ChikoLad
Purple Boi
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2014
- Messages
- 23,084
I don't think they're outdated at all.This site has mostly been superseded as far as Smasher usage goes by sites like Reddit, Discord and Twitter. But I'm sure it'll stick around for some more time. I think forums are outdated personally, like something that belongs to 2003 specifically, but they can have their place in a way. You've got TL;DR (long, long) posts for example. That's something you can't really do on IM because of how fast the conversation goes.
Reddit is good for your quick discussion fix or if you wanna see some cool pictures or videos. It also has the advantage of you only needing one account to interact with pretty much any community. But to do anything more expansive you have to link to external sites, which not only makes people less likely to read or view your content, but people can much more easily link to unsafe malware and the like. Also, the big issue I have with Reddit is the rampant abuse of the downvote button. The downvote button is supposed to be used to filter out useless posts that don't add to a discussion, or spam bots and blatantly toxic and offensive posts (like someone saying the "n" word or something to another poster). However, barely anybody uses it for that purpose. People just downvote the posts they disagree with. This encourages hive mind mentalities to an extreme, and perfectly valid opinions get buried just because they're not popular. Also, I find it very difficult to make anything resembling a friend or acquaintance on Reddit, but that may just be me. The site does downplay your personal identity, which can be either good or bad, but it's something forums don't really do.
Twitter has the obvious strict character limit, so right away it's not well-equipped for having proper discussions. It also has a terrible video player. Formatting is basically non-existent there too, since it's always fixed. It also has more limitations on the kind of media you can post. Twitter isn't a discussion medium, at least not by design. It's designed around exposure for yourself, or for a brand if it's a verified Twitter account.
Discord is pretty great and is actually the most valid alternative to traditional forums in my opinion, but being an IM service immediately gives it a different context. It's perfectly serviceable for holding lengthy discussions, but only on a smaller scale. Get into a gigantic Discord server and it's impossible for everyone to keep up a discussion because "SEVERAL PEOPLE ARE TYPING". In general, I always feel more of a pressure respond ASAP on Discord, because I get messages live.
Forums aren't completely real-time like Discord. They allow more verbose content and robust, custom formatting unlike Twitter. And they generally don't actively encourage hive minds and favour inherently popular and easy to digest content like Reddit. So I feel they more than have their place. Until virtual reality and/or holographic conference rooms become the standard, forums will always have a place.