Mini Mafia Game Thread | Newbies are welcome! | Town wins Gheb's game | Zen next to host!

[Ashemu]

btw one major reason im buying into horfs commentary on jdietrz is that when jditz was questoning me it felt townie but near the end there was an inkling of "this shuld be obvious from what ive been saying lol, when are u gonna come to the conclusion that im town instead of asking me **** that should be apparent from my post's" & now in behindsight im wandering if it wasnt actually town aggression, just scum trying for activity

 

[Ashemu]

also marshy.... do ur opinions basically mirror sword's so far?

 

[Jdietz43]

This was his intro post, for example. His stance on the Ash thing seems horrendous for the time, because if he was reading from a town POV id hear more about the "stuff" ash is "throwing out," and to be honest, aside from the tumblr shtick thing, I feel like his posts are reasonable and hard to misinterpret. Feels like a "going with the thread" stance to me, in fact he hasn't had to act on his own at all cuz you've been giving him stances to make, and it feels clear in his posts that that's his goal. Tis but a feel though.

Didn't see that coming ehh?

Maybe that'd be fair if the rest of thread had actually been there to talk about at that point, but as it was everything relevant was self evident and bounced off me by Orbo before I had anything unique to speak about. When you like 2/3 of the people who have posted so far and the third is already gone and null what else is there to say but to go to bed. (And thanks on the reasonable and hard to misinterpret thing, I'm legit working on it lol)

Jdietz how do you interpret me putting myself at L_1? Do you think I'm scum just trying to hardbody a townie in guise of an aggressive townie? Or maybe something else?

What about Kantrip's meta play keeps him null?

I took it as null, you could want it as either alignment, the point of my post was the fact that I didn't feel I had enough to work with from you to make a judgement call. I'm not calling you scum, but I also don't know why Gorf has you as a town read right now considering I don't remember any major contribution that wasn't idle chit chat.

Lol, how about every game Kantrip has ever played in. MMU for starters. I ain't reading shiz into a twitch plays pokemon joke entrance from that slot though I appreciate the effort Ash and later Gorf attempted with it.

btw one major reason im buying into horfs commentary on jdietrz is that when jditz was questoning me it felt townie but near the end there was an inkling of "this shuld be obvious from what ive been saying lol, when are u gonna come to the conclusion that im town instead of asking me **** that should be apparent from my post's" & now in behindsight im wandering if it wasnt actually town aggression, just scum trying for activity

Why, because I asked you if your democracy comment was serious after you already tried to say it could have scum intent? At that point I wanted to see if you even realized it was a reference, I already awknowleded the probable town intent.

 

[Jdietz43]

I feel like Kantrip/Dietz should be looked at. Either way ash sword and orbo have already proven themselves fine enough in my book, maybe not orbo but the other two are kinda glowing with obvtown.

Are people really town reading JDietz after last page?

@underlined: What about Swords screamed to you obvtown at that point? He barely even interacted with anyone beyond the self vote. He didn't scream scum but I'm not seeing a scream for town either.

 

[Jdietz43]

(in this thread, Dietz doesn't read when questions have already been asked)

It's your posts mostly.

Okay, way more specific than this needed if I'm going to take that stance as is. Is this meta-based?

 

[Ashemu]

ok dietz
so orbo and i are town
kant is null because he played badly once and is immune to all criticism
swords is weird but you're "not calling him scum"

whos mafia?

 

[Jdietz43]

We'll find out once Kant comes back, Gorf responds, and Ryu starts posting.

 

[Jdietz43]

Also Swords is not "weird", his actions were null. Those two things are very very different.

 

[Orboknown]

Dietz
Swords had marshy replace in because he rolled scum y/n?
(In all aspects this is a null action but I want to see your thoughts for a sec)

 

[Jdietz43]

Dietz
Swords had marshy replace in because he rolled scum y/n?
(In all aspects this is a null action but I want to see your thoughts for a sec)

No, not here. There wasn't even any pressure on Swords at the time, and especially not for a Marshy replacement in particular.

 

[Orboknown]

Kay. T'ank ye for the answer

 

[Jdietz43]

Like since when has anyone called in Marshy to make their slot look more town...

Just sayin'

(marshy don't hurt me)

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Dietz town so far Ryu.

Given what you said later that Gorf pointed out why?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

swords response to me is good & gorfs aight. i feel like if we shoot kant/ryu and dietz as backup wed win, i thought dietz looked townmotivated but gorfs thing on him is p good actually.

i dont like ryu's questions theyre meekly worded and dont rly press people and itd be better for him to talk about opinions.... like is orbos dietz read actually going to help u? i already asked pota to clarify about his democracy pots and if ryu wanted to read him their were a lot of better question too be asked instead of clarification. it just seems soulles & empty if you compare it 2 dietzs' pressure on me earlier in the thread

also if you know who i am then who am i lmao

the 1 thing that worries me is that eth ppl i suspect arent actually doing anything, at all, id think scum would be trying harder ~_~

Harder to sink me teeth, sucks but trying to avoid, "omg unwarrented town reads **** you Ruy." If I do, I make sure there is an internal reason outside of a lot of emotional tells I used to do.

Marshy/Swords is the only one I absolutely trust.

I'm a little bother that Deitz/Kantrip is the preferred shots considering people seen to be throwing away the others off a bandwagon. Kantrip I think has merit. I don't see why Dietz is a preferred shot.

 

[Ashemu]

who does your intuition tell you is town and why, even if youre not willing to listen to it?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Dietz/Swords/Ashemu

 

[Ashemu]

"and why" maybe learn 2 read.....

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

@underlined: What about Swords screamed to you obvtown at that point? He barely even interacted with anyone beyond the self vote. He didn't scream scum but I'm not seeing a scream for town either.

It's just how sword is. It's... kinda hard to misread em as town.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Dietz is more carefree and seems interested in reading people.

I like you because you have a clear flow that doesn't look like a scum mindset, no where did I see you try and use it in a malicious method, can't see it off this.

I'm wondering if you will answer my previous question and why you wanted my "No logic" reads.

 

[Ashemu]

if ur gonna talk about how you have intuition-based "twon reads" its helpfull to hear youre thought process behind them bc if your scum you have to make 1 up, gut hapens for a reisen usually. and that can be put intoo words.

im interested in hearing why you think detz is "carefree", im not seeing it. is this just compaired to his usual play?

i dont see why i should talk about prev mafia experience if u claim to know who i am (u never ealborated on that btw) but ive been playing for multiple year's

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I can't help but laugh at ashemu's posts

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Possible I am wrong about that, but I am pretty sure you're an alt of another DGamer. But if not this can confirm if you are or not if you don't reference anything or let me know of anything.

 

[Ashemu]

liek i said my ip wont match up and im not using a proxy, youre free 2 believe i flew to california just to make a convincing alt acc though

 

[Ashemu]

ive played with othr dgamers before tho :>

 

[Ashemu]

horf-kun what do you think of ryu atjm???

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I ain't diggin em, but at this point it's about as much as I ain't diggin kantrip, and that's mostly because I feel good about my reads on you/orbo/nameless

 

[Orboknown]

Given what you said later that Gorf pointed out why?

Just how he feels to me. I read dietz a lot like I read rake-when we are lining up and I can feel the thought process flowing I can be confident he is town. Thats what is happening here.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

My v/la continues into tomorrow.

Sorry about this, but I work another full day and more hw. Life and all.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

btw one major reason im buying into horfs commentary on jdietrz is that when jditz was questoning me it felt townie but near the end there was an inkling of "this shuld be obvious from what ive been saying lol, when are u gonna come to the conclusion that im town instead of asking me **** that should be apparent from my post's" & now in behindsight im wandering if it wasnt actually town aggression, just scum trying for activity

This is possible, do you consider he may have of not realized this as town?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Just how he feels to me. I read dietz a lot like I read rake-when we are lining up and I can feel the thought process flowing I can be confident he is town. Thats what is happening here.

What would be a counter example if you don't think they are town?

 

[Orboknown]

What would be a counter example if you don't think they are town?

One of the last minis I played in before leaving for basic rake ended up being mafia while dietz and I were both town. Also toonami. Its been about since then since I was the opposite alignment of either of them in a queue game

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

One of the last minis I played in before leaving for basic rake ended up being mafia while dietz and I were both town. Also toonami. Its been about since then since I was the opposite alignment of either of them in a queue game

Misworded, more so what would you look for if they didn't sync with you? Like if they are scum in a game, what would you look for?

 

[Orboknown]

Honestly the easiest way to tell is if we disagree on something, the way they explain themselves. Its a thought process and vibe most of the time

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

@ #HBC | Gorf : Tell me about what in particular got you to like Sworddancer/Marshy and Orbo?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

It's their posts mostly.

 

[Ashemu]

so did kant baisicaly flake wtf

jditz couldve missed my posts as town but i generaly think town should be paying more attention than that if theyre putting effort into the game!!! when i answer a question by linking to a previous post and then get asked sometihng i already answred at the start of the game it makes me wonder if the duder pressurnig me is actually paying attention 2 my posts lol.

gorf's responses have mostly been one-liners which dont rly delve into his thought process, kinda bugs me caus it contrasts w/ teh efort he had when he first enterd the thread
ryo still iffy, the "i dont watn ppl to go off on me for dubm townreads" thing couldve been town but when he expanded on it it didnt rly imperss me.... when somebody has werid gut townreads theyre unsure about i woudlnt expect them to be the exact same townreads everyone else has lmao

feel like we should have less questions rn and more "this guy is scumym" & genuine violence lets shoot some mother****ers
id still like to read a marshy post especailly since dancer is busy

 

[Ashemu]

i mean u guys paint aknt like the village idiot, if he was town id expect him too get in here and run his mouth off, instead he lies low after the ****ty start and doesnt really do much while around..... p lame of him if hes town cuz some ppl were null on him and the game definitly woudlve progressed more if we had his thought's

i dont know hisschedule though.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

They aren't gut reads.

Another one liner

 

[Ashemu]

yea i was takling about ryu, unless youre speaking for him

 

[Orboknown]

How do you expect us to get reads without votes to wagon with? Better way of putting it, what should we be doing instead of asking qs ash?