Just a thought on GAW's Judge Side Special

[Deleted member]

Why don't they make it so that when you get a 1 while in the air, it restores your jump, much like how Captain Falcon/Ganon get theirs restored after a Falcon Kick/Wizard Foot?

Would that be to OP? I mean it's 1/9 chance to get it, and that's sort of justification for taking 12% damage from getting a 1. What do you guys think about this?

 

[Rᴏb]

Seems kinda pointless, and way too risky to ever be worth attempting. If you wanna give G&W a better recovery, I say let him airdodge after upb.

 

[Metmetm3t]

When Captain Falcon uses Down-B to restore his jump he sacrifices all of his vertical positioning. There's an obvious risk reward involved. If 1 hammer for some reason gave G&W a jump he would not be giving up the same vertical aspect. He could use it while double jumping to not lose any height at all.

Plus G&W's recovery is already solid so any buff even an unlikely one to that game is unnecessary and takes away from the depth of edge guarding him.

On top of that you hurt the aesthetics of the move. The one hammer has always been completely useless and if feels justified by the way that the 9 hammer is so overpowered and how the 7 hammer is a healing move.

This change would only add unnecessary complications to what is already the most complicated (and worst) move in the game.

 

[br8k]

Adding a 1/9 chance to recover from normally unrecoverable situations?

That's infuriatingly dumb. I don't think we should increase the luck factor in this game.

 

[Oracle]

one needs to make the luigi dtilt honk noise

 

[Deleted member]

Lol, just throwing out so ideas.