out of all the characters in melee which one does not deserve to come back the most

[NeoSoul]

jigglypuff, pichu, ice climbers, game and watch, young link, masterhand/crazy hand

 

[Pluvia's other account]

I posted this on the Brawl Manga topic, but it seems more suited here.

 

[Bassoonist]

jigglypuff, pichu, ice climbers, game and watch, young link, masterhand/crazy hand

Sure! Lets take out the unique characters and leave in Dr. Mario! Great idea.

 

[Fabiano]

Just the clones.. exept falco.

 

[ndm508]

I think that Mario guy should get kicked out. Trying to be all sweet with his stupid red hat and his overalls...

I mean who really even knows of the guy? I never heard of him. Not ever.



...yeah, kidding aside, Pichu sucks.

 

[Chickenboy666]

Dr Mario!!!!

 

[Pitbull]

I would have to say it's a tie between Pichu and Doc. Pichu doesnt deserve to be in Smash at all because the way I see it is that they could have picked any of the 400+ pokemon and they went with Pichu. That is a stupid choice considering hes just like Pikachu who is already in the game. Also, Doc shouldn't return because he is the same person as Mario which also supid. We need more variety in our characters!

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Fox and Marth...


I mean, they SUCKED

 

[PIT_IS_BACK]

Fox and Marth...


I mean, they SUCKED

QFTW XD hahahaha

 

[heety9]

Roy! I mean, he was only in one game!

 

[Yukiwarashi]

For all the Pichu bashers, I'm curious.

Who do you think represents the second generation of Pokemon best as a playable character, hm?

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

For all the Pichu bashers, I'm curious.

Who do you think represents the second generation of Pokemon best as a playable character, hm?

Marill or Topegi....seriously...


they were the ICONS of 2nd gen...


I could prob thing of something actually good as soon as I remember what the 2nd gens were

 

[Bassoonist]

I would have to say it's a tie between Pichu and Doc. Pichu doesnt deserve to be in Smash at all because the way I see it is that they could have picked any of the 400+ pokemon and they went with Pichu. That is a stupid choice considering hes just like Pikachu who is already in the game. Also, Doc shouldn't return because he is the same person as Mario which also supid. We need more variety in our characters!

Yeah and believe it or not there are people out there that want MORE electric rats in the game!

Yes, and Marill >>>>>>>>>> Pichu

 

[Devastlian]

I'm gonna have to go with Falco. Of all all the characters in Star Fox, they had to pick his ***** as to be in SSBM. They could've flashed forward into the future and put in Krystal or even kept with clone thing and put in an actually cool character like Wolf. :/

Also, that comic is inaccurate since Marth is all cocky and Roy is more heroic...<_<

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

I'm gonna have to go with Falco. Of all all the characters in Star Fox, they had to pick his ***** as to be in SSBM. They could've flashed forward into the future and put in Krystal or even kept with clone thing and put in an actually cool character like Wolf. :/

Krystal wasn't out when they made Melee

 

[Devastlian]

Hence why I said they could have "flashed forward into the future" like they did with Roy.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Hence why I said they could have "flashed forward into the future" like they did with Roy.

...They knew Roy was coming out...I'm not sure if they were planning on Krystal around that time...

 

[Bassoonist]

Falco should return... I liked him, and he's like the second most important character of the Star Fox series, right? Not saying that Krystal or Wolf shouldn't be playable, but why should we remove Falco?

 

[SirroMinus1]

mitsarugi from soul caliber 2

 

[Ekaru]

I'd say Roy. She is just a clone of Marth, and she has, unlike the other clones, no quality differences. What, two attack stronger? Everything else is slower and weaker, and she is lighter and slower.


Yes, I know Roy's a he. He looks like a girl though IMO. =P

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

mitsarugi from soul caliber 2

...he was never in the game...

 

[Devastlian]

Star Fox Adventures was shown at the same E3 SSBM was revealed at.

Falco's no more important than the other Star Fox team members, definately not as much as Andross or even Krystal. And Wolf is just as important as Falco and infinitely cooler.

 

[Bassoonist]

I'd say Roy. She is just a clone of Marth, and she has, unlike the other clones, no quality differences. What, two attack stronger? Everything else is slower and weaker, and she is lighter and slower.


Yes, I know Roy's a he. He looks like a girl though IMO. =P

I don't see how he looks like a girl. >_>

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

I don't see how he looks like a girl. >_>

Apparently he thinks any guy with Long hair looks like a girl...even though it's spiked...

 

[Rx-]

Fox, Captain Falcon, Link. They all need the axe. They are clones, and nobody uses them.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Fox, Captain Falcon, Link. They all need the axe. They are clones, and nobody uses them.

EXACTLY what I just said!!!!


...except I had Marth and not Link or Captain Falcon

 

[SirroMinus1]

Woot

I posted this on the Brawl Manga topic, but it seems more suited here.

this is FOR THE WIN!

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

this is FOR THE WIN!

Except I HAD Fire Emblem games before Melee...

 

[Bassoonist]

Marth's hair is ridiculously long in that comic. The creator must have thought Marth looked like a girl...

(I still don't understand that! -_-)

 

[sugarpoultry]

Ness needs to die. My opinion.

And the comic above... LOL FUNNY!!!!

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Ness needs to die. My opinion.

Well...that's not a very good opinion then...


...in fact it's a mean opinion

 

[shinkazenokizzu]

pichu and maybe mewtwo

 

[E-Jolteon]

Pichu hands down. I'm sorry, I like Pichu, he's got cute looks, but he's more useless that Pikachu is in the actual Pokemon games. Pikachu is awesome in Smash bros, in fact, my favorite, and my best next to Kirby. But in the actual games of Pokemon, he's quite sad, with low stats.

On that note, even though Pichus moves are almost exactly the same, between taking damage for his own attacks, and the horrible lack of strength that even Pikachu possesses, plus being what has too be the lightest character, his extra speed just isn't enough.

 

[sugarpoultry]

Well...that's not a very good opinion then...


...in fact it's a mean opinion

I would much rather see Sonic in Brawl than Ness. Even then, who knows if Sonic would make it in at all. I think Nintendo would be wise to bring in some characters that actually attract an audience. Ones we all know. I didn't even know about Ness until I saw Melee.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

I would much rather see Sonic in Brawl than Ness. Even then, who knows if Sonic would make it in at all.

Sonic and Ness aren't in competition...


Why are you even making that comparison?

 

[Bassoonist]

Ness needs to go because you don't like him?

Yay. I guess Sonic shouldn't appear in this game because I hate him!

 

[prettymanfairy]

That's a terrible excuse. I don't like Jigglypuff or the Ice Climbers, but they still deserve to come back.

 

[sugarpoultry]

Sonic and Ness aren't in competition...


Why are you even making that comparison?

Um.... its a preference, not a comparison. Read my post a little closer.....

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Um.... its a preference, not a comparison. Read my posts a little closer.....

Your saying Sonic should be in over Ness...


If anything SOnic will get in over another third Party...


Ness will only be out if LUCAS gets in...

 

[sugarpoultry]

Your saying Sonic should be in over Ness...

If anything SOnic will get in over another third Party...


Ness will only be out if LUCAS gets in...

I'm only saying that I like Sonic more than Ness. I never implied that Sonic is in any competition for a character slot with Ness. Anyway, even if Lucas doesn't make it in, you have zero proof that Ness will be returning. In case you haven't heard, not everyone from Melee will be making a return.