Muster
Smash Lord
-he isn't changing the art style, he's updating it graphically, full models obviously couldn't be used in the ds games, compare toon link to his gcn counterpart. Using a blocky, tiny phantom model would just look unprofessional and lazyThe change from Chibi to full grown adult style is exactly what he's pointing at.
Changing art style for an Assist Trophy actually is something Sakurai stated he did not desire to do back in Brawl. Not only that but it goes against what assist trophies represent, which is representing the game they came from.
As for the reasoning why it does not look like TP guards its because this Zelda is not supposed to be "TP Zelda", otherwise she would not use things like Din's Fire or Nayru's Love. She's a representation of all Zeldas. If you wanted to represent Phantom Hourglass Zelda would you not include the same armor she uses in that game and adjust it to fit with the art style decided upon instead of using a completely different armor?
Also Sheik is not in TP. Just because Zelda puts on a face mask does not mean its Sheik.
Now, don't get me wrong, none of this means Sheik was cut or that the Phantom is a new move, there is no conclusive evidence yet but it does mean that your reasoning as to why it can't be a move is flawed.
I myself do believe it is a new move.
PS: Also someone care to give an explanation as to why Zelda is doing an specific pose while the Phantom attacks? No AT makes you do specific poses (after you've summoned it).
-Zelda never uses those spells in game, they're taken from link in Oot, and have stuck with zelda since melee which used her Oot art style. It's been a staple of her smash character, along with sheik.
-I said Shiek had a TP art style, not that she was a character in the game. Artwork was made for a TP style shiek so she can stay up to date with TP Zelda.
-It's her assist trophy summoning pose, not gonna copy and paste the pics again. why would she be using her pose for summoning an assist trophy when supposedly using a new move?