Nair vs. Nair: Parachute or Fishbowl?

[xX-LeaF-Xx]

I definitely like the melee parachute more, but it wouldn't work well in brawl.
But for the physics of brawl, the fishbowl works better.

 

[Needle of Juntah]

ive prolly said this but il prefer the parachute

if it was in the game GW might get himself banned though

 

[Tero.]

ive prolly said this but il prefer the parachute

if it was in the game GW might get himself banned though

I'm quite sure parachute wouldn't be better than the bowl.
Why do you think it would be so broken to get G&W banned?

 

[drunk3ng0ldfish]

I'm more of a multi-hit kind of guy. fishbowl ftw.

 

[Needle of Juntah]

I'm more of a multi-hit kind of guy. fishbowl ftw.

lol, it would be multi hit alright....

 

[A2ZOMG]

ya a2zomg, it was actually really good in melee. i think you forget that his dthrow popped people up low and could combo easily out of it. Also dtilt and up tilt were great for setups, along with just fastfalling it off the stage to edgeguard and putting a massive hitbox out for them to get around.

I specifically pointed out that you can D-throw -> N-air FASTFALLERS. D-tilt or U-tilt -> whatever is also pretty much limited to fastfallers.

Who cares about that? It doesn't work very well on anything floatier; Peach and Jigglypuff come to mind here. The three reasons G&W was terrible in Melee were because of bad defensive options, bad recovery, and poor combos.

 

[Taeran]

Utilt is just silly (hard to remember using them in melee)

G&W's new N-air by far is better than his old one. Especially when you consider the changes in game physics.

Brawl revolves around solid juggle traps to make up for the lack of true combos in this game. G&W's old N-air would not have been a very good juggle trap due to the hitbox coming out fairly slowly and not lasting all that long. G&W's new N-air is an amazing juggle tool on the other hand.

I actually, like to use a utilt chain (like mario's utilt) to launch for a juggle. It's hard to pull off but I like the extra 15-40 percent that comes with it, and a lot more from the nair juggle.

I agree with A2ZOMG on the juggle, and true combos do exist but are rare. Nair is much faster then chute and does 19%, and I earnestly can't remember what the % for the chute was.

And in all respects, if what lost our nearly ungimpable recovery I wouldn't even consider chute, because his recovery s one of the many reasons I play gaw.