Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Yeah I know, but I'm sure whatever the PMBR makes would be... Miles better!
It may technically be eligible, but it being exclusive to a series of comic books that few people read or have any interest in makes it less worthy than the other video game based options in this video game celebrating the best characters in video games.
My bias is towards Links only.It may technically be eligible, but it being exclusive to a series of comic books that few people read or have any interest in makes it less worthy than the other video game based options in this video game celebrating the best characters in video games.
Also your text is green so you clearly have a bias.
Is Scourge green? Literally the only thing I know about him is that he's an AU version of Sonic. I don't even really play Sonic games. I'm just saying, for the sake of argument, I would count an AU of a character as eligible.
Not really. Scourge before was just a more jerky Sonic with a black jacket, shades and some boots. He didn't become his own identity until the Master Emerald gave him a paint job and blue contacts.
That's not a different model. They're sharing the same bones because that's a vertex hack. one that usually comes with resided animations, too. XDActually, the only major difference is that Classic Sonic's torso is about twice as big, and his legs shrink appropriately.
These two models are sharing the same bones. It needs some tweaking so that Classic Sonic's arms don't clip through his belly especially in some of the more extreme poses, but it all lines up rather well with the hurtboxes.
That's why my second option, that you've seemed to ave COMPLETELY skipped over ¦D;, was the Sonic that had all of his accessories from Adventure up to Black Knight. It's very easy to tell the two apart.
They're the same damn person. That's what I'M saying. XD
Oh wait, the ugly kid who was of no value or importance. I forgot he had a name.
Yeah, they said they'd release them in batches. I believe we should be getting some tomorrow.
For some reason I find it really off-putting that a Sonic storyline would do a take on The Killing Joke.Besides, the two have a struggle towards each other in regards tot heir personalities because of how different they are, but how easily they could turn out just like the other, which gets brought up at times by Sonic by him remembering Scourge taunting him with saying he knew the real reason he can't stand him.
You mean the kid who just stood there while the kokiri equivalent of the president was on the verge of death? I forgot about him too. Also, when did he EVER become a "likable fellow"? Even in the future he was a major ****.
In the future, he apologizes and wishes he could take it all back, entrusting you to tell his old friend that he should've treated him better. Of course, you are this friend. Hit me in the feels when I got there as a kid.
Completely off topic, but now that I think about it, Pokemon X & Y was full of Mido like characters. Mostly because they replaced most of the terrain roadblocks with people standing in front of you and saying you can`t go there.
I already stated how relevant this argument was pages ago when I suggested Scourge. If Link, Pit, Mario, and Luigi can have alternate color schemes based on their dark/rival counterparts, it isn't much of a stretch to say Sonic could use Scourge since they are the SAME person. It is completely pointless to argue the fact they have different personalities.
Fair enough. I still think it's more of a stretch considering that he'd have more model changes (assuming you're putting in things like the sharp teeth, scars, etc) than just the clothing and green color, but it's plausible. Dark Link may be totally different and look entirely the same, but he's really just a recolored Link. Mario/Luigi do the same thing. A green Sonic would be the equivalent, but I'm sure that's not something we're aiming for.
Now you are just nitpicking. And what this "we're" crap? Don't mistake your word for P:M's or anyone else for that matter. Also:
All I meant was that I don't think the P:M community wants a green Sonic recolor with a jacket. I figured this was a safe bet, so I said it. I'm not saying it's true because it's not what I want; I just thought it to be true. For that reason, I don't think it's nitpicking either...Now you are just nitpicking. And what this "we're" crap? Don't mistake your word for P:M's or anyone else for that matter. Also:
This happened. Scourge wasn't just a green Sonic before. He was "Evil Sonic". Relevant. And that even knocks out 2 colors. And another matter that bugs me. Anyone who can distinguish Melee Fox and Link from their Brawl varients can very well distinguish Sonic from his Soap Shoes varient. I don't want to hear excuses.
Will we also be getting Dry GigaBowser?
I like this decision, honestly. They're pretty different and I really don't think they look that great.
Who is being aggressive? Lol.. I'm just saying don't ASSUME things. That just makes an argument fall apart by simply not having solid proof to back up your point. And yes, you are nitpicking small details such as personality and model changes. They are irrelevant. It is a costume.
Great call if true.
I wonder if they returned GigaBowser to his Melee self
LIke no joke. The Shadow Queen render had to be created totally from scratch as well, and it's just...just so perfect. Dry Bowser's scratches and details and everything is just perfect. the PMBR rocks so much!
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, but this seems unnecessary.
I don't think I need compelling evidence to argue that people may not like a Scourge-ish recolor for Sonic, because it seems to miss the best of both Sonic and Scourge (not that I was saying I was totally right; it was at most a precautionary statement). I'm also pointing out that if we're keeping with the notion that it's a costume, it'd need to literally be the Sonic we know, or something that's a recolor of his Brawl self. That's the precedent. Call it nitpicking, but it's my argument since the Project Melee team is using Brawl as a base.
I would probably be fine with this; I thought that you meant it would just be Brawl Sonic with Soap Shoes. An Adventure-themed Sonic is probably enough to set it apart, especially with changes to the Brawl model. If not for that, though, I doubt you could tell the difference from a distance. Link and Fox have quite different color pallets, as stated. Take this as an anecdote, because that's what it is, but I've had models quite similar to Melee Fox and Link fight against their Brawl counterparts with no trouble, simply because you can see their differences by just their color. It's harder to do that with just shoes.
Yes, thank you. I want to talk about what the best thing is, so logic's welcome, but we can be cool about it.
