Sorry I've been pretty quiet. I've been finding it more difficult than I expected to have time to play during the day, and I'm struggling to catch up and keep all of the different personalities straight. Unfortunately, the way my days have ended up I'm probably not going to be able to do much more than a very quick phone posts now and then during the day but I'll try to post some larger posts at night.
Starting on some rereads, not sure if I'll get through everyone tonight but I'll try:
##Unvote
Sabrar:
My early suspicion of him largely centred around the fact that I am used to Sabrar being much more active and aggressive in the early game than I see him here, and I usually associate his passive play with being scum. Around #215 or so his content starts to pick up as he engages with UP. His reads on #309 look reasonable to me. I don't really buy his case on UP in #326, but it's at least plausibly motivated. Wiisp seems weirdly placed on his reads in #332 FMPOV and 3DS is astoundingly high, but overall I'm liking his content more than I did previously.
Putting him at a Town lean.
Re: #335
As I said, this is something I didn't really put a lot of thought into. My experience though is that such coaching is pretty limited and that too much coaching tends to lead to very stilted replies that would probably be detectable in other ways.
UP:
I liked the early energy and engagement. Returning to #94, my interpretation of this comment was the emoji posting was a hard null, and what he could glean from my actual commentary moved me slightly below null. This is a conservative approach but not much different from, e.g. pythag's response or Ran's.
UP's early suspicions on Sabrar seems to have been built heavily on (IMHO) misunderstanding Sabrar's opening post. This post is fairly typical opening Sabrar regardless of alignment, but I could see how it can be misconstrued. It bothers me more that UP is still pushing this point much later when Sabrar has more content and we're well out of RVS.
I don't like the naked vote on BoomFrog and the later backpedal. Townread on Maven is o.O
Overall... I'm liking UP a lot less than I was early in the game. Dropping them down to a scum lean.
BoomFrog:
Content is still light, which is not exactly out of character for Boom D1 especially if IRL is interfering. One of the few people to give a full-throated defense of 3DS. Tone feels townie to me, which is about all I have to go on at this point pretty much everything else I think could plausibly come from him as either Town or scum Boom. On tone, I lean slightly Town.
3DS:
I don't really feel like there's much more that needs to be said about him. I think it's fairly obvious that he's an impulsive newbie and I can see claim and the mistake on Wiisp could *possibly* have come from him as either alignment. I do think that his tone in #133, #139, and #140 (also #151 and several posts going forward that I won't bother to list) immediately after he was made aware of the slip (though it had been mentioned earlier he doesn't appear to have reading closely) looks very bad to me. I think most likely he is caught scum and I imagine I'll be voting for him at the end of this.
