affect me much. But....

I really hope they take out Marth. I am extremely sick of Marth. And Ike not only looks very much like Marth, but has lots of the same moves and apparently Sakurai won't do clones. So him not getting his own character slot would please me a lot. I have nothing against the Fire Emblem character, but as a Smash Bros. fighter, he is obscenely annoying.

If they do put him, then tweak the crap out of him. The last thing I need is to online in Brawl to fight Marth 75% of the time, when there is 30+ other characters to use instead.

 

[TheMagicalKuja]

Ike is replacing Sigurd, get it right.

Sigurd will not be in Brawl. stop crying like pansies [/completely irrelevant]

 

[Razed]

obviously Roy. This shouldn't even be a thread.

 

[Fizz-sama]

Prz to be adding the Black Knight. :/

 

[Jumpinjahosafa]

Marth/Roy and Ikes moveset are differnt..

Why would Ike replace both of them?

 

[Shishou]

Marth won't be in. Not only does Ike have Blue hair and a similar appearance to Marth, but his sword is long and appears to show emphasis on the tip.

Roy I can see returning to use the moveset from Melee. Marth is not going to happen though, thanks to Ike. Plus Marth doesn't even look cooler than Ike or Roy, he was just the better character in Melee. Which would be no guarantee for Brawl as every character is changing in some shape. You really think they would put Marth in and keep him with his tip power, speed, and range? Think again.

 

[Shiny Ivysaur]

Answer: Neither